Governing quality: assurance and the role of the board
01 May 2026
Daniel Taylor looks at a notoriously tricky area of governance and offers some practical tips
Points addressed in this article
• Quality sits at the heart of governance but is notoriously difficult to govern
• Assurance is the standard response – but it is flawed
• To govern effectively, boards must shift emphasis
• Four key questions to strengthen your quality governance
Quality sits at the heart of governance in many public-purpose organisations. It is central in healthcare, higher education, regulation and across much of the public and third sectors. Boards speak about it often and with confidence. It appears prominently in reporting, in committee structures and in discussions of risk and assurance.
And yet, for something so central, it is notoriously difficult to govern and with any sense of the board’s tangible influence and impact.
We know more about quality than we ever have. We measure it more extensively, regulate it more closely, and discuss it more frequently at board level. Despite this, outcomes remain variable – sometimes stubbornly so. In some cases, it is unexpectedly fragile; in a few, it is catastrophically poor despite layers of oversight.
Part of the issue is that quality is often treated as if it were simply another performance domain, capable of being measured, tracked and assured in broadly the same way as finance or operations. That framing is understandable, but it is also incomplete. Quality behaves differently, and the way boards govern it needs to reflect that difference.
The nature of the problem
Quality has at least three characteristics that make it inherently difficult to govern – and shape how it is often governed.
- First, it is experiential. Quality is, in part, the lived reality of receiving a service. It is what patients encounter on a ward, what students experience in a seminar, what service users feel when interacting with a system. It is also what staff experience in trying to deliver that care or service—whether systems support them, whether workload is manageable, whether culture enables good judgement. Much of this sits below the line of formal reporting.
- Second, it is technical. Judgements about quality depend on forms of professional expertise that most boards do not possess. Clinical quality, academic standards, regulatory compliance—these are domains where depth of knowledge matters. Boards operate at one remove from that expertise and must rely on interpretation.
- Third, it is distributed. Quality is not produced in a single place. It emerges from thousands of interactions across an organisation, shaped by local conditions, leadership, culture, systems and resource. It varies—between departments, teams, sites, even individuals.
These three characteristics create a structural tension. Boards are accountable for something that is experienced locally, judged professionally, and produced systemically. It is not something that can be directly seen or easily verified from the boardroom.
Why assurance struggles
The standard response to this problem is assurance: metrics, dashboards, committees, escalation routes. These create a picture of quality, often a detailed one, but they also create a risk.
All assurance is a representation. It reflects choices about what is measured, how it is defined, and what is surfaced through organisational processes. It is shaped by incentives, by culture, and by the limits of measurement itself.
As the statistician George Box observed, “all models are wrong, but some are useful.” The question for boards is not whether their assurance is accurate in some absolute sense—it cannot be—but whether it is sufficiently complete, sufficiently challenging, and sufficiently honest to support good judgement.
Too often, boards are presented with a stable and reassuring picture of quality that masks underlying variation, fragility or emerging risk. Not because anyone is deliberately obscuring the truth, but because the system of assurance is not designed to surface it.
The deeper question: can boards influence quality?
This leads to a more uncomfortable question – one that sits beneath much governance practice but is rarely articulated. To what extent can boards meaningfully influence quality outcomes?
Boards do not deliver care, teach students or interact with service users. They do not make clinical decisions or design curricula. Their influence is indirect, exercised through strategy, culture, resource allocation, oversight and challenge. And yet, when quality fails, boards are held to account. There is a gap here between responsibility and control. Bridging that gap is the work of governance.
What effective boards do differently
The strongest boards recognise that they are not governing quality directly. They are governing the conditions in which quality is produced, and the systems through which it is understood. That requires a shift in emphasis.
- First, towards governing the credibility of assurance. This means interrogating how information is constructed, what it excludes, and where blind spots may lie. It means asking not just “what are we being told?” but “why do we believe it?”
- Second, towards triangulation. Quantitative data is set alongside qualitative intelligence—staff voice, complaints, peer insight—and tested against direct exposure to the organisation. The aim is not more information, but a more reliable understanding.
- Third, towards candour. The most sophisticated assurance system will fail if the organisation does not surface bad news. Boards influence this more than they sometimes realise, through how they respond to challenge, how they react to failure, and what behaviours they reward.
How far should non-executives go?
This is where practice often becomes uncertain. Non-executives are rightly cautious about straying into operational or professional territory. At the same time, remaining at a purely high-level risks detachment. The balance is not between “high level” and “detailed,” but between types of depth.
Non-executives need to go far enough into the detail to test how assurance works—how conclusions are reached, how variation is understood, how confidence is established—without substituting for professional judgement. They should be methodologically curious rather than professionally substitutive. That is a demanding position. It requires confidence, discipline and clarity of role.
An illustrative scenario
A university board receives consistent reports indicating strong academic quality. Student satisfaction is stable, continuation rates are acceptable, regulatory metrics are within threshold.
A non-executive asks about variation across departments. The answer is general. Further probing reveals significant differences in outcomes between programmes, uneven student feedback, and concerns among staff about assessment practices.
None of this contradicts the reported position, but it reframes it. The issue is not that the board was misinformed, it is that the system of assurance did not bring the most important questions into view.
Practical takeaway: testing your understanding of quality
Boards can strengthen their governance of quality by periodically stepping back from routine reporting and asking a small number of deeper questions:
- What does our assurance not tell us?
- Where does quality vary most across the organisation?
- How do we know what it feels like to receive or deliver our core service?
- What information reaches us late, filtered, or not at all?
These questions are not comfortable. But they are often more revealing than the dashboard.
Closing thought
The sociologist William Bruce Cameron wrote, “not everything that can be counted counts, and not everything that counts can be counted.” The challenge for boards is not simply to see more but to understand the limits of what they can see—and to govern accordingly.
In common with all our articles, this blog has been reviewed by a second GGi expert