NHS audit committees

17 August 2026

Professor Andrew Corbett-Nolan focuses on one of the most important committees in any NHS organisation, and identifies what distinguishes effective, future-fit practice

 

Points raised in this article:

- Independence underpins credible scrutiny of governance, risk and control 

- Audit committees must challenge assurance, not merely review compliance

- Strong audit relationships strengthen accountability, transparency and public trust 

- King V reinforces outcomes-focused, independent and evidence-based governance.

 

Audit committees stand as the senior statutory committee of NHS boards and governing bodies. Their core purpose is not merely compliance or the mechanical review of accounts, but the independent scrutiny of the systems of governance, risk management and internal control on which the board places reliance.

They test whether those systems are the right ones, are in place, are working, are effective in driving improvement and are futureproofed. In an environment of sustained financial pressure, workforce challenge, cyber threat, integrated care complexity and heightened public expectation, this role has never been more critical.

GGi has consistently argued – and events have proved us right – that audit committees must move beyond checklist assurance to triangulated, evidence-based challenge that gives boards genuine confidence.

This article builds on that body of work, situating NHS practice within the legislative framework, UK-wide variations, comparative public-sector and charitable practice, and the enduring principles of the King Committee reports—particularly the recently issued King V Code on Corporate Governance (2025).

Legislative and regulatory framework

In England, the requirement for an audit committee is clearest for NHS foundation trusts under the National Health Service Act 2006 and the NHS Foundation Trust Code of Governance (and its successor mappings). The board must establish an audit committee of independent non-executive directors (minimum three, or two for smaller organisations). The chair of the board must not be a member, the vice-chair or senior independent director should not chair the committee, and at least one member should have recent and relevant financial experience.

The committee’s main roles include monitoring the integrity of financial statements, reviewing internal financial controls and risk management systems, overseeing internal and external audit effectiveness, and advising on whether the annual report and accounts are fair, balanced and understandable.

For NHS trusts the primary legislation is less prescriptive, but secondary legislation and NHS England statutory guidance make an audit committee a practical necessity, alongside the appointments/remuneration committee. Integrated care boards operate under the Health and Care Act 2022 framework and the Local Audit and Accountability Act 2014 arrangements for external audit. The HFMA NHS Audit Committee Handbook (updated 2024/2025) remains the sector’s practical bible, reflecting current structures including ICBs and group models.

In Scotland the National Health Service (Scotland) Act 1978 and the Scottish Government Audit & Assurance Handbook (updated versions referenced in board terms of reference) provide the foundation. Health boards must maintain effective systems of internal control and corporate governance. Terms of reference commonly require a minimum of three (often five) non-executive members; the board chair is excluded from membership but may have a right to attend.

In Wales, health board standing orders and Welsh Government expectations similarly require an independent audit committee. The chair of the organisation should not be a member and will not normally attend; membership is drawn from independent members with appropriate skills.

Across the UK, the HM Treasury Audit and Risk Assurance Committee Handbook (refreshed 2024/2025 to incorporate Global Internal Audit Standards) supplies cross-government principles on roles, private meetings with auditors, effectiveness self-assessment and emerging risks such as cyber security and whistleblowing. NHS bodies are expected to align with these expectations as public bodies spending public money.

Committee composition and UK variations

Independence is non-negotiable. Members must be free of management responsibility and, ideally, of any material financial dependence on the organisation. A minimum of three independent members is the near-universal baseline; collective competence in finance, governance, risk and the sector is essential. At least one member should possess recent and relevant financial experience.

A consistent principle, reinforced by King V, the UK Corporate Governance Code tradition and NHS guidance, is that the board chair should not be a member of the audit committee. This protects the committee’s ability to provide independent challenge. Practice on attendance varies. In Scotland it is not uncommon for the board chair to have a standing right to attend (while remaining excluded from membership). In England and Wales guidance more often advises that the board chair should not normally attend or should limit attendance (for example, to one meeting a year to support effectiveness evaluation). These differences reflect local constitutional traditions rather than any fundamental disagreement on independence; the key is that the committee’s deliberative independence is preserved.

Quorum is typically two or three independent members. Private sessions with internal and external auditors (without executives present) at least annually are regarded as essential good practice. Skills matrices, induction, ongoing development and periodic effectiveness reviews are expected.

Relationship with internal and external audit

The audit committee owns the relationship with both internal and external audit on behalf of the board. It approves (or recommends) the internal audit plan, monitors delivery and quality, reviews the head of internal audit opinion that underpins the annual governance statement, and ensures the function has the resources, independence and access it needs. With the introduction of the global internal audit standards, committees must also satisfy themselves on the governance of the internal audit function itself.

For external audit the committee oversees appointment processes (auditor panels in England under the Local Audit and Accountability Act arrangements, national audit bodies elsewhere), reviews the audit plan and findings, monitors independence and non-audit services, and considers the auditor’s report on the annual accounts and value-for-money conclusions. Private meetings without management remain a critical safeguard.

The committee also oversees local counter-fraud arrangements and receives reports from other assurance functions (clinical audit, information governance, cyber, speaking up). Its ultimate product is the contribution to the annual governance statement and the assurance that the board’s overall framework of control is sound.

Comparison with other public-sector and charitable audit committees

CIPFA’s Position Statement and practical guidance on audit committees in local authorities and police (2022 edition) articulate a strikingly similar purpose: an independent, high-level focus on the adequacy of governance, risk and control arrangements. Core functions—oversight of internal and external audit, review of the annual governance statement, financial reporting integrity, and risk management—mirror NHS expectations. Differences arise mainly in external auditor appointment (public sector audit appointments arrangements in English local government versus national auditors in Scotland, Wales and much of the NHS) and in the political composition of some local authority committees. The principles of independence, private access to auditors and annual effectiveness review are shared.

Charity audit (or finance and audit) committees offer a valuable comparative lens. Larger charities, under Charity Commission guidance (including CC8 on internal financial controls and the broader governance framework), establish committees to protect assets, ensure proper accounting, manage risk and maintain public trust. Trustees retain ultimate responsibility; the committee’s role is to provide independent scrutiny of controls, fraud risks and reporting. Independence, financial literacy, private access to auditors or independent examiners, and a clear link to the full board are common themes. Charities remind NHS committees that stewardship of public (or publicly donated) funds ultimately rests on trust