The hall and the tapestry: governing England’s cathedrals

21 September 2026

Andrew Corbett-Nolan and Janice Smith use the Bayeux Tapestry as a starting point to explore a much older governance question: who holds the hall, on what terms, and with what accountability? Five years on from the Cathedrals Measure 2021, they examine whether England’s cathedral Chapters are truly operating as modern trustee boards.

 

Points raised:

- Cathedrals now operate within clearer trustee and charity duties.

- The 2021 reforms reshaped Chapter governance and accountability.

- Finance, safeguarding and culture remain critical governance challenges.

- Good governance protects purpose, stewardship and long-term sustainability.

 

This month, for the first time in centuries, the Bayeux Tapestry is on English soil. Laid flat in a single length in the British Museum’s Sainsbury Exhibitions Gallery, it will stay until July 2027: seventy metres of wool on linen describing a Norman argument about legitimacy, embroidered almost certainly in England in the 1070s and now loaned back as an act of diplomacy.

Among its named figures is a man the Latin titulus does not flatter: STIGANT ARCHIEP[ISCOPU]S. Archbishop Stigand stands beside Harold Godwinson at the moment the tapestry wishes us to understand as Harold’s coronation. He is tonsured, vested and bareheaded. He does not, in the stitching, actually place the crown. He is simply there, which, for a Norman audience, was enough. Presence was the point. If Harold’s kingship could be shown to rest on a ‘dodgy cleric’, William’s claim looked less like conquest and more like addressing poor church governance. Indeed, William had obtained a Papal banner for just this.

So, to some extent the tapestry is a governance story. It is, if we are honest, a cautionary tale about what happens when office, property, legitimacy and personal power are allowed to run out of control.

Stigand as a problem of office

Stigand is not in fact a cartoon villain, though later chroniclers found this a convenient fiction. He served six kings. He was a political cleric of the old English type: Royal Chaplain, Bishop of Elmham, then of Winchester, then, after Robert of Jumièges fled in 1052, Archbishop of Canterbury while remaining Bishop of Winchester. He accumulated abbeys and at lined his pockets. Indeed, the Domesday Book would later show that only the king and the Godwinsons held more land. 

He obtained a pallium from Benedict X, who was shortly afterwards treated as an antipope. Five popes are said to have excommunicated him. So, while English sources insist that Ealdred of York, not Stigand, crowned Harold, Norman sources and the tapestry place him firmly in the picture. 

In April 1070, at Winchester, Papal legates deposed him on three counts: pluralism, seizure and the matter of the use of the pallium. He had used the pallium left behind by his predecessor, Robert of Jumièges, rather than receiving his own, the pallium he later obtained came from Benedict X, who was treated as an antipope, so the title itself was defective. He died in custody at Winchester in 1072. His estates went to the Crown. Lanfranc succeeded him, and the Church was restored to good governance.

The charges have a modern ring to them. Holding two incompatible roles. Occupying an office on a defective title. Treating the assets of the Holy See as personal property. Confusing the person with the corporation. Enjoying the confidence of a court while lacking the confidence of the only external authority that should confer legitimacy. William used Rome when it suited him and kept Stigand in place when it did not. Reform was only instituted when it became useful.

So English cathedral governance has always been about more than liturgy. It has been about who may hold the hall.

GGi has long used stewardship in its older sense. The Old English word stigweard means ‘the keeper of the hall’. To note, not the owner but the person accountable for a building and a community that pre-exist keeper (or steward) and must outlast him. A cathedral is that hall, the place where a people gather, where memory is staged, where the bishop’s seat is set, and where, if the roof fails, everyone gets wet. The keeper’s duty is to hand it on in better condition than it was received. Stigand failed that test not because he was insufficiently Norman, but because he could not separate the health of the institution from the reach of the man.

The tapestry, hanging now a short walk from the Thames, is a reminder that governance failures are rarely private. They are stitched into the public record. 

What a cathedral is for

A cathedral is the seat of a bishop and a centre of worship and mission. This is not piety dressed as statute. It is now the opening duty of the Cathedrals Measure 2021. Anyone exercising a function under the Measure must have due regard to those facts and to the cathedral’s role as a focus for the life and work of the Church of England in the diocese. The constitution of each Chapter must specify only three objects these being to:

  • advance the Christian religion in accordance with the faith and practice of the Church of England, in particular by furthering its mission
  • care for and conserve the fabric and structure of the cathedral church building
  • advance ancillary charitable purposes.

Everything else is ultra vires in the strict sense.

