Are quality committees strengthening assurance or creating activity?

12 May 2026

Normi Cadavieco wonders what would change if your quality committee disappeared tomorrow

 

Points raised in this article:

- Do quality committees make a difference – and should they?

- Quality committees often drift from assurance to activism

- In trying to make a difference, committees sometimes undermine themselves  

- The solution is to balance activism and assurance and ask yourself the right questions

 

In recent discussions with colleagues and clients, alongside the work we’ve been doing on quality assurance, an interesting question has kept coming up: do quality committees actually make a difference, and more importantly, should they?

On paper, the answer feels straightforward. Quality committees are established as committees of the board, with a delegated role to receive and provide assurance on its behalf. But that’s a very rigid interpretation and one that doesn’t reflect what we know about how governance actually works in practice. Governance is not just structure; it’s behaviour, culture and how people engage with the system they are part of.

If people feel that they are simply feeding a bureaucratic process by producing papers, reporting metrics or attending meetings that don’t meaningfully influence anything, engagement inevitably drops. And when engagement drops, so does the quality of what is being reported. Information becomes performative rather than insightful. Risk is managed upwards rather than understood. Assurance becomes something that is presented, rather than something that is tested.

This is where the idea of 'quality committee activism' emerges. It is, in many ways, a reaction to perceived passivity. Committees push harder, ask more questions, get closer to the detail, and want to see and feel what is happening on the ground. Instinctively, that feels right. It feels like impact.

Making a difference

So should quality committees make a difference? Absolutely. And not just as a byproduct of their formal delegated role. They should be a critical part of how organisations understand quality, risk and performance. They should shape the questions that get asked, the conversations that are had and the confidence – or lack of it – that is surfaced to the board.

But what we often see in practice is a drift towards activism at the expense of assurance. Quality committees can step further into operational territory, focusing on detail rather than insight and inadvertently duplicating the role of management rather than holding it to account.

The issue is not that committees look at operational information – this is essential. Quality, safety and experience are lived operationally before they are reported strategically. The issue is whether that information is being used in a way that supports the committee’s role: to test assurance, understand risk, identify patterns, and provide the board with a clear line of sight to what really matters.

When that does not happen, the impact can be more superficial than it appears. There is activity, but not necessarily clarity. More questions, but not always better ones. A sense of grip, without necessarily a stronger understanding of quality and risk.

This brings to mind a quality committee I observed that spent 45 minutes of a scheduled two-hour meeting discussing pressure ulcers. The topic itself was entirely appropriate. Pressure ulcers can be a serious indicator of care quality, patient safety, patient experience and wider system pressures. But the discussion did not focus on what the pattern of incidents was telling the committee, whether the controls were working, whether there were gaps in assurance, or what this meant for the board’s confidence in the quality of care.

Instead, the conversation became absorbed in painstaking operational and clinical-level detail. The detail itself was important – it had a legitimate place in clinical improvement, operational learning and day-to-day management. But at the committee level, the question needed to be different: what did this tell members about the quality of care, the effectiveness of controls, and the level of confidence the board could reasonably take?

The irony is that in trying to make more of a difference, committees can weaken the very thing that enables them to do so: their ability to provide clear, credible and independent assurance.

Active assurance

The increasing use of patient stories in committees is another interesting example. Patient stories can provide valuable insight into the real impact that services have on patients, families, staff and the wider community. They can humanise data, challenge assumptions and reconnect the committee with the lived experience behind the reports.

Again, the issue is not the use of patient stories. It is how they are used. If patient stories become a self-congratulatory listening exercise, particularly if they are almost always positive, they risk narrowing rather than deepening the committee’s understanding. A powerful story can be meaningful and still not be sufficient assurance. Committees need to ask how what they are hearing connects to other sources of evidence: complaints, incidents, survey results, claims, staff feedback, inequalities data, audit findings and performance trends.

In other words, patient stories should not sit outside the assurance process. They should strengthen it.

So the challenge is not choosing between assurance and activism. It is understanding the balance between the two and being intentional about how each is used.

Assurance, done well, is not passive. It is active, curious and testing. It asks, how do we know this? What gives us confidence? Where are the gaps? What are we not seeing? What would tell us if quality was deteriorating?

And activism, done well, is not about stepping into operations. It is about shaping focus. It ensures that attention is directed to where it matters most and that uncomfortable or ambiguous areas are not smoothed over.

The most effective quality committees are able to hold both. They resist the pull towards performative assurance but also avoid the trap of overreach. They create space for honest conversations, not just polished reporting. They focus less on volume and more on meaning.

Ultimately, the question is not whether quality committees make a difference. It is how they do it and whether that difference is real. Are they strengthening the organisation’s understanding of quality and risk, or simply creating more activity around it? Are they increasing confidence, or just visibility? Are they holding the line of assurance, or quietly stepping over it?

And perhaps most importantly, consider: if your quality committee disappeared tomorrow, what would actually change?

Meet the author: Normi Cadavieco

Director of organisational development

Email: normi.cadavieco@good-governance.org.uk Find out more

Prepared by GGI Development and Research LLP for the Good Governance Institute.

Enquire about this article

Enquire
Contact us