The world we want?

30 September 2026

Aidan Rave suggests that we stop asking what we can't have and start deciding what we want

 

Key points

- Like a good society, good governance starts with clear purpose

- Technology shows what's possible, not what's desirable

- Civic decline isn't inevitable; communities are built by our choices

- It’s time to decide what world we want to build together

 

In governance, there is no silver bullet, no panacea, no single action that will secure effective governance. Rather, there are a series of principles, the brilliant basics if you will, that combine to underpin the foundations of good governance. 

That said, when GGi undertakes a board or senior team governance review, we consistently start with one foundational question: 'What is your purpose?’. That’s because everything must flow from that - and if an organisation’s purpose is not clear, then governance is little more than a process of compliance to a regulator or to a series of arbitrary internal risks and performance indicators. How can a board create value through governance if it is unable to articulate something as fundamental as why it exists?

As purpose matters in governance, so it matters in life. Boards are charged with stewarding purpose within organisations, but the same principle applies beyond the boardroom. The communities and society we want do not emerge by accident; they are shaped by the choices we make and the purpose we define and then pursue.

I’ve been thinking a lot about purpose in relation to the relentless march of AI. What has struck me most is the way humans (aside from the few tech-savvy kids who proclaim to actually understand it) seem to be framed as mere extras in the unfolding drama of technological advancement. Look at the way AI is talked about and reported on; you could be forgiven for overlooking the fact that, when all is said and done, AI remains an invention of humankind – for now at least!

My argument is that such passivity has become a definite pattern since the 2008 global financial crisis. Political discourse has become more formulaic than aspirational, constrained by what we perceive we can’t do (whether you lean to the left or right) rather than what we can. Quality of life is treated as a side issue at best, something left over once the main business is settled. That main business – the demands of the bond market, public services, taxation – is taken as given. It rests on a set of assumptions seen as non-negotiable, and they have shaped our thinking so deeply that any challenge to them is dismissed as radical, even extremist.

What are these assumptions? Well, the right would argue that the size of the state, exemplified by welfare spending in particular, has become a fixed variable. They are probably right. So are the left when they argue for a more even distribution of wealth. The point is, we don’t really start with the question 'What do we want?’, but rather 'What can’t we have?'  

Declining engagement

In his new book The Future Starts With Us, former Prime Minister Gordon Brown picks up on this worrying trend, arguing that declining participation in many of the institutions that have traditionally formed the backbone of civil society – faith organisations, community groups, voluntary associations and civic networks – have all seen dramatic falls in engagement, participation and influence over recent years. As Robert Putnam has consistently argued, the gradual decline in civic participation tends to correlate with negative trend data in terms of health, community safety and the economic loss of discretionary effort that is at the heart of civic life. 

The knee-jerk reaction to all of this is often nostalgic - lamenting the passing of a world in which more people went to church, joined local associations, volunteered in their communities or participated in civic life. Yet nostalgia is rarely a useful guide to the future. Every generation tends to view the institutions of its youth through a rose-tinted lens. The reality is that many of those institutions were imperfect, exclusionary and often sustained by social expectations that few would wish to recreate today.

Mind you, I find the opposite response equally unsatisfactory. This is the argument that civil society's decline is simply happening to us. That technology, economic pressures, social atomisation and a host of other forces have combined to make civic participation increasingly difficult. There is truth in this analysis. The social and economic conditions around us matter. That doesn’t mean that we should simply view ourselves purely as victims of circumstance.

When polarised like this, both perspectives miss a more fundamental issue; not what we have lost, nor what we should seek to recover, but rather what sort of society we want to create.

Technology undoubtedly has a role in answering that question. It can expand what is possible, but it cannot tell us what is desirable. Nor can it determine what will make our neighbourhoods, communities and institutions places in which people genuinely want to live, learn, work and belong.

As Albert Bandura's work on self-efficacy demonstrated, human beings retain the capacity to shape their own circumstances. Whether we choose to exercise that agency is another matter, but the choice remains ours.

Yet much of the public conversation about technology implies the opposite. It often begins from the assumption that human beings are passive recipients of forces beyond their control. AI is transforming work. Social media is changing relationships. Technology will reshape democracy. The language itself is revealing. Technology is frequently cast as the actor and humanity as the audience. In this framing, change happens to us rather than through us.

This is where a sense of hopelessness can emerge. If technology is the protagonist and people merely spectators, our role is reduced to adaptation. But technological change is not an act of nature. It is the product of human choices, human values and human priorities. The future will not simply be delivered to us. It must be shaped by what we decide to build, encourage, regulate and reject.

Yet, as we have seen and often lament, functional and coherent communities and societies are not axiomatic; they do not simply happen. I was thinking about this the other day as I walked though a park in my hometown of Doncaster. A couple of generations earlier, that same park would have been lovingly tended by an army of groundskeepers; the boating lake would have had boats on it, with a few more people hired to operate and maintain them. In years gone by there was a pitch and putt golf course, tennis courts, a bowling green – all regularly used and scrupulously maintained, patronised and guarded. I could go on. The point here is emphatically not nostalgia. I’m not suggesting that we need to recreate a long-gone golden age, but as I looked around the dirty, dishevelled, unloved ‘park’, I couldn’t help but wonder if this is really what we want our communities to be in 2026?