This, usefully, amounts to a tighter purpose clause than most large charities ever write for themselves. It is also the right starting point for any serious conversation about cathedral governance. Governance, as we have argued for years, is not audit, bureaucracy or business efficiency. It is not democracy by another name. The word comes from the Greek kubernan, to steer. It is a high-level activity concerned with long-term plans, purpose and impact: how an organisation is led and run so that its aims are more likely to be achieved and its duties to stakeholders discharged. Good governance is dynamic. It adds value. It makes it easier to do the right thing and harder to do the wrong thing.

The governance tension for cathedrals is that they inevitably strain that definition because they are several organisations at once. They are praying communities. They are among the most demanding heritage assets in Europe, often listed as Grade I, with fabric liabilities to be thought about across generations. They are civic stages, being the one great public interior a city may still possess. They are diocesan institutions. They are trading and fundraising bodies whose income is seasonal, reputation-sensitive and still marked by the visitor collapse of 2020–21. And they are now registered charities, whose trustees can be directed, warned and, in the last resort, removed.

The 2021 Measure did not invent those tensions. It put them on one table and appointed the people at that table charity trustees.

From corporation to three bodies to one chapter

English cathedrals are corporations established for spiritual purposes. A corporation exists independent of its members, in perpetuity, with a seal, the capacity to hold land, and, because corporate acts must be supervised, a Visitor. That common-law inheritance is why cathedral governance has never been a simple matter of a board and a chief executive. It is why the bishop’s ancient visitatorial jurisdiction still matters and why reformers have had to proceed by Measure of the General Synod rather than by ordinary statute alone.

The modern story is usually dated from the Cathedrals’ Measure 1931, which addressed property and finance after the winding-up of cathedral ownership of land and the arrival of Church Commissioners’ block grants, and from the Cathedrals Measure 1999, which abolished the old distinction between “Dean and Chapter” cathedrals and “parish church” cathedrals for corporate purposes. The 1999 Measure required three bodies: Council, Chapter and College of Canons. Together they constituted the cathedral as a legal entity. Chapter directed and oversaw administration. Council was to further and support the work and to review Chapter’s direction. The College of Canons remained a clerical and honorary college with, among other things, the duty of electing a bishop under the Appointment of Bishops Act 1533. At least two-thirds of Chapter, beyond dean and residentiary canons, were to be lay. Cathedrals were ecclesiastical corporations excluded from Charity Commission registration. Best practice was borrowed, voluntarily, from charity codes. The Association of English Cathedrals published guidance that said as much.

On paper this was a system of checks. In practice it was a system of blur. Responsibilities were “unclear or ambiguous". Governance and management roles were often occupied by the same people. The Council’s review function was often courteous rather than forensic. The bishop’s relationship to Chapter was theologically thick and legally thin. Finance and risk sat too far from the body that was, in reality, running the place. Later criticisms noted that this confusion of governance and management had increased operational and financial risk for the sector.

The precipitating events for the 2021 Measure were the episcopal visitations at Peterborough and Exeter in 2016–17. The presenting issues were financial. The deeper issues were grip, culture and the absence of a trustee mind. The Bishop of Peterborough asked that the legislation itself be examined. The Archbishops’ Council established the Cathedrals Working Group. Its report of 2018 is still the intellectual source of the present law. It proposed retaining Chapter as the governing body – "its praying heart is also its governing heart" – but with:

  • a non-executive majority, at least two-thirds of the non-executives lay
  • retaining the dean as chair
  • separating governance from management through a senior executive team
  • strengthening finance, audit and risk
  • introducing a quinquennial assurance review
  • the bishop having a more direct relationship through a senior independent lay member
  • abolishing statutory Councils
  • bringing Chapters under the Charities Act

It was careful - and right - to warn against the pendulum swinging from under-regulation to suffocation. Cathedrals had been among the least regulated of church or charitable bodies. The answer was not to bury them in process.

The 2021 settlement

The Cathedrals’ Measure 2021 received Royal Assent on 29 April 2021. It is the single greatest change in English cathedral governance in a generation. Implementation was staged. For each cathedral there was a "certificate date 1", when the new governing instruments took effect, and a "certificate date 2", when the charity provisions bit and Chapter came within the Charity Commission’s jurisdiction. By the summer of 2024, all 42 Church of England cathedrals to which the Measure applies (Christ Church, Oxford, remaining a special case) were registered charities, co-regulated by the Charity Commission and the Church Commissioners. David Holdsworth, then the Commission’s chief executive, put the boundary cleanly with the Southwark precedent: the Commission does not regulate spiritual mission or doctrine; it co-regulates the charity. Deans welcomed the chance to “steward our resources with great care and accountability” and to belong visibly to wider society as well as to the mission of the church.

The modern cathedral governance architecture is now as follows:

Chapter is the body corporate. The three-part corporation is gone. The body corporate consists only of Chapter. Members of Chapter have the general control and management of the administration and are the charity trustees of the Chapter for the purposes of the Charities Act 2011. Chapter is subject to the control of the High Court in the exercise of the court’s jurisdiction with respect to charities. That is a change of legal personality and of personal duty.

