When “well-led” is not enough: the Mann Review and the duty of public-purpose boards

18 September 2026

Professor Andrew Corbett-Nolan and Dr Anna Barnes argue that if an organisation can be rated well-led and still fail its own staff, that is a failure of governance.

 

Key points

- The review tests how the NHS answers for racism.

- A well-led rating is no proof of a healthy culture.

- Employers, not regulators, carry the first duty to act.

- Every public-purpose board faces the same test.

 

The National Health Service rests on a governance promise as much as a service one: that care is given according to need, and that neither patients nor staff should have to conceal who they are in order to be safe. 

Lord John Mann’s review of antisemitism and other forms of racism in the NHS and the healthcare regulatory system, published on 4 June 2026, tests that claim and finds it unmet. Government and NHS England accepted the recommendations directed at them. The remaining question is the extent to which boards are implementing the report and recalibrating what accountable leadership now requires.

Mann Review key points

  • The Mann Review is a system-governance inquiry into how the NHS and health regulators identify, report and sanction antisemitism and other racism.
  • It was commissioned in October 2025 by the Secretary of State for Health and Social Care and the Prime Minister, after evidence that Jewish patients were uneasy about seeking care and Jewish staff did not trust the system to protect them.
  • Lord Mann, the government’s Independent Adviser on Antisemitism, frames the problem in Macpherson terms: collective institutional failure, expressed through process, attitude and behaviour.
  • Organisations can be rated good under the “well-led” domain while minority staff experience and progression remain poor. That finding should unsettle any board that treats the rating as proof of culture.
  • NHS employers, not regulators, are the first line of defence. Boards own prevention, investigation, data and consequence.
  • Accepted measures include staff standards, NHS Oversight Framework scoring, mandatory training for chairs and chief executives, stronger Care Quality Commission use of well-led, clearer definitions, and reporting to Parliament.
  • The same tests apply to public-purpose boards beyond the NHS: purpose, assurance, definitions, speaking up, and implementation through organisational change.
  • In GGi governance and developmental well-led reviews, equality, diversity and inclusion are examined as part of whether an organisation is genuinely well led.

What the Mann Review is

The review asked two operational questions. First, how are perpetrators of antisemitism and other racism held to account across NHS employment and professional regulation? Second, how are patients and staff kept safe from racism in that system?

It examines trusts, integrated care boards, arm’s-length bodies, NHS England, the Department of Health and Social Care, the Care Quality Commission, the General Medical Council and other professional regulators. Antisemitism is named specifically because it has been under-recognised. Most recommendations, nevertheless, address racism in all its forms. 

Why the review was commissioned

The commission in October 2025 followed “multiple cases of intolerable antisemitism” in healthcare, including high-profile concerns involving registered professionals. It preceded the Heaton Park synagogue attack of 2 October 2025 and later attacks on Jewish communities, including in Golders Green in April 2026. Those events intensified public urgency around an under-recognised underlying problem.

The July 2025 Commission on Antisemitism, co-chaired by Lord Mann and Dame Penny Mordaunt, had already identified a distinct NHS failure: Jewish patients delaying or avoiding care and Jewish staff who did not believe discrimination against them would be addressed. That finding sat on a wider evidential base. King’s Fund analysis of the NHS Staff Survey has shown racism becoming normalised. In the 2025 survey, 11% of Jewish staff and 16% of Muslim staff reported discrimination from patients or the public; 13% of both groups reported discrimination from managers or colleagues. More than 20% of Black and minority ethnic staff reported discrimination from patients or the public, compared with 5% of White staff. Jewish staff were the only religious group for whom colleague-on-colleague discrimination was rising. The 2024 Brap report Too Hot to Handle, NHS Race and Health Observatory research, and the Care Quality Commission inpatient survey results show the same pattern on the patient side: lower trust and, in some groups, a reasoned fear of unequal treatment.

National hate-crime data supplied the civic context. Religious hate crime has risen sharply; Jewish people face, proportionately, the highest recorded religious hate-crime rate of any group. Community Security Trust and Tell MAMA totals have been among the highest on record. The NHS is not a sealed system. It is a public institution operating inside that climate, with a higher duty because people cannot easily choose another hospital when they are ill. We also know from what staff have told us on several well-led reviews that the rise of far-right agitation and the recent epidemic of flags appearing in localities have made NHS staff from ethnic minorities increasingly edgy.

Lord Mann and the design of the mandate

John Mann, Baron Mann of Holbeck Moor, was Labour Member of Parliament for Bassetlaw from 2001 to 2019. In 2019 he left the Commons, took a peerage, and became the United Kingdom government’s Independent Adviser on Antisemitism, a post created under Theresa May and continued thereafter. He is a long-standing campaigner on antisemitism and brought that mandate, rather than a health-management career, to the review.

