Why NHS boards must act on Nottingham's maternity failures
29 June 2026
Following the publication of the largest independent review of maternity services in the history of the NHS, GGi CEO Professor Andrew Corbett-Nolan examines the findings of the Ockenden Review into maternity and neonatal care at Nottingham University Hospitals NHS Trust, placing the report within the context of recurring governance failures across the NHS and drawing out key lessons.
Points raised in this article:
- Donna Ockenden’s latest report on maternity services paints another devastating picture of systemic failure.
- The review offers urgent lessons for NHS boards and for governance in other organisations delivering services to vulnerable people.
- Will NHS boards treat this report as another difficult chapter to be managed or as the catalyst for fundamental improvement?
Two sets of practical action points – for individual board members and governance teams.
On 24 June 2026, Donna Ockenden published the final report of the Independent Review of Maternity and Neonatal Services at Nottingham University Hospitals NHS Trust (NUH). This is the largest review of its kind ever undertaken in the NHS, examining the experiences of nearly 2,500 families whose care was provided between 2012 and 2025 alongside evidence from more than 800 members of staff.
The report paints a devastating picture of systemic failure in which hundreds of mothers and babies suffered potentially avoidable death or serious harm because of longstanding weaknesses in clinical care, organisational culture, and, most pertinently for this audience, governance and leadership.
This latest Ockenden review follows the pattern established by previous major enquiries into NHS maternity services. The 2015 Morecambe Bay Investigation led by Dr Bill Kirkup exposed a ‘lethal mix’ of clinical failures, dysfunctional relationships and a culture that suppressed concerns. The Francis Inquiry into Mid Staffordshire (2013) had already highlighted the lethal consequences of boards losing sight of the quality of care. The first Ockenden report into Shrewsbury and Telford Hospital NHS Trust (2022) documented repeated failures to listen to families and learn from incidents. The East Kent Maternity and Neonatal Services review (2022) similarly pointed to deep-seated problems with leadership, governance and psychological safety. All the old favourites.
The Nottingham review demonstrates once again that these are not isolated incidents but recurring features of NHS governance when boards and executive teams fail to maintain effective oversight of clinical services.
Key findings of the Nottingham Ockenden Review
The review concluded that there were potentially avoidable outcomes relating to 444 maternity cases and 76 neonatal cases examined. Different care may have altered the outcome for a significant number of babies who died or suffered brain damage and for mothers who died or experienced serious harm.
Families described being ignored when raising concerns about reduced foetal movements or changes in their baby’s condition, being subjected to cruel or dismissive treatment and in some cases experiencing racist or misogynistic behaviour. Many reported being ‘gaslit’ when they tried to understand what had gone wrong.
Staff accounts revealed a bullying and toxic culture in which concerns were suppressed and speaking up was difficult. There was chronic understaffing across perinatal services, compounded by an inability of staff to complete even basic mandatory training. Perhaps most damagingly, there was a persistent failure to properly investigate serious incidents and, crucially, to learn from them.
Between 2015 and 2022, at least six external reviews of maternity services at NUH had already highlighted concerns about governance, leadership, culture and patient safety. The same themes continued to reappear because the trust’s governance systems failed to convert external scrutiny and internal intelligence into sustained improvement.
Governance and board-level failures
The Ockenden report is explicit about the role of the board and senior leadership. It states that maternity and neonatal services “do not operate in isolation but within wider trust division and corporate structures, with ultimate responsibility for quality and safety resting with the chief executive and board.”
Specific governance failings identified include:
- significant issues not being referred to or discussed by the board
- board members demonstrating insufficient curiosity to challenge information presented to them
- a culture of leaving major operational problems within sub-committees rather than bringing them to the main board for proper scrutiny
- executive teams providing reassurance rather than assurance – telling the board that problems were being managed without robust evidence
- a disconnect between midwifery and obstetric leaders and the board, with maternity leaders lacking direct access to the board table
- weak mechanisms for triangulating different sources of intelligence (complaints, incidents, staff surveys, CQC reports and external reviews).
These findings echo the governance failures documented in almost every major NHS inquiry of the past fifteen years. Boards have repeatedly been found to lack real visibility of what is happening on the ‘shop floor’, to accept optimistic narratives too readily and to fail to create the conditions in which staff feel safe to speak up. At GGi we only too often find ourselves writing recommendations to address similar issues in our reviews.
Implications for NHS boards
The Nottingham Ockenden review carries clear and urgent lessons for boards across the NHS and, more broadly, for governance in other public sector organisations that deliver complex services to vulnerable people.
First, boards must move beyond passive receipt of assurance to active curiosity and triangulation. Receiving a positive report from a subcommittee or executive director is not the same as knowing that services are safe. Boards need robust mechanisms to test the quality of assurance they receive and to seek out dissenting voices and ‘soft’ intelligence.
Second, psychological safety and speaking-up cultures are governance issues, not just HR or staff engagement issues. The review shows that when staff and families are not heard, harm follows. Boards have a direct responsibility to model and require behaviours that make it safe (indeed normal) to raise concerns.
Third, clinical governance must be a core board competence. Non-executive directors and executives alike need sufficient understanding of the services they oversee to ask the right questions and recognise when answers are incomplete or overly reassuring. This does not mean boards should become operational, but they must be intelligently engaged.
Fourth, the repeated failure to learn from previous reviews, both internal and external, points to a fundamental weakness in organisational memory and accountability. Boards should regularly review how previous recommendations have been implemented and whether the underlying issues have truly been addressed.