Membership is split. Members are the dean, the residentiary canons and such others as the constitution provides. Executive members are the dean and those residentiary canons who carry out cathedral duties. All others are non-executive. There must be more non-executives than executives. Constitutions must provide for terms of office for non-executives. This is the Measure’s answer to Stigand’s problem in modern dress: the people who run the place day-to-day must not be the majority of the people who hold them to account.

The dean remains chair and principal dignitary next after the bishop. The dean must govern and direct, on behalf of Chapter, the life and work of the cathedral, ordering worship, promoting mission and doing so as Chapter’s agent, not as a freeholder. The dean is accountable to Chapter for cathedral functions; cathedral clergy are accountable to Chapter through the dean. This is the hinge of the whole reform. A praying community led by its dean is retained. A dean unaccountable to the trustee body is not.

Management is given statutory shape. Constitutions must provide for a chief operating officer and a chief finance officer. They must establish a Nominations Committee and, save where Chapter can justify a different arrangement proportionate to scale, a Finance Committee and an Audit and Risk Committee. These arrangements are not optional. They are how a trustee body without a large executive infrastructure still discharges duties that the Charity Commission will recognise.

The College of Canons continues, but neither the College nor its members form part of the body corporate. Its historic functions, including the election of a bishop, remain. Stakeholder engagement, which the old Council was supposed to provide, is now Chapter’s to design.

The bishop is Visitor and is treated, for Charity Tribunal purposes, as a person who may be affected by a Commission decision, direction or order. The Working Group’s hope of a “more direct and positive relationship” with Chapter, without collapsing the dean’s presidency, is written into that design. It only works if it is used with restraint. Visitations are a nuclear instrument. Everyday governance should not require them.

Property and finance remain cathedral-specific. The fabric, the precinct, restricted funds, the Church Commissioners’ support and the visitor economy sit inside a charity wrapper they were not designed for. That is not a reason to pretend they are ordinary. It is a reason for trustees who can read both languages.

Dual regulation and the unfinished cultural work

Dual regulation is now the fact of life. In effect this can be seen to perturb some Chapters whilst flattering others. Neither reaction is useful. The Church Commissioners retain ecclesiastical and financial functions. The Charity Commission brings the ordinary law of trusteeship: fiduciary duty, conflicts, serious incident reporting, safeguarding as a trustee responsibility, and accounts that mean what they say. Official warnings issued to diocesan boards of finance in 2026 for failures of safeguarding oversight are serious matters for local action. “We follow national church policy” is not, by itself, trustee oversight. Trustees must know that the policy is working for their particular cathedral.

The legal architecture is largely in place. New constitutions and statutes have been adopted. Committees exist. Registration numbers have been issued. The unfinished work is behavioural. We see the same pattern after every statutory reform in public-purpose organisations. Muscle memory snaps back. Papers lengthen. Committees multiply. Assurance acquires extra storeys until the line of sight from Chapter to the shop floor, the loft and the cloister is lost. Performance is mistaken for assurance. The dean-as-chair arrangement, which is ecclesiologically right, becomes governance-sensitive unless there is a senior independent lay member who can actually convene the non-executives, appraise the chair and can raise the difficult issue.

Finance remains the hot spot. Peterborough’s later public appeals (a cathedral that had already worked through a multi-million-pound debt, still facing a seven-figure annual cost base and thin reserves) show that the 2017 visitation issues remain very much live issues. Energy, staff costs, restricted fabric funds and a volatile visitor market will defeat a Chapter that treats money as an afterthought to mission. Trustee duty here is not to "support the dean’s vision". It is to know whether the going-concern assumption is a plan or a hope.

Safeguarding, people and culture belong in the same conversation. A cathedral’s workforce is a peculiar mixture of clergy under common tenure, professional staff, volunteers who keep the place alive and contractors who keep it standing. Chapter is employer, trustee and, in the person of its executive members, colleagues. That is why the split between executive and non-executive is not a piece of imported company-law ritual. It is how conflicts are made visible rather than remain holy.

Purpose drift is the quiet risk. Civic hire, concerts, filming, cafés and heritage funding are often necessary to the second statutory object (the building) and sometimes to the first. They become illegitimate when they silently rewrite the objects. A Chapter that cannot say, on one page, what success looks like against the three objects and what it might need to stop doing is not governing. It is hosting.

Codes, King V, and outcomes 

Two documents sit on the Chapter table. The Cathedral Governance Code of 2021 adapts the Charity Governance Code to the sector: purpose, leadership, integrity, decision-making, risk, board effectiveness. It was written in the knowledge of “recent failures” and in the hope that implementation would be continuous improvement rather than a certificate on the wall. The 2025 Charity Governance Code adds a Foundation principle that GGi has welcomed: trustees must invest time in understanding their legal duties, their governing document and their context before they do anything clever. Apply or explain. 

