The governance implications of The Hillsborough Law
23 July 2026
GGi CEO Professor Andrew Corbett-Nolan asks what The Public Office (Accountability) Act 2026 means for UK public authority governance
Points raised in this article:
- The 'Hillsborough Law' creates organisational duties and personal accountability for candour
- It complements, rather than replaces, the NHS Duty of Candour
- Boards must embed ethical conduct, transparency and inquiry readiness
- Cultural change, not box-ticking compliance, will determine its impact
Public authorities across the UK stand at a pivotal moment in the evolution of governance and accountability. In this article, I trace the development of statutory duties of candour from the New York State Public Authorities Accountability Act of 2005 and earlier UK private members’ bills through to the landmark Public Office (Accountability) Act 2026. I also explore how this legislation complements the existing NHS duty of candour, strengthens the ethical foundations of public bodies, and will drive higher standards as measured by GGi’s Public Bodies Governance Maturity Matrix. Finally, I present practical checklists for individual office holders and governance teams, together with reflections on how the Act will shape future governance reviews and super reviews.
The long-awaited statutory duty of candour for public authorities is finally taking legislative form. The Public Office (Accountability) Bill, introduced by the government on 16 September 2025 and commonly known as the Hillsborough Law, reached Report Stage in the House of Commons earlier this month. Upon Royal Assent it will become the Public Office (Accountability) Act 2026.
This landmark legislation responds to decades of public inquiries exposing institutional defensiveness, cover-ups and failures of openness. It builds on earlier structural reforms and private members’ efforts while complementing the existing NHS duty of candour. For boards, governance professionals and public bodies it represents both a compliance imperative and a powerful catalyst for cultural improvement.
At GGi we see this as a defining moment that will elevate expectations across our public bodies governance maturity matrix and reshape how we conduct governance reviews and, within NHS organisations, our new ‘super reviews’.
Precursors: structural accountability in New York and the UK post-Hillsborough campaign
The concept of legislating for greater accountability in public bodies has international heritage. In the United States, New York State enacted the Public Authorities Accountability Act of 2005 (PAAA) following concerns about opacity and weak oversight in the state’s numerous public authorities.
The PAAA introduced mandatory governance reforms: board training on fiduciary and ethical duties, requirements for audit and governance committees, enhanced transparency and reporting obligations, and oversight by the Authorities Budget Office. Evaluations in subsequent years noted improvements in board engagement and some reduction in governance failures, though cultural change proved slower than structural reform.
In the UK, the push for a statutory duty of candour gained momentum after the Hillsborough disaster in 1989. The Hillsborough Independent Panel (2012) and subsequent inquests revealed decades of misleading statements and withheld information by public bodies. Similar patterns emerged in the Grenfell Tower Inquiry, the Infected Blood Inquiry and other reviews such as the East Kent Maternity Services investigation, which explicitly recommended legislation to enforce candour on public authorities.
A Private Member’s Bill, the Public Authority (Accountability) Bill, was introduced in 2017 (sponsored by Andy Burnham and others) and reintroduced in 2025 by Ian Byrne MP. It proposed a broad duty of candour, a code of ethics, offences for non-compliance and support for bereaved families. While it did not progress fully, it kept the issue alive and shaped the government’s eventual bill.
The 2025 bill refined and advanced these ideas into a comprehensive package that addressed both individual conduct and organisational culture.
Core provisions of the new Public Office (Accountability) Act 2026
The Act imposes a statutory duty of candour, transparency and frankness on public authorities and public officials in their dealings with inquiries and investigations (sections 2–4 and Schedule 1). Public authorities must proactively notify relevant information, provide full assistance, correct errors and ensure staff comply. The duty applies to a wide range of formal processes, including those under the Inquiries Act 2005 and coroners’ investigations.
Public authorities are defined broadly (Schedule 2) to include government departments, NHS bodies, local authorities, police forces, schools and further education providers, social landlords, regulators, arm’s length bodies, some universities and higher education institutions – to the extent they exercise public functions – and other entities exercising public functions. Public officials are those working for or holding office under such authorities.
A key innovation is the explicit requirement for public authorities to promote and maintain high standards of ethical conduct across the organisation (section 9). This includes adopting and publishing a code of ethical conduct that incorporates the duty of candour, disciplinary consequences for breaches, protected disclosure mechanisms and complaint routes. The principles mirror the Nolan Principles of selflessness, integrity, objectivity, accountability, openness, honesty, and leadership, which is now given statutory reinforcement.
New criminal offences are created for serious failures:
- intentional or reckless non-compliance with the duty of candour that impedes an inquiry (up to two years’ imprisonment)
- misleading the public in a seriously improper manner
- certain seriously improper acts or breaches of duty by holders of public office that cause critical harm
The common-law offence of misconduct in public office is abolished and replaced by these clearer statutory provisions.
The Act also strengthens participation and support for affected persons at inquests and inquiries (Part 4 and Schedule 6), including measures to improve ‘parity of arms’ through guidance on proportionate legal representation and expanded non-means-tested legal aid for bereaved families in relevant cases.
These provisions create both organisational duties and personal accountability, with potential criminal liability for individuals in serious cases.
Complementing the existing NHS Duty of Candour
The NHS has been in front on this agenda for more than a decade with the Duty of Candour. However, the new Act does not replace the existing statutory duty of candour under Regulation 20 of the Health and Social Care Act 2008 (Regulated Activities) Regulations 2014. That duty, introduced following the Francis Inquiry into Mid Staffordshire NHS Foundation Trust (2013), requires registered health and social care providers to be open and transparent with patients or service users (and their representatives) when a notifiable safety incident occurs.
Providers must notify the relevant person, provide a truthful account, offer an apology, and provide support. It is enforced by the Care Quality Commission (CQC) and applies at the individual patient level in the immediate aftermath of harm.
The Public Office (Accountability) Act 2026 operates at a different but complementary level. It focuses on candour and assistance during formal inquiries, investigations and public scrutiny processes. It applies more broadly across public authorities (not just CQC-registered providers) and introduces criminal sanctions for serious breaches in those contexts. It also requires organisations to embed ethical conduct and candour into their governance frameworks and cultures.
Together, the two duties create a layered expectation of openness with patients when things go wrong buttressed by full candour and cooperation when public bodies are held to account through formal processes. Governance teams will need to ensure policies, training and assurance mechanisms address both.
Driving maturity: the GGi public bodies governance maturity matrix
GGi’s public bodies governance maturity matrix, launched in July 2025, provides a structured framework for arm’s-length bodies and other public organisations to assess their governance across domains including leadership, assurance, stakeholder engagement, and, crucially, governance and ethical standards.
The matrix helps boards move from basic compliance (Level 1–2) through developing and embedded practice to exemplar status (higher levels). The Public Office (Accountability) Act 2026 will accelerate progress up this maturity curve, particularly in the ethical standards, transparency, accountability and culture domains.
Organisations at lower maturity levels will face significant risk: weak codes, poor speaking-up cultures, inadequate board oversight of inquiries or defensive behaviours could now constitute not only governance failure but also potential legal exposure. Higher-maturity organisations – those with proactive candour cultures, robust ethical frameworks, and integrated assurance – will be better positioned to demonstrate compliance and resilience.
Practical checklists for implementation
For individual office holders (board members, executives, and senior public officials)
- Familiarise yourself with the Act’s definitions of public authority/official and the scope of the duty of candour and assistance. Understand your personal exposure under the new offences.
- Champion a culture of candour by visibly supporting staff who raise concerns and modelling openness in board and committee discussions.
- Ensure you receive targeted training on the Act, its interaction with the existing NHS Duty of Candour (where relevant) and own your organisation’s ethical code.
- Review personal declarations of interest, expenses, and decision-making records for completeness and transparency.
- When involved in or overseeing an inquiry or investigation, proactively consider what information should be disclosed and document the rationale.
- Hold yourself and colleagues to account for timely correction of any misleading statements or errors.
- Reflect on how your leadership style supports or hinders psychological safety and the free flow of information.
For governance teams and boards
- Conduct a gap analysis of existing policies, codes of conduct and speaking-up frameworks against the Act’s requirements (duty of candour, ethical conduct promotion, and victim support measures).
- Update the organisation’s code of ethical conduct to explicitly incorporate the statutory duty of candour and the Nolan Principles, with clear disciplinary consequences.
- Develop or refresh board and staff training programmes, ensuring they cover both the patient-facing NHS duty of candour and the inquiry-focused duties under the new Act.
- Strengthen board reporting and assurance mechanisms so that compliance with candour obligations, inquiry readiness, and ethical culture indicators are routinely scrutinised.
- Integrate the Act into the organisation’s risk register, internal audit programme and governance effectiveness reviews.
- Prepare ‘inquiry readiness’ protocols, including clear escalation routes, record retention policies and support arrangements for staff and affected persons.
- Use GGi’s Public Bodies Governance Maturity Matrix to benchmark current position and track improvement, with particular focus on the ethical standards and transparency domains.
- Engage early with legal, HR and communications colleagues to ensure consistent, organisation-wide understanding and implementation.
Implications for GGi governance reviews and our NHS ‘super reviews’
The Act will materially influence GGI’s approach to governance reviews and our more intensive ‘super reviews’. We will incorporate explicit assessment of:
- evidence that the duty of candour and ethical conduct requirements are understood, embedded and actively overseen at board level
- quality of codes, training, and cultural indicators (e.g., Freedom to Speak Up data, whistleblowing outcomes, inquiry response quality)
- board papers and minutes demonstrating proactive consideration of candour obligations
- alignment between the organisation’s self-assessment on the GGi maturity matrix and observable behaviours during reviews or simulated inquiry scenarios.
Organisations that treat the Act as a box-ticking exercise will be exposed; those that use it as a catalyst for genuine cultural improvement will demonstrate higher maturity and greater resilience. GGi is already preparing guidance and development programmes to help clients move from compliance to exemplar practice in this area.
An opportunity for authentic accountability
The Public Office (Accountability) Act 2026 represents the culmination of decades of campaigning and inquiry recommendations. It moves the Nolan Principles from aspiration toward enforceable expectation and layers a powerful inquiry-focused duty of candour onto the existing patient-focused NHS framework.
For public authorities and their boards, the message is clear: structural compliance alone will be insufficient. Sustainable change requires visible leadership, robust governance systems, and a culture in which candour is normalised rather than exceptional.
At GGi we believe this legislation offers a genuine opportunity to strengthen public trust. We stand ready to support boards and governance teams in turning statutory requirements into everyday practice through targeted reviews, maturity assessments, training and practical implementation support.
The era of “institutional instinct which… will prefer concealment” must finally end. The Public Office (Accountability) Act 2026 provides the legal framework; effective governance will determine whether it delivers the cultural transformation that victims, families and the public deserve.
References and further reading (selected)
- Public Office (Accountability) Bill documents and factsheets, UK Parliament and GOV.UK (2025–2026)
- The Report of the Mid Staffordshire NHS Foundation Trust Public Inquiry (Francis, 2013)
- Hillsborough Independent Panel Report (2012) and related inquest findings
- GGi Public Bodies Governance Maturity Matrix (July 2025) and supporting materials
- CQC guidance on Regulation 20 Duty of Candour
- Committee on Standards in Public Life, First Report [PDF] (Nolan Principles, 1995) and subsequent updates