Well-led, revisited
17 September 2026
Four years after the introduction of the CQC’s single assessment framework, GGi director Joanna Watson predicts possible changes in developmental well-led reviews
Points raised in this article:
- CQC proposes seven new well-led KLoEs from 2027
- The new framework closely resembles the pre-2023 model
- Risk, performance and assurance receive greater prominence
- Independent well-led reviews remain an important source of assurance
NHS Improvement’s 2017 guidance strongly encouraged NHS providers to undertake independent developmental well-led reviews every three to five years. That guidance still stands today – and right now well-led reviews are more important than ever.
A bit of history
Monitor, the original regulator for NHS foundation trusts, advocated regular reviews of governance, including board and committee structures, modelled on best-practice UK corporate governance principles. Back in 2015, there were four domains for well-led governance reviews and below these, ten questions.
In June 2017 NHS Improvement (successor to Monitor, now part of NHS England) published their guidance for NHS trusts and NHS foundation trusts on developmental reviews using the well-led framework. This set out eight key lines of enquiry (KLoEs) to answer the overall question “are services well led?”:
- W1 Leadership capacity and capability
- W2 Vision and strategy
- W3 Culture
- W4 Governance and management
- W5 Managing risk, issues and performance
- W6 Information
- W7 Public, staff and external partner engagement
- W8 Learning, improvement and innovation
The CQC single assessment framework was introduced in January 2023, and this included eight quality statements. Four years ago this month, I wrote an article about the change and how the previous KLoEs mapped to the proposed quality statements.
I wrote at the time that there was a shift of emphasis, with organisations encouraged to take ownership of the areas, as the quality statements all being “we”. For example, “we have a shared vision, strategy and culture”. The eight quality statements for the well-led question are:
- Shared direction and culture
- Capable, compassionate and inclusive leaders
- Freedom to speak up
- Workforce equality, diversity and inclusion
- Governance, management and sustainability
- Partnerships and communities
- Learning, improvement and innovation
- Environmental sustainability – sustainable development
Four years later
In March 2026, following the CQC’s ‘better regulation, better care’ consultation, four draft sector-specific assurance frameworks were published. These cover:
- Adult social care
- Mental health care
- Primary care and community services
- Hospitals
This recognises that leadership, culture, governance and quality assurance need to be assessed differently in different parts of health and social care.
The consultation closed in June 2026, and it seems likely that the frameworks will be finalised in early 2027. If adopted substantially as proposed, we envisage that developmental well-led reviews will evolve to reflect the new key lines of enquiry.
The headline change
Currently, the assessment framework describes well-led as follows:
“There is an inclusive and positive culture of continuous learning and improvement. This is based on meeting the needs of people who use services and wider communities, and all leaders and staff share this. Leaders proactively support staff and collaborate with partners to deliver care that is safe, integrated, person-centred and sustainable, and to reduce inequalities.
“There are effective governance and management systems. Information about risks, performance and outcomes is used effectively to improve care.’”
The draft assessment frameworks use the same well-led description across all four sectors and are much more concise:
“The leadership, management and governance of the service make sure it's providing high-quality care that's based around your individual needs, that it encourages learning and innovation, and that it promotes an open and fair culture.”
The KLoEs
Each framework also includes the same seven KLoEs:
- Strategic direction
- Workforce equity and culture
- Capable and compassionate leaders
- Governance
- Management of risk, performance and issues
- Partnerships and communities
- Improvement, innovation and learning
For each KLoE there is a summary of the topic areas included together with a description of what outstanding, good, requires improvement and inadequate look like.
What’s changed?
When comparing the proposed KLoEs with the quality statements, the most obvious changes are that two topics no longer have their own section:
- Freedom to Speak Up, which is now part of workforce equity and culture
- Environmental sustainability, which is now within strategic direction
Meanwhile, governance, management and sustainability has been split, with governance separated from risk management and performance. This reflects the breadth of the previous quality statement, which meant that this was almost always the longest section in one of our reports because of all that it covered. Given the challenges faced in leading NHS organisations, the greater prominence given to assurance, performance and risk management is very welcome.
Overall, it is interesting to see that the draft 2026 well-led KLoEs compare very closely to the pre-2023 model:
The introduction of different assessment frameworks for different sectors highlights that the characteristics and evidence required for different settings will be different. GGi’s well-led reviews are always tailored to individual organisations, and the frameworks confirm this approach.
The continued importance of well-led reviews
Independent, developmental well-led reviews are arguably more important than ever. While in the past they were considered good practice, they now provide helpful evidence for the assessment team when considering whether a trust should be approved as an advanced foundation trust. NHS England's Advanced Foundation Trust Programme guidance now references independent governance reviews as a source of assurance.
For trusts not yet in the assessment process, they provide valuable insight into the trust’s strengths and development areas and set out the key areas to be progressed.
How GGi can help
GGi is continuing to develop its approach to developmental well-led reviews, including ensuring that evidence supports the new KLoEs as well as the existing quality statements.
- Well-led review – GGi will work with you through a developmental review of your leadership and governance, supporting you to provide high-quality care.
- Rapid assessment – GGI is here to help you prepare for regulator inspections. For NHS trusts and foundation trusts, our CQC preparation offer can start as soon as you receive notification of an inspection and support you with mock interviews, narrative development, board workshops and more.
- Workshops – We run board workshops or briefing sessions to help your organisation adjust to a changing regulatory landscape.
If you’d like to find out more about any of these services, or you’d just like to discuss the impending changes, please get in touch.