We would add as helpful the outcomes associated with the King reports, which have shaped GGI’s work since 2009 and which King V has restated with new economy: ethical culture, good performance, effective control, legitimacy. They travel into the world of a cathedral with very little translation. Ethical culture is a Chapter that can talk about money, safeguarding, clergy conduct and welcome in the same register as worship. Good performance is not footfall alone and not "keeping the building open", but delivery of the objects. Effective control is finance, audit, risk and safeguarding that reach the floor. Legitimacy is with congregation, city, diocese, donors, staff, volunteers and a public that will no longer accept “because we are a cathedral” as an answer. Governance as stewardship with trustees as cyclical custodians of strategy, policy, oversight and accountability. Indeed, this is almost a perfect description of what a well-run cathedral already is when it is working. Integrated thinking across financial, built, human, social and spiritual capital is not just a South African import. It is how a precinct has always had to be understood, when it has been understood at all.

What governing looks like

A Chapter that is governing, rather than merely meeting, will be able to show the following.

  • a one-page expression of purpose that quotes the statutory objects and then localises them (this city, this diocese, this building, this century)
  • a strategy that treats fabric, worship, mission, people and money as one system, with a published risk appetite, including an appetite for commercial activity and an appetite for saying no to uses that hollow the place out
  • a real split between Chapter and the senior executive team: a COO and CFO with authority; residentiary canons clear whether they sit as executives; a senior independent lay member who can do the vice-chair job
  • finance and audit committees that own going concern, reserves, restricted funds and the fabric liability over ten to thirty years — not merely last year’s management accounts
  • safeguarding as a standing trustee responsibility, with serious incident reporting understood as a Chapter duty
  • a stakeholder map that replaces the old Council: bishop and diocese, city, congregation, staff, volunteers, Friends, schools, funders. Designed, not accidental
  • an annual board review and a periodic externally facilitated review. Every improvement journey begins with a review. Cathedrals are not exempt
  • lean, meaningful and transparent governance papers, as all boards should be working towards
  • a culture in which disagreement about money or risk is not treated as disloyalty to the house.

None of this is a demand that cathedrals become NHS trusts with better stone. It is a demand that they use the settlement they asked for. The Working Group was explicit: good governance only works if it is supported by a clear and robust management structure. Many of the strategic, operational and financial challenges in cathedrals stem from management focus and effectiveness, not from a shortage of committees. Leaner, smarter governance liberates time. Time is the scarcest resource in a precinct, as it is in a hospital. Boards that apply lean discipline to themselves lead by example.

Back to Anglo-Saxon England: handing on the hall

Stigand’s failure, reduced to a few words on the tapestry, is that he could not show a clean title to the office he occupied or proper separation between the office and himself. William and the legates solved that, as powerful people do, by deposition and confiscation. Good governance is the business of making it harder for a Chapter to drift into the same confusion by accident and easier for it to notice when it has.

The Bayeux Tapestry is a masterpiece of narrative control. It names Stigand because naming him served a purpose. Good governance is, among other things, the discipline of addressing issues while there is still time and being clear about roles and accountabilities: who holds the hall, on what terms, for whom and how we will know if we are failing.

England’s cathedrals have practised a form of stewardship for a thousand years. The 2021 Measure did not invent their duty. It removed the alibi that the duty was unclear. Five years on, the statutes are in force, and the charity numbers have been issued. The remaining question is the only one that ever matters in this work. Are Chapters trustee boards that pray, or chapters that have acquired some trustee paperwork?

A cathedral that is well governed is not less sacred. It is more usable by the people it exists for including both the living and those not yet born. That is what the keeper of the hall is for and what Stigand forgot. The tapestry, back among us for a season, is a useful aide-mémoire.

 

Selected references

  • Cathedrals Measure 1999; Cathedrals Measure 2021; Charities Act 2011.
  • Cathedrals Working Group, Report (GS 2101A, 2018).
  • Association of English Cathedrals, Cathedral Governance Code (2021); Good Governance: a Guide for Cathedral Chapters.
  • Charity Governance Code (2020; 2025).
  • King Committee, King IV and King V.
  • British Museum, The Bayeux Tapestry (10 September 2026–11 July 2027).
  • On Stigand: Oxford Dictionary of National Biography; John of Worcester; William of Malmesbury; Liber Eliensis; PASE / Domesday.

Andrew Corbett-Nolan

Chief executive and senior partner

Find out more

Janice Smith

Principal consultant

Find out more

Prepared by GGI Development and Research LLP for the Good Governance Institute.

Enquire about this article

Enquire
Contact us