The Nolan Principles and cash for questions
06 July 2026
Andrew Corbett-Nolan reflects on the legacy of David Hencke and the profound contribution his investigative journalism made to public accountability in Britain.
Points raised in this article
- The origin of the Committee for Standards in Public Life and the Nolan Principles
- Guardian journalist David Hencke's role in exposing the cash for questions scandal
- The important governance lessons to learn from the scandal
- Why the decline in investigative journalism should concern us all
In October 1994, Prime Minister John Major responded to the ‘cash for questions’ scandal by setting up the Committee on Standards in Public Life. The committee was chaired by the judge Lord Nolan and developed the Nolan Principles. The scandal was exposed by Guardian journalist David Hencke, who died last month.
This article explores Hencke’s career, the governance lessons that emerged from that period and why serious, independent investigative journalism remains essential to the health of public institutions today.
David Hencke was one of the most respected and tenacious Westminster correspondents and investigative journalists of his generation. Hencke’s work on the cash for questions scandal in the 1990s helped expose serious failings in parliamentary standards and played a significant role in prompting wider reforms including the development of the Nolan Principles.
David Hencke joined The Guardian in 1976 and served as its Westminster correspondent from 1986 until 2009. Over more than three decades he built a reputation for rigorous, evidence-based reporting that held power to account, often at considerable personal and professional cost. His work was characterised by persistence, attention to detail and a willingness to pursue stories that others might have found too difficult or politically sensitive.
Hencke’s most significant contribution to public life came in the mid-1990s when he played a central role in exposing what became known as the cash for questions scandal. Working with colleagues at The Guardian, he revealed that certain members of parliament had accepted money from Mohamed Al-Fayed, the then owner of Harrods, in return for asking parliamentary questions on his behalf.
The scandal centred particularly on Neil Hamilton MP, then a Conservative MP and minister, and Tim Smith MP. The revelations caused enormous political damage and led to a series of resignations, inquiries and legal proceedings that stretched on for years.
The scandal exposed fundamental weaknesses in the self-regulatory systems of the House of Commons. It demonstrated how easily the rules around paid advocacy could be circumvented and how limited the mechanisms were for detecting and punishing such behaviour. Public confidence in parliament was badly damaged. In response to the crisis, the then prime minister John Major established the Committee on Standards in Public Life in 1994, chaired by Lord Nolan. The Nolan Committee’s first report, published in 1995, set out the famous Seven Principles of Public Life - selflessness, integrity, objectivity, accountability, openness, honesty and leadership - which remain the cornerstone of ethical standards across the public sector to this day.
It is in this context that a tenuous but human connection exists between the events of that period and my own work. Many years later, I had the privilege of serving on the board of a charity alongside the late Iris Bond. Iris had been a witness in the legal proceedings connected to the Neil Hamilton case. It was Iris who witnessed the stuffing of the famous brown envelopes with wads of cash.
During the trial she was subjected to some crude and dismissive descriptions in court, including being referred to as “aging totty” and “mutton crumpet”. Far from being crushed by this, Iris recounted the episode with characteristic good humour and resilience. Her presence on that charity board many years later was a quiet reminder that behind every major political scandal are real people whose lives are touched, sometimes in unexpected ways, by the consequences of failures in public standards.
Cash for questions lessons
The cash for questions affair and the subsequent Nolan Principles offer several enduring lessons for governance that remain highly relevant today.
First, they demonstrated the critical importance of external scrutiny. Parliament’s internal systems at the time were simply not capable of policing themselves effectively. It took determined investigative journalism, working with sources who were prepared to take risks, to bring the misconduct to light. Without that external pressure, it is highly unlikely that the scale of the problem would have been exposed or that meaningful reform would have followed.
This remains a vital lesson for all public institutions. Boards and regulators can become captured by their own narratives or institutional defensiveness. Independent voices, whether from journalism, whistleblowers or most helpfully external reviews, are often essential to surface problems that would otherwise remain hidden.
Second, the scandal highlighted the dangers of weak accountability mechanisms and over-reliance on self-regulation. The rules that existed were either inadequate or poorly enforced. The episode led directly to the creation of stronger structures, including the Parliamentary Commissioner for Standards and clearer rules on paid advocacy. It also reinforced the principle that those who hold public office must be subject to meaningful consequences when they fall short. These lessons have been repeatedly tested in subsequent years, from the expenses scandal of 2009 to more recent concerns about lobbying and conflicts of interest.
