The Office of the Scottish Charity Regulator
21 August 2026
Professor Andrew Corbett-Nolan explains what Scottish charity boards need to know about OSCR, trustee duties and effective governance.
Points raised in this article:
- OSCR regulates around 25,000 charities across Scotland.
- Trustees carry collective, personal responsibility for effective governance.
- New legislation has strengthened OSCR’s oversight and enforcement powers.
- Strong board oversight protects beneficiaries and sustains public confidence.
The Office of the Scottish Charity Regulator (OSCR) is the independent registrar and regulator of charities in Scotland. It is a non-ministerial office of the Scottish Administration, directly accountable to the Scottish Parliament. It regulates approximately 25,000 charities.
Because there is no income threshold for registration, the Scottish Charity Register includes a high proportion of small, volunteer-led organisations as well as larger institutions. For the boards and trustees of these charities, understanding OSCR’s legal framework, strategy, expectations, investigative approach and the practical implications for accountability is fundamental.
Origins and evolution
Organised public support for Scottish charities long pre-dated modern regulation, but the present statutory framework was created by the Charities and Trustee Investment (Scotland) Act 2005. OSCR assumed its full powers on 24 April 2006.
It was established as an independent regulator answerable to the Scottish Parliament rather than to ministers on operational matters. The Charities (Regulation and Administration) (Scotland) Act 2023 significantly updated the 2005 Act, with changes phased in between 2024 and early 2026. These included stronger intervention powers, a requirement to publish trustee names, publication of all charity accounts, an internal database of trustee details, the ability to remove defaulting charities, positive directions, and inquiries into former charities and trustees.
Strategy and current priorities
OSCR’s Corporate Strategy 2026–29 sets out its mission, which is to regulate Scottish charities in a proportionate and targeted way that promotes trust and confidence, ensures accountability, and strengthens the sector’s ability to deliver public benefit. Four strategic themes guide the period:
- driving compliance through proportionate and effective regulation
- supporting the development of a resilient, effective and trusted charity sector through regulation
- continuing to drive efficiency as a public body
- supporting OSCR’s own people.
This builds on the previous 2023–26 strategy, which emphasised public access to information, tools and guidance for charities, smart regulation, workforce capability and best value. OSCR’s approach is risk-based and generally more relationship-oriented than that of larger regulators, reflecting the scale of the Scottish sector, while the 2023 Act has equipped it with more assertive tools when required.
What OSCR expects of charity trustees
Charity trustees are the people who have the general control and management of the charity. Under section 66 of the 2005 Act, they must:
- act in the interests of the charity
- seek, in good faith, to ensure that the charity acts in a manner consistent with its purposes
- act with the care and diligence that it is reasonable to expect of a person managing the affairs of another
- manage conflicts of interest by putting the charity’s interests first or disclosing the conflict and refraining from participation
- ensure the charity complies with the 2005 Act.
These duties are collective. All trustees must take reasonably practicable steps to correct breaches and to remove any trustee who is in serious or persistent breach. Failure constitutes misconduct in the administration of the charity.
OSCR expects boards to be in genuine control, to follow their governing document, to keep proper records, to manage finances responsibly, and to ensure that assets are applied only for the stated charitable purposes. For SCIOs there are additional structural requirements (a minimum of three trustees, registers of members and trustees, and members’ meetings at least every 15 months). Trustees of all legal forms must file annual accounts and returns and keep the Register entry up to date.
Support for charity trustees in Scotland
OSCR places significant emphasis on guidance and self-service tools. Its core publication is Guidance and good practice for charity trustees. This is supplemented by topic-specific guidance on safeguarding, remuneration, governing documents and meetings, conflicts, fundraising and many other areas. A Trustee information & guidance pack is available online and can be tailored to the characteristics of the individual charity (legal form, trading activity, elected members, social media use, cross-border status, etc.). Checklists, model constitutions (especially for SCIOs, developed with SCVO), and clear statements of what OSCR can and cannot deal with are designed to help trustees meet their duties without unnecessary bureaucracy.
OSCR’s stance is that most charities are well run and that clear guidance, combined with proportionate monitoring, is the primary means of supporting compliance. It does not mediate internal disputes where trustees are acting within their powers; such matters should be resolved by the board itself.
Investigations and enforcement
OSCR can open inquiries under section 28 of the 2005 Act where there is evidence of misconduct or risk to charitable assets or public confidence. It publishes inquiry reports (including ‘section 33’ reports) to promote transparency and sector learning. Powers include directions (now both negative and positive), suspension or removal of trustees, appointment of interim trustees, and, in serious cases, petitioning the Court of Session for the appointment of a judicial factor.
Recent published inquiries have covered financial governance and decision-making (including the Clan Donald Lands Trust and the Centre for Contemporary Arts), historical governance issues (The King’s Foundation), failure to engage or risk to assets (The Gate Way For The Less Privileged), and individual trustee conduct. OSCR has also dealt with a rising number of concerns about internal disputes (more than doubling between 2024 and 2025) and has used its powers to protect vulnerable beneficiaries and charitable assets in complex cases such as The Jericho Benedictine Society, which generated significant legal costs.
Accountability of trustees and recent context
Trustee accountability under Scottish charity law is real and personal. While OSCR’s response is intended to be proportionate and while honest, reasonable trustees are unlikely to face formal action, serious or persistent breaches can lead to directions, suspension, removal, and, ultimately, Court of Session involvement. The 2023 Act has strengthened OSCR’s ability to act against former trustees and dissolved charities, closing previous gaps.
OSCR has faced less high-profile public criticism than some other regulators, but individual inquiries have attracted scrutiny from complainants who felt investigations were insufficiently robust or one-sided. The regulator has also noted the increasing complexity and cost of some inquiries and the need for specialist input. Its published strategy and annual reports emphasise continued improvement in digital capability, efficiency and support for trustees while maintaining the capacity to intervene effectively.
Practical implications for charity boards in Scotland
Boards of Scottish charities operate under a clear statutory framework that places primary responsibility on trustees themselves. They must understand and discharge their section 66 duties, ensure the governing document is followed, maintain accurate registers and financial records, manage conflicts, and treat public benefit and the charity’s purposes as the constant reference point for decisions. Serious concerns about assets, beneficiaries or misconduct should be reported; internal disagreements should first be addressed by the board.
The quality of that board-level engagement determines both the charity’s resilience and its relationship with OSCR. Charities that can demonstrate active, informed and independent oversight, that use the available guidance, and that respond constructively when issues arise are better placed to protect their beneficiaries, sustain public confidence and continue their work.
OSCR’s role is to uphold that confidence by maintaining an accurate register, supporting compliance through clear information, and intervening proportionately and effectively when the legal framework is breached.