The Charity Commission for England and Wales: what boards need to know
01 October 2026
Andrew Corbett-Nolan sets out the commission's role, powers and expectations of trustees, and what boards can learn from its most instructive inquiries.
Points raised
- Charity trustees share six core duties, held collectively by the board.
- Conflicts of interest and weak controls are recurring themes in failing charities.
- Board capacity must keep pace with organisational growth and complexity.
- Inquiry reports offer boards rich, practical lessons in governance.
The Charity Commission for England and Wales is the independent registrar and regulator of charities in England and Wales. It is a non-ministerial government department accountable directly to Parliament. For the boards and trustees of the roughly 170,000 charities on its register, which range from small community organisations to large national institutions with combined income and expenditure exceeding £100 billion, understanding its statutory role, strategy, expectations of trustees, investigative powers and the practical implications for accountability is essential.
Origins and evolution
The commission’s roots lie in the Charitable Trusts Act 1853, which created the charity commissioners to oversee charitable trusts. Successive legislation modernised and strengthened its position. The Charities Act 1960 introduced a formal register. The Charities Act 1993 and especially the Charities Act 2006 placed the commission on a clearer statutory footing as a corporate body. The Charities Act 2011 consolidated the framework and set out the commission’s five statutory objectives. Further powers came through the Charities (Protection and Social Investment) Act 2016 and administrative simplifications through the Charities Act 2022.
The commission is independent of ministerial direction in the exercise of its functions. Section 13(4) of the Charities Act 2011 provides that it “shall not be subject to the direction or control of any Minister of the Crown or other government department.” Accountability is to Parliament through its annual report and accounts and through the relevant select committees.
Strategy 2024–2029
In February 2024 the commission published its strategy for 2024–2029. Its ambition is to be “the expert Charity Commission that is fair, balanced and independent so that charity can thrive.” Five priorities guide its work:
- fair and proportionate regulation and clarity about its role
- support for charities to get things right, coupled with robust action where there is wrongdoing or harm
- speaking with authority and credibility, free from external influence
- embracing technological innovation and strengthening the use of data
- building an expert organisation in which people are empowered to deliver excellence in regulation
The strategy is risk-led. The commission focuses resources on the most serious risks to public trust, charitable assets and beneficiaries. Its second annual Charity Sector Risk Assessment (published August 2026) highlighted rising complexity: a sustained increase in concerns about private benefit abuse, safeguarding issues (around a quarter of concerns in recent years), governance weaknesses, and cases linked to geopolitical tensions and social divisions. The commission reported a 29% increase in private-benefit concerns in 2025–26 and noted that it had passed information to other agencies (HMRC, police, local authorities) on 500 occasions in the preceding year.
Dame Julia Unwin became the commission’s chair on 1 January 2026 for a three-year term. David Holdsworth has been chief executive (and accounting officer) since July 2024. The board comprises the chair and up to eight other members appointed by the secretary of state.
What the commission expects of charity trustees
Charity trustees (whether called trustees, directors, board members or governors) have independent control of, and legal responsibility for, the management and administration of their charity. The commission’s core guidance, The Essential Trustee (CC3), sets out six main duties:
- Ensure the charity is carrying out its purposes for the public benefit
- Comply with the charity’s governing document and the law
- Act in the charity’s best interests
- Manage the charity’s resources responsibly
- Act with reasonable care and skill
- Ensure the charity is accountable
These duties are collective. Trustees must take decisions properly, manage conflicts of interest, maintain adequate financial controls, and ensure timely filing of annual returns, accounts and reports. Serious incident reporting is required for adverse events that result in, or risk, significant loss of funds or assets, harm to beneficiaries, or damage to the charity’s work or reputation.
The commission expects boards to be independent of the executive, to meet regularly, to receive and scrutinise proper information, and to hold the executive to account. Weak, captured or poorly informed boards create regulatory risk. The Charity Governance Code (of which the commission is an observer rather than a member) provides non-statutory good-practice principles covering organisational purpose, leadership, integrity, decision-making, board effectiveness, equality, diversity and inclusion, and openness and accountability.
Support and information for trustees
The commission invests heavily in guidance. The Essential Trustee remains the foundational document. It is supplemented by a large library of topic-specific guidance covering financial controls, decision-making, conflicts of interest, safeguarding, grant-making, connections with non-charities, and many other areas. Short “five-minute guides” and practical tools are designed for busy volunteer trustees. The commission’s online services (including My Charity Commission Account) enable registration, filing and some permissions processes. Trustees can also seek formal advice under section 110 of the Charities Act in complex or high-risk situations; acting on that advice in good faith provides legal protection.
The commission’s stance is that most trustees want to get things right and that clear, accessible guidance is the primary means of support. It repeatedly urges trustees actually to use the guidance rather than rely solely on advisers or leave compliance to staff.
Investigations and enforcement
Where the commission has regulatory concerns it can open a compliance case or, in more serious situations, a statutory inquiry under section 46 of the Charities Act 2011. During an inquiry it has wide powers to require information, freeze bank accounts, restrict transactions, appoint interim managers, remove or suspend trustees, and take other protective steps. Findings of misconduct or mismanagement can lead to disqualification and entry on the Register of Removed Trustees.
Recent high-profile work has included inquiries into governance failings at Mermaids (findings of mismanagement published 2024), class inquiries into groups of charities involved in cheque-cashing arrangements, investigations into sports and community charities over financial management and conflicts, and cases involving alleged links to extremism or expenditure outside charitable purposes. The commission has also dealt with a significant volume of safeguarding-related concerns.
Recent criticisms
The commission itself has faced criticism. In 2026 the House of Commons Privileges Committee found that the commission had committed a contempt of Parliament by taking legal action aimed at preventing the Parliamentary and Health Service Ombudsman from laying special reports before the house. The commission apologised. Separate concerns have been raised about the speed and quality of some case handling, about perceived inconsistencies in high-profile inquiries, and about the balance between support and enforcement. The commission has responded by emphasising its statutory independence, its risk-led approach, and its dual role of supporting the well-intentioned majority while taking robust action against wrongdoing.
Rich learning: investigations by the Charity Commission
The Charity Commission’s investigative work remains one of the most practical sources of learning for charity trustees. When the commission opens a statutory inquiry under section 46 of the Charities Act 2011, or escalates a regulatory compliance case, the resulting published reports almost always turn on failures of governance that boards can recognise and guard against. The following inquiries are particularly instructive.
The Captain Tom Foundation (inquiry report published November 2024) - The Commission found repeated instances of misconduct and/or mismanagement by Hannah Ingram-Moore (former trustee and CEO) and Colin Ingram-Moore (former trustee). There was a clear pattern of behaviour in which the family repeatedly benefited personally from their involvement with the charity. Key failings included:
- the failure to manage conflicts of interest arising from links to their private companies
- the handling of publishing deals for books by the late Captain Sir Tom Moore, where the public reasonably expected sales to benefit the charity but no material donation was made
- unauthorised trustee benefits
- the inappropriate use of the charity’s name in a planning application for a private spa building.
The unconflicted trustees were also criticised for insufficient oversight, although their ability to manage conflicts was limited by incomplete disclosure. Both Ingram-Moores were disqualified from trusteeship and senior charity management roles (for 10 and 8 years respectively).
The case is a textbook illustration of the dangers of blurred boundaries between private and charitable interests, especially in founder- or family-linked charities. Boards must insist on early, full disclosure of conflicts, independent decision-making by unconflicted trustees, proper authorisation of any benefit, and clear separation of intellectual property and commercial arrangements. High public profile offers no protection; if anything, it intensifies scrutiny.
RNIB (Royal National Institute of Blind People) and RNIB Charity (inquiry report published June 2020) - The commission described this as one of the worst examples it had uncovered of poor governance and oversight having a direct impact on vulnerable people. Systemic shortcomings in safeguarding across RNIB’s regulated care and educational establishments, combined with weak corporate governance, placed beneficiaries at undue risk and, in some cases, resulted in actual harm. Oversight committees provided only superficial scrutiny and, for a period, did not meet for ten months. The board lacked sufficient skills and expertise in safeguarding and the management of regulated services; its composition rules (requiring a high proportion of elected and visually impaired trustees) limited the ability to recruit the necessary expertise. An official warning was issued and a detailed action plan imposed.
The lasting lessons concern board composition and the quality of oversight. Large or complex charities delivering regulated services need skills-based boards capable of rigorous challenge. Passive acceptance of executive reports, infrequent or ineffective committee scrutiny, and structural barriers to bringing in the right expertise create serious risk. Safeguarding is not an operational detail to be left to staff; it is a core trustee responsibility that requires active, informed board-level oversight.
Mermaids (inquiry report published October 2024) - The commission found that the charity’s governance, culture and practices had not kept pace with its rapid growth in size, public profile and demand for services. Trustees failed to address internal cultural issues, carried out insufficient due diligence when recruiting trustees, and did not properly apply their own HR policies to the supervision of the former chief executive. The inquiry did not uphold more sensational allegations, but the governance findings were clear: rapid growth without matching board capacity and process creates real risk.
Fashion for Relief and similar high-profile cases - Inquiries into charities associated with prominent individuals have repeatedly highlighted unauthorised benefits, weak financial controls, and failure to maintain independent oversight when a dominant founder or celebrity figure is involved. Collective trustee responsibility remains absolute.
Class inquiry into cheque-cashing arrangements (opened 2025 and expanded thereafter) - Following identification of 105 charities exchanging cheques for cash totalling £22 million, the commission examined how trustees had overseen these transactions and whether funds had been applied for charitable purposes. The case underscores that apparently routine financial practices can conceal serious risk and that “we didn’t know” is rarely an adequate defence when basic controls are absent.
Common themes from investigations with high learning value
Across these inquiries the same failures recur:
- inadequate management of conflicts of interest and private benefit
- weak financial controls and poor documentation of decision-making
- failure to keep governance capacity aligned with organisational growth or complexity
- insufficient challenge of dominant individuals or executives
- structural or cultural barriers to bringing the right skills onto the board
- delayed or incomplete engagement once concerns have been raised.
Boards that treat published inquiry reports as a standing source of learning asking “could this happen here and what would prevent it?” significantly reduce their own regulatory risk. The commission’s consistent message is that most trustees act in good faith; the difference between a well-run charity and one that ends up in formal inquiry is usually the quality of everyday board oversight, record-keeping, conflict management and the willingness to confront difficult issues early.
Summarising the Charity Commission’s role and charity boards
Boards of charities in England and Wales operate in an environment of heightened public and regulatory expectation. Trustees must understand their six core duties, ensure the board is properly constituted and independent, treat the governing document and public benefit as living constraints on decision-making, maintain robust financial and risk controls, and engage seriously with the commission’s guidance. Serious incidents must be reported promptly. When the commission engages, whether through guidance, a compliance case or a formal inquiry, boards are expected to respond constructively and to demonstrate that they are capable of putting matters right.
The quality of board-level governance in charities is itself part of the case for public trust and continued support. Charities that can show active, informed and independent oversight are better placed to withstand scrutiny, to protect their beneficiaries and assets, and to sustain the confidence on which the sector depends. The Charity Commission’s role is to uphold that confidence by ensuring that the legal framework is understood, observed and, where necessary, enforced.