The future is created, not delivered

Our communities are built through countless individual decisions about how we spend our time, where we direct our energy and what we consider important. We should refamiliarise ourselves with the principle that the future is not delivered to us. It is created by us.

This is why the debate about civil society matters so much. Its decline is not principally a story about organisations. It is a story about purpose. 

For much of human history people inherited strong answers to a simple question: what am I part of? The answers varied. Faith. Community. Family. Trade unions. Public service. Political movements. Neighbourhoods. Some of these structures have weakened considerably in recent years. Take organised religion. Identification with and declining participation in religious institutions has been precipitous over the last half century. Indeed, the 2026 British Social Attitudes survey sets this out in stark terms, with just 2% of under 25s identifying themselves as Church of England, while the figure for over 70s is a more respectable but still much depleted 21%. The trend is clear. 

It’s the same when it comes to membership of trade unions, longstanding bodies like the Women’s Institute and so on. Of course, some arguably deserved to weaken. Greater freedom has brought enormous benefits. Yet greater freedom has also placed a new burden upon us. We are increasingly expected to create our own meaning, define our own identity and discover our own purpose.

That freedom can be exhilarating. It can also be exhausting.

Purpose has not disappeared. Perhaps it has merely become obscured. After all, we continue to see extraordinary acts of commitment and generosity. In moments of crisis, people still volunteer. They still organise. They still support one another. They still care deeply about causes larger than themselves.

The instinct remains. What may have changed is our ability to channel it. Technology plays an important role in this story, but perhaps not in the way we often assume. Too often technology is portrayed as the enemy of community. The force that isolates us, distracts us and pulls us apart. Yet this overlooks a remarkable truth. Never in human history has it been easier to find like-minded people, organise collective action, raise money for a cause, share knowledge or build communities that transcend geography and circumstance.

The tools already exist. The question is how we choose to use them, or perhaps more pertinently, why we choose not to. The paradox is that the more tools we have to communicate, organise and act, the less inclined we seem to do so. 

We can use technology to consume more content, retreat further into personalised worlds and become increasingly detached from one another, or we can use it to connect, organise, collaborate and contribute. The technology is the same. The choices are different.

Which brings us back to purpose. The Austrian philosopher and Holocaust survivor Viktor Frankl once said, “When we are no longer able to change a situation, we are challenged to change ourselves." We matter in this question of purpose, because it is the aggregation of our individual purpose, argued out, refined, revised and finally achieving consensus that defines who we are. As Frankl puts it, if we are able to articulate the ‘why’ in terms of the way we live, we can bear almost any ‘how’.

Collective endeavour begins with personal agency

Civil society has never been built by institutions alone. Every community group, charity, campaign, governing board, sports club or place of worship started with individuals deciding that their life should be about more than themselves. Collective endeavour begins with personal agency. It starts with a decision to participate rather than observe. Governmental attempts to recrate this have largely failed; The Big Society, New Deal for Communities, countless regeneration programmes stretching from the 70s to the present day have titivated and spruced in terms of physical infrastructure but few have sustainably transformed communities, with reductions in the fear of crime proving transitory and potentially foundational shifts like educational attainment stubbornly difficult to shift. 

Not that regeneration schemes don’t have their place, some have proved useful catalysts for wider progress. However, we must never lose sight that people are intrinsic to this progress; people who step up to lead and, critically, those who are prepared to follow. Little happens without them.

Yet even personal agency alone is not enough.

Purpose grows when it encounters the commitment of others. One person's spark becomes something far more powerful when it connects with the energy, ideas and dedication of a wider community. This is how movements form. It is how institutions emerge. It is how societies renew themselves.

Returning to Gordon Brown's concern about the decline of civic participation and the weakening of the institutions that once connected people to causes larger than themselves. Perhaps this matters for reasons that go far beyond civil society alone. A world in which people lose faith in collective action is also a world in which they begin to see the future as something that happens to them rather than something they shape. The erosion of agency in our communities and the sense of powerlessness that often accompanies debates about technology may be two sides of the same coin.

Aligning technology with purpose

The challenge facing us today is therefore not to recreate the past, but nor is it to resist the future. If it’s about anything, surely the challenge is to align technological possibility with human purpose.

In that context, the real danger is not that technology advances too quickly, it’s that we fail to decide what we want that advance to achieve., that we cede the drive, the determination and ultimately the agency to create and shape the communities we want to live in. A society without purpose will simply drift wherever innovation takes it. A society with purpose can use innovation to strengthen human connection, expand opportunity and deepen participation.

In the end, the future of civil society will be determined by people not governments, algorithms or experts. As it has been throughout history, just ordinary people making choices about how they live and what they value, as Margaret Mead famously said, in terms of changing the world, it’s the only thing that ever has. So, the question is not so much whether technology will shape the future. It inarguably already does. The question is whether we still have the vision and determination to shape it in return. 

And that begins by asking ourselves a deceptively simple question:

What world do we want to build together?

Meet the author: Aidan Rave

Principal consultant and partner

Email: aidan.rave@good-governance.org.uk Find out more

Prepared by GGI Development and Research LLP for the Good Governance Institute.

Enquire about this article

Enquire
Contact us