Fifth, the forthcoming Public Office (Accountability) Act 2026 (the Hillsborough Law) will add statutory weight to these expectations. The new duty of candour and assistance, combined with requirements to promote ethical conduct and new offences for serious misconduct, will increase personal and organisational exposure when governance fails. Boards that have not already strengthened their candour frameworks, ethical codes, and inquiry readiness will find themselves significantly more vulnerable once the act is in force.
Relevance beyond the NHS
While the Ockenden review focuses on maternity services, the governance lessons are transferable to other public sector boards, particularly those responsible for complex, high-risk services involving vulnerable people (social care, education, policing, housing and regulatory bodies). GGi sees the same patterns of weak escalation, defensive cultures, insufficient board curiosity and failure to triangulate intelligence appear across multiple sectors. Any board that relies on reassurance rather than rigorous assurance, or that treats governance as a compliance exercise rather than a mechanism for protecting service users, risks, as surely as night follows day, similar failures.
The role of GGi and the path forward
At the GGi we have long argued that effective governance in public bodies requires more than structures and policies. It requires a culture of inquiry, humility and relentless focus on the experience of those who use services. The Nottingham Ockenden review reinforces this view.
Our public bodies governance maturity matrix provides a practical framework for boards to assess their current position and identify where they need to improve, particularly in the domains of assurance, ethical standards, stakeholder voice and leadership culture.
Reviews such as this one should prompt boards to use tools like the matrix to test whether their governance is genuinely mature or merely compliant on paper.
GGi’s governance reviews and, for NHS organisations, our ‘super reviews’ will continue to examine these issues rigorously: the quality of board papers and challenge; the effectiveness of escalation routes; the lived experience of speaking up; and the extent to which boards actively seek out and act upon uncomfortable information.
Conclusion
The families who contributed to the Nottingham Ockenden review have once again done the hard work of holding the system to account. Their courage has exposed failings that should never have been allowed to persist for more than a decade.
For NHS boards and public sector boards more widely, the message is stark but clear: governance is not a theoretical exercise conducted in boardrooms. When it fails, real people suffer avoidable harm. The structures, behaviours, and cultures that boards create, or tolerate, have direct consequences for the safety and dignity of those they exist to serve.
The question now is whether boards across the NHS will treat this report as another difficult chapter to be managed or as the catalyst for the fundamental improvement in governance practice that patients, families and staff have a right to expect.
Practical action points for boards
The findings of the Nottingham Ockenden review point to a number of concrete actions that boards and governance teams should take now.
For individual board members
- Actively test the quality of assurance you receive rather than accepting it at face value. Find out what the underlying data, the sources of assurance that was relied on.
- Develop and maintain ‘intelligent curiosity’ about clinical services, particularly for high-risk areas such as maternity. This includes requesting regular deep dives, unvarnished staff and patient feedback and triangulated intelligence from multiple sources.
- Challenge optimistic or overly reassuring narratives. If something feels too good to be true, probe further.
- Ensure you have sufficient visibility of how concerns from staff and families are escalated, heard and acted upon. This is a governance issue, not solely an operational one.
- Personally model and champion psychological safety. Be visibly receptive to bad news and supportive of those who raise concerns. If you are a non-executive, be mindful about how you exercise constructive challenge.
- Regularly reflect on whether the board is receiving the right information in the right way, and whether you have the skills and knowledge needed to provide effective oversight of clinical services.
- Prepare for the requirements of the Public Office (Accountability) Act 2026 by ensuring you understand the new duty of candour and assistance and your personal responsibilities under it.
For governance teams
- Review and strengthen the mechanisms by which significant issues are escalated to the board, ensuring there is a clear route that bypasses normal committee structures when required.
- Improve the quality of board reporting so that it supports genuine scrutiny rather than reassurance. This includes highlighting areas of uncertainty, conflicting information, or known gaps in assurance.
- Develop a systematic approach to triangulating intelligence from complaints, incidents, staff surveys, Freedom to Speak Up data, CQC reports, and external reviews.
- Ensure that previous internal and external reviews (including their recommendations and action plans) are regularly reported to the board with candid assessments of implementation and impact.
- Strengthen the board’s access to ‘soft’ intelligence and the voices of staff and patients, including through direct engagement and protected routes for raising concerns.
- Use tools such as the GGi public bodies governance maturity matrix to assess current board effectiveness in areas such as assurance, ethical culture, and stakeholder voice, and to track improvement over time.
- Use GGi tools to help board committees operate effectively, with escalation tools such as GGi’s 3As reporting method.
- Prepare the organisation for the Public Office (Accountability) Act 2026 by reviewing and updating codes of conduct, training programmes, inquiry readiness protocols, and candour frameworks.
- Link board development programmes to better governance.
- Ensure your regular governance reviews or board effectiveness reviews properly explore assurance reliability.
Selected references
Corbett-Nolan, A. (2026) What are the big investigations into governance failure telling us? GGi
Francis, R. (2013) Report of the Mid Staffordshire NHS Foundation Trust Public Inquiry. London: The Stationery Office
GGi (2025) Public Bodies Governance Maturity Matrix. London: Good Governance Institute.
Kirkup, B. (2015) The Report of the Morecambe Bay Investigation. London: The Stationery Office
Kirkup, B. (2022) Reading the signals: Maternity and neonatal services in East Kent – the report of the independent investigation. London: The Stationery Office
Ockenden, D. (2022) Final report of the Independent Review of Maternity Services at Shrewsbury and Telford Hospital NHS Trust. London: NHS England
Ockenden, D. (2026) Report of the Independent Review of Maternity and Neonatal Services at Nottingham University Hospitals NHS Trust. Nottingham: Ockenden Maternity Review
The Chartered Governance Institute UK & Ireland (2026) Ockenden review holds governance lessons for boards across the NHS. London: CGIUKI. Available at: https://www.cgi.org.uk