Third, the cash for questions affair showed how quickly public trust can erode when standards appear to be compromised. Once the perception takes hold that politicians are ‘on the take’, it becomes extremely difficult to restore confidence. The MPs expenses scandal with duck houses and moat cleaning became Chapter II.
The Nolan Principles were an attempt to articulate a clear ethical framework that could help rebuild that trust. They remain powerful because they are simple, memorable, and aspirational. However, as we see repeatedly in public life, principles on paper are only as good as the culture and enforcement mechanisms that support them.
Time to reflect
The death of David Hencke is therefore an appropriate moment to reflect on the broader importance of serious investigative journalism to public accountability. In an age of fragmented media, declining resources for long-form investigative work, and the rise of instant commentary, the space for the kind of patient, forensic reporting that Hencke practised has narrowed. Yet the need for it has arguably never been greater.
Public institutions, whether in central government, the NHS, local authorities, or the wider public sector, operate with significant power and public money. When things go wrong the consequences can be severe, as we have seen in repeated inquiries into failures in healthcare, social care and other services. Time and again, these inquiries reveal that problems were known about internally for years but were not properly surfaced or addressed. In such environments the role of independent scrutiny becomes even more important.
Investigative journalism serves several vital functions. It can act as an early warning system, bringing issues to public attention before they become catastrophic. It can give voice to those who might otherwise be ignored - patients, families, staff or whistleblowers. And it can create the political and public pressure that forces institutions to confront uncomfortable truths and make necessary changes. Without this external pressure, the default position of many organisations is often defensiveness, delay, and damage limitation.
This is why the decline in properly resourced investigative journalism should concern anyone interested in good governance. When news organisations no longer have the capacity or appetite to pursue complex, long-running stories, the risk increases that serious wrongdoing or systemic failure will go undetected for longer. Social media and citizen journalism can play a role in surfacing issues, but they rarely provide the sustained, evidence-based investigation that traditional long-form journalism at its best can deliver.
Engaging with challenges
There are, of course, challenges. Investigative journalism is expensive, time-consuming and often legally risky. Sometimes investigative journalism gets it wrong. It requires news organisations with the resources and editorial commitment to support it. It also requires journalists with the skills, tenacity and ethical grounding to do the work properly. David Hencke represented a particular tradition of public service journalism that combined deep knowledge of Westminster with a determination to hold those in power to account, regardless of party.
For boards and governance professionals working in public and third sector organisations, there are practical lessons to draw from this history. Strong internal governance including clear codes of conduct, robust conflict of interest policies, effective whistleblowing arrangements, and genuine board oversight is essential. But these internal mechanisms are not sufficient on their own. Boards should also recognise the legitimate role of external scrutiny, including from the media, and resist the temptation to treat all investigative reporting as hostile or ill-informed.
Organisations that develop a culture in which concerns can be raised internally, and in which external challenge is engaged with constructively rather than defensively, are far better placed to identify and address problems early. Conversely, those that seek to control narratives at all costs, or that view transparency primarily as a reputational risk, are more likely to find themselves the subject of damaging exposés further down the line.
GGi has long argued that effective governance requires a combination of strong internal systems and a willingness to engage openly with external perspectives. Our work with charities, public bodies and NHS organisations consistently shows that the healthiest organisations are those that treat accountability not as a threat but as a core part of their purpose. They recognise that public trust is hard won and easily lost, and that maintaining it requires more than compliance with minimum standards.
David Hencke’s career reminds us that investigative journalism, at its best, is not about sensationalism or score-settling. It is about shining a light on the exercise of power and asking difficult questions on behalf of the public. The cash for questions scandal, painful as it was for those involved, ultimately strengthened the framework of standards in public life in Britain. That strengthening came about in large part because determined journalists such as David Hencke refused to let the story go.
As we face new challenges to public trust, from questions about lobbying and conflicts of interest to repeated failures in major public services, the need for serious, independent investigative journalism remains as great as ever. Its decline would not only be a loss for the media; it would be a loss for public accountability itself.
At GGi, we will continue to support boards in building the cultures, systems and behaviours that make organisations more open, more accountable and better able to serve the public interest. That work is, in its own way, part of the same tradition that David Hencke represented: a belief that power should be exercised with integrity, and that those who hold it should be willing to be held to account.