The choice of reviewer is part of the governance story. A conventional health inquiry might have produced a more internally NHS document. The government asked the holder of a cross-government antisemitism brief to inspect employment practice, professional regulation and board accountability at speed. A first tranche of his recommendations was already inside the March 2026 consultation on General Medical Council reform, including appeals and Professional Standards Authority oversight of Medical Practitioners Tribunal Service decisions. The June report is therefore not an isolated essay but part of a wider, ongoing regulatory reform programme.

Findings that should disturb a board

Three high-level conclusions belong on every public-sector and public-purpose board agenda:

  1. The service is already failing some of the people it exists to serve
    The review records Jewish patients putting off or avoiding treatment and Jewish staff who feel routinely excluded and are considering leaving. This is a failure of the core duty: equal access to care and a safe workplace. If people hide their religion or ethnicity in order to be treated or to come to work, the organisation is not meeting the purpose it claims.
  2. Boards and regulators can give themselves false assurance.
    Some organisations rated “good” for well-led still had poor results for minority ethnic staff experience, development and promotion. A favourable leadership rating can therefore sit alongside evidence that leadership is not working for a significant part of the workforce. Boards should not treat a well-led judgement as proof of a healthy culture. They should set that judgement beside staff-survey results, progression data, complaints and speaking-up outcomes, and explain any gap.
  3. The employer carries the first duty to act.
    What regulators do matters, and the review is clear that professional regulation of racism has been inconsistent. That does not transfer day-to-day responsibility away from the board. Protecting staff and patients is an employment and service duty. If the organisation’s own data already show discrimination, waiting for a regulator to intervene is a misunderstanding of who is accountable.

What boards are now expected to do

The recommendations are essentially practical and cohere around a small number of key actions for both individual NHS boards and the wider NHS:

  • Treat tackling racism, including antisemitism, as a core organisational priority rather than a delegated inclusion workstream.
  • Prepare for NHS staff standards on racism and for composite scoring in the NHS Oversight Framework, with consequences. 
  • Ensure chairs and chief executives of provider trusts complete mandatory training on antisemitism, anti-racism and Macpherson principles within six months.
  • Put measurable anti-racism objectives into senior appraisals.
  • Use staff-survey racism metrics, Workforce Race Equality Standard-type data and incident data in the board and the relevant committee, and act on outliers.
  • Adopt the International Holocaust Remembrance Alliance working definition of antisemitism and the government’s definition of anti-Muslim hostility.
  • Apply forthcoming national guidance on uniforms and politicised identifiers, on violence prevention, and on when incidents require regulatory referral.
  • Close data gaps, including consultation on recording Jewish and Sikh identity in protected-characteristic datasets, so that boards are not assuring what they cannot see.
  • Expect the Care Quality Commission, with the Department of Health and Social Care, to inspect equality performance for patients and staff more searchingly under well-led.
  • Track implementation through restructure and redundancy so that “reset” does not become a euphemism for lost attention.

NHS England has accepted the recommendations directed at it, committed to the seven anti-racism principles of the NHS Race and Health Observatory, and instructed boards to understand their racism data and to communicate action to staff, patients and communities. Government will report to Parliament, with an initial update by October 2026 and a full report within 12 months of publication.

Well-led as a false comfort

The well-led framework is intended to test culture, governance, improvement and system working as one system. If an organisation can be judged well-led while significant groups of staff report discrimination, stalled progression and little confidence in speaking up, the framework is being applied as narrative rather than as empiricism. In other words, if an organisation can receive a "well-led" rating even though many staff members say they experience discrimination, cannot progress in their careers, and do not feel safe raising concerns, then the assessment process is relying more on a story about good leadership than on actual evidence.

That is why independent developmental reviews matter. In GGi governance and developmental well-led reviews we routinely include consideration of equality, diversity and inclusion: not as a discrete section bolted onto an otherwise conventional assessment of finance, quality and risk, but as evidence about whether purpose, culture, speaking-up arrangements, workforce data and board behaviour describe the same organisation. After Mann, that integration is non-negotiable. A board that discusses racism only in the people committee and strategy only in the boardroom has already partitioned the issue it claims to own.

Reviewers and boards should therefore ask whether staff-survey metrics, employee-relations cases, complaints, fitness-to-practise referrals and patient-experience data are triangulated in one conversation; whether Jewish, Muslim, Sikh and other groups are statistically visible; and whether a comfortable self-assessment survives contact with grievance outcomes and career-progression data.

Purpose, values and contested issues

Public-purpose boards outside the NHS will err if they think of the Mann Review as a health service circular. Universities, schools, local authorities, housing associations, regulators, royal colleges and major charities face the same test: can people use the service, work in it, or depend upon it without negotiating their identity as a condition of safety?

The Seven Principles of Public Life (Nolan Principles) apply here. Accountability requires that leaders own outcomes, not intent statements. Openness requires that data gaps are disclosed. Leadership requires that chairs and chief executives complete the training, set the objectives and accept consequences. Objectivity requires that antisemitism is not immediately reframed in terms that would not be applied to other racisms.

Few issues are more liable to capture a board than those at the junction of identity, geopolitics and lawful speech. The institutional temptation is false neutrality: to treat every complaint as an equal and opposite political claim and therefore to do nothing that can be characterised as taking a side. That is not impartiality. It is an abdication of the duty to keep people safe. Boards need an agreed approach for symbols, social media, uniforms, visiting speakers and staff networks that is developed before the next incident. Parity of protection is not achieved by averaging grievances. It is achieved by consistent definitions, consistent process and consistent consequences.

Independent review is itself an instrument. Mann’s model (rapid external mandate, published findings, formal acceptance, regulatory follow-through and parliamentary reporting) is only as good as implementation. Local boards should ask what they must now do because the national system requires it and what they should commission themselves because their own data already justify it.

The risks are not just reputational. Patients who defer care generate later service demands. Staff who leave take scarce capacity with them. Tribunals convert cultural failure into financial exposure. Regulatory action under a strengthened, well-led domain is a licence issue, not a communications issue. These belong on the board assurance framework as quality and safety, workforce, regulatory compliance, public confidence and equality of access.

In our well-led and culture reviews we have seen staff broken and careers wrecked, both by those who have experienced harassment and those who are accused of it. It is a false economy to sweep such issues under the carpet.

Antisemitism and racism more broadly are experienced by staff from other staff and, equally troubling, from the patients themselves. This is doubly challenging, as these forms of racism require a different response. We know, for instance, in inpatient wards that zero tolerance is extremely difficult to maintain from patients who, it could be argued, lack capacity.

Questions for the next board meeting

Board members should consider:

  • Do racism and antisemitism sit on the board assurance framework, and if so, who is the executive owner?
  • Which committee sees the data, and when did the full board last interrogate these issues thoroughly?
  • Can we see Jewish, Muslim, Sikh and other groups in workforce and patient datasets, or are we governing by proxy averages?
  • Would we still call ourselves well-led if we published staff experience by group beside our rating?
  • Have we adopted the relevant definitions, and can HR and complaint handlers apply them?
  • What happens, and how fast, when a staff member or patient reports racial or religious abuse?
  • Do staff networks have a route to the board?

Conclusion

Lord Mann’s central claim is a governance claim: Jewish people, and everyone else who uses or staff a public service, must be confident of receiving the same treatment at all times in all situations. If that confidence is absent, the institution’s purpose has already failed, whatever its rating.

Boards that confine their response to a noted paper and an updated equality plan will have missed the point. The review asks whether leadership ratings, assurance packs and regulatory judgements describe the organisation as staff and patients experience it. Where they do not, the failure is not “EDI.” It is governance. In GGi’s reviews, equality, diversity and inclusion are already part of that test. After Mann, they cannot be the part done politely and last. Implementation will be the measure. Parliament has been promised an account. Patients and staff will supply another.

Frequently asked questions

What is the Mann Review?
An independent review by Lord John Mann, published 4 June 2026, of how the NHS and UK healthcare regulators recognise, report and respond to antisemitism and other forms of racism, with recommendations on leadership, data, training, investigations and regulation.

Who commissioned it, and why?
The Secretary of State for Health and Social Care and the Prime Minister, in October 2025, after evidence of serious antisemitism in healthcare and after the 2025 Commission on Antisemitism had already flagged NHS-specific harm to patients and staff.

Who is Lord Mann?
A Labour former MP, member of the House of Lords, and the government’s Independent Adviser on Antisemitism since 2019. He was asked because the problem sits at the junction of national hate-crime policy, public-service employment and professional regulation.

What must NHS boards do now?
Use racism data at board and committee level; prepare for staff standards and Oversight Framework scoring; adopt the stated definitions; ensure chairs and chief executives complete mandated training; strengthen investigations and referrals; and expect closer well-led scrutiny of equality performance.

Why does this matter to boards outside the NHS?
Any public-purpose organisation that claims universal or equitable service faces the same tests of purpose, assurance, definitions and consequence. The well-led mismatch is a general warning about comfort ratings that do not match lived experience.

Principal sources

  • Lord Mann, Review of antisemitism and other forms of racism in the NHS and healthcare regulatory system (Department of Health and Social Care, 4 June 2026).
  • Department of Health and Social Care, government response and press notice, 4 June 2026.
  • NHS England, letter to chief executives, publication reference PRN02538, 4 June 2026.
  • House of Commons, statement on the Mann Review, 4 June 2026.
  • Commission on Antisemitism report, July 2025.
  • NHS Staff Survey 2025; King’s Fund analysis; Brap, Too Hot to Handle (2024); NHS Race and Health Observatory publications; CQC adult inpatient survey 2025.
  • Consultation on the draft General Medical Council Order, March 2026.
  • CQC and NHS England well-led framework guidance.

Dr Anna Barnes

Principal consultant

Find out more

Andrew Corbett-Nolan

Chief executive and senior partner

Find out more

Prepared by GGI Development and Research LLP for the Good Governance Institute.

Enquire about this article

Enquire
Contact us