Schemes of publication: what they mean for boards of public bodies

17 September 2026

Joanna Watson on publication schemes: what boards must publish, why only a quarter of authorities get it right, and what an unminuted away-day costs you.

 

In this article:

- A statutory board duty most directors quietly delegate and forget 

- Only a quarter publish what the ICO expects — Barnet's breach 

- Private sessions are legitimate; creeping, unrecorded ones are a warning

- Board away-days: the deliberation nobody minutes, and nobody can prove

 

Publication schemes are one of the most under-discussed statutory duties that sit directly with the boards of public bodies. They are not a technical Freedom of Information (FOI) housekeeping matter to be left to the company secretary or information governance team. They are a formal, ongoing commitment by the organisation, and therefore by those who govern it, to make significant categories of information routinely available to the public. 

When the scheme is weak, poorly maintained or only partially observed, the gap between the organisation’s formal transparency commitments and its actual practice becomes visible. That gap is a governance issue.

These matters are important for directors to really understand. To help explain the director duties concerned this article sets out the legal basis of publication schemes across the United Kingdom, explains what the model schemes require, examines how practice varies between sectors, and focuses on the practical implications for boards and directors. It pays particular attention to the recording of private (“in camera”) sessions and the common absence of proper records for board seminars and development sessions. The aim is to equip board members with clear questions they can ask and a practical sense of what good assurance looks like.

Legal basis and territorial coverage

In England, Wales and Northern Ireland the duty arises under section 19 of the Freedom of Information Act 2000. Every public authority must adopt and maintain a publication scheme approved by the Information Commissioner’s Office (ICO), publish information in accordance with that scheme, and review it from time to time. Since 2009 the ICO has required authorities to adopt its model publication scheme. The scheme must specify the classes of information to be published, the manner of publication, and whether material is free or charged. When adopting or reviewing the scheme the authority must have regard to the public interest in access to information and in the publication of reasons for decisions.

Wales is covered by the same FOIA 2000 framework. Welsh public authorities, including the Welsh Government, the Senedd Commission, NHS Wales bodies, local authorities and higher education institutions, adopt the ICO model scheme. There are additional Welsh-specific transparency expectations in other legislation and guidance, but the core publication-scheme duty is the UK one.

Scotland operates under a separate statutory regime: the Freedom of Information (Scotland) Act 2002 (FOISA). Scottish public authorities must adopt a publication scheme approved by the Scottish Information Commissioner. In practice virtually all have adopted the Commissioner’s own Model Publication Scheme (MPS). The Scottish scheme has nine classes of information rather than the seven used in the ICO model, and the statutory language places particular emphasis on the public interest in information about the cost and standards of services and the facts and analyses underlying major decisions. 

The principles are closely aligned with those south of the border, but the legal basis, the model document, the detailed classes and the oversight body are distinct. Boards of Scottish public bodies should therefore work to the Scottish Information Commissioner’s requirements and guidance rather than assuming the English/Welsh model applies unchanged. A more detailed comparison of the two regimes would merit a short companion note; the remainder of this article concentrates on the common ground while noting the Scottish distinction where it is material.

In all four nations the publication scheme is the proactive counterpart to the reactive right of access. It is intended to reduce the need for individual requests by placing core information in the public domain as a matter of routine.

The model schemes and the classes of information

The ICO model publication scheme (England, Wales and Northern Ireland) commits an authority to publish information falling within seven classes, where that information is held and is not exempt:

  • Who we are and what we do
  • What we spend and how we spend it
  • What our priorities are and how we are doing
  • How we make decisions
  • Our policies and procedures
  • Lists and registers
  • The services we offer

The Scottish Model Publication Scheme uses a similar structure with nine classes that cover the same broad territory, with additional emphasis on open data in some formulations.

Authorities are also required to produce and maintain a “guide to information” (or equivalent) that tells the public what is available under each class, how to obtain it, and what charges (if any) apply. The guide, the scheme itself and any schedule of fees should be easy to find on the organisation’s website.

The ICO (and the Scottish Commissioner) issue sector-specific definition documents or equivalent guidance that spell out the kinds of material expected under each class. These documents are not exhaustive checklists, but they set a clear expectation. Information that falls within the classes should be published unless it is not held, is exempt, is in draft form, has been archived and is difficult to access, or it would be impractical to prepare it for routine release.

What “how we make decisions” actually requires

Class 4 (or its Scottish equivalent) is the class that most directly engages the board. Definition documents for health bodies, higher education institutions and non-departmental public bodies all expect the proactive publication of agendas, supporting papers and minutes of the board and of those committees that take significant decisions about services, strategy or major resource allocation. The expected time period is typically the current year plus the previous two or three years.

Practice varies. Many NHS organisations in England publish substantial board packs (sometimes with redactions). Arts Council England and a number of other NDPBs publish National Council or board minutes, often with clear redaction notices citing commercial interests, future publication or other exemptions, but do not always release full supporting papers in the same way. Universities commonly publish governing-body and key committee minutes and agendas, though the volume of supporting papers varies.

The scheme does not require the publication of every internal discussion or every draft. It does require a serious attempt to place the formal record of decision-making in the public domain, subject to legitimate exemptions.

Redaction and exemptions

Redaction is both permitted and expected. The ICO guidance is clear that authorities need not publish information that is exempt under FOIA (or FOISA). Where only part of a document is exempt, redacted minutes are normally expected; it is accepted that it may be impractical to produce heavily edited versions of every other type of paper.

Common grounds for redaction include personal data, commercial interests, information intended for future publication, and prejudice to the effective conduct of public affairs. The key governance tests are consistency, proper reasoning, and transparency about the fact of redaction. Boards should know the high-level principles their organisation applies and receive assurance that those principles are followed in practice rather than used as a convenient default.

Implications for boards and directors

Publication schemes sit inside the board’s accountability for transparency, culture and compliance. Directors should be able to answer three linked questions:

  • Is the scheme itself up to date and compliant with the current model (ICO or Scottish Commissioner as appropriate)?
  • Does the material actually published match the commitments in the scheme and the relevant definition document?
  • Are the processes for deciding what is published, what is redacted and what remains private robust, consistent and subject to oversight?

These questions can be addressed through the assurance framework, the audit and risk committee work programme, or a periodic short report from the company secretary or FOI lead. Dedicated internal audit reviews of publication schemes remain uncommon; that does not mean the topic is outside the scope of assurance. A focused review of design, maintenance, redaction controls and alignment between published material and the scheme would be proportionate every few years.

Getting it wrong

This probably happens more than is apparent. One concrete illustration of the risks of weak application of a publication scheme that is in the public domain comes from a February 2026 decision notice concerning Barnet Homes Limited. A requester raised concerns that FOI responses were not being routinely published on the organisation’s website and asked for a list of responses covering an 11-month period. The Information Commissioner found that, at the time the request was received, Barnet Homes had not met its obligation under section 19(1)(b) of FOIA to publish information in accordance with its publication scheme. Although the organisation later remedied the position by publishing the responses, and the Commissioner decided against further formal action given staffing constraints and the subsequent corrective steps, the finding itself is clear: failure to keep the scheme’s commitments current and visible constitutes a breach of the statutory duty. 

For boards, the lesson is straightforward. A scheme that exists on paper but is not actively maintained and applied creates both regulatory exposure and reputational risk; the gap between formal commitment and actual publication is precisely what external scrutiny will test.

More broadly, the ICO’s own  snapshot of publication-scheme compliance across public authorities painted a concerning picture. While three-quarters had formally adopted the model scheme, only a quarter were publishing all the example information the ICO would expect under the relevant definition documents. Many schemes had not been reviewed for more than five years, broken weblinks were common, and evidence of dataset publication was rare. Small authorities struggled disproportionately. 

These findings underline that adoption of the model scheme is only the starting point; the real governance test is whether the organisation routinely publishes what it has committed to publish and keeps the scheme and guide to information under active review. Boards that treat the scheme as a living document rather than a one-off compliance exercise are far less likely to find themselves on the wrong side of such assessments. In 2025 the ICO published an interesting article on compliance issues that stated ‘It’s worth remembering that public authorities shouldn’t just look at publication schemes as a legal requirement’

Private (“in camera”) sessions – the importance of proper recording

Private sessions are legitimate. Commercial negotiations, identifiable personal data, live legal advice and certain sensitive operational matters often require confidentiality. The existence of a private session does not, however, remove the organisation from the reach of the publication scheme.

Good practice requires:

  • Written criteria, known to the board, that define when an item may properly be taken in private session. Vague or expansive criteria tend to expand over time.
  • A clear public record that a private session occurred, the broad nature of the business (without disclosing exempt detail), the decision reached where it is not itself exempt, and the exemption or reason relied upon.
  • A full private minute for the organisation’s own record and for any later FOI request or regulatory review.
  • Periodic review of the volume and nature of private business. A rising proportion of private items, or the regular appearance of routine strategy or performance matters in private session, is a warning sign.

The published minutes under the publication scheme should be the redacted or summarised account that meets the scheme’s Class 4 expectations. The private minute remains the definitive internal record.

Board seminars and development sessions – a common recording gap

Many boards hold seminars, away-days or development sessions that sit outside the formal meeting cycle. These sessions are often treated as informal and therefore left without any proper record. Attendance may be noted, but the topics covered, the issues explored and any emerging conclusions or actions frequently go unrecorded.

This creates an assurance and continuity problem. When a board later needs to demonstrate that it considered a particular strategic risk, cultural issue or regulatory development, the absence of any record of the seminar discussion becomes a weakness. It also sits awkwardly with the spirit of the publication scheme: if significant board-level deliberation is occurring outside the formal, minuted meetings, the public record of “how we make decisions” becomes incomplete.

Good practice does not require verbatim transcripts or the same level of formality as a statutory board meeting. It does require a short, factual note that records:

  • who was present
  • the topics or themes covered
  • any decisions, directions or actions that arose
  • any papers or external inputs that were considered.

Where the seminar is purely developmental and no decisions are taken, a brief attendance and agenda note may suffice. Where the discussion informs later formal decisions, a clearer link to the formal minute trail is needed. Boards should decide, as a matter of policy, how seminar records are to be kept and whether any summary belongs in the public domain under the publication scheme.

Practical prompts for board members

Directors may find the following questions useful to prompt their thinking about compliance:

  • When did the board last formally note or review the organisation’s publication scheme and guide to information?
  • Does the scheme (and the guide) reflect the current ICO or Scottish Commissioner model and the relevant sector definition document?
  • Looking at Class 4 material, do we routinely publish agendas, papers and minutes of the board and key decision-making committees for the expected time period, subject to legitimate redaction?
  • What written criteria govern the use of private sessions, and when were they last reviewed?
  • When we move into private session, is the reason and the broad nature of the business recorded in the public minutes in a way that is meaningful to an outside reader?
  • How do we assure consistency in redaction practice across board and committee papers?
  • Do board seminars and development sessions generate any formal record of attendance, topics and outcomes? If not, is that a conscious policy choice or an oversight?
  • Has internal audit or any other independent review ever examined the operation of the publication scheme and the boundary between public and private business?
  • Does our board assurance framework or audit committee work plan include periodic assurance on proactive transparency?

Tightening up on transparency 

Publication schemes are a statutory expression of the principle that public bodies should make core information available as a matter of routine rather than only on request. For boards they are also a practical test of transparency culture, record-keeping discipline and assurance. The legal frameworks differ between Scotland and the rest of the UK, but the underlying expectation is the same: organisations should be able to show that they have a current scheme, that they publish in accordance with it, and that the formal record of decision-making, including the careful handling of private sessions and the proper noting of seminar discussions, is coherent and defensible.

Boards that treat the scheme as a living commitment rather than a static compliance document strengthen both their external accountability and their internal grip on how decisions are made and recorded. That is good governance in practice.

Meet the author: Joanna Watson

Principal consultant

Email: joanna.watson@good-governance.org.uk Find out more

Prepared by GGI Development and Research LLP for the Good Governance Institute.

Enquire about this article

Enquire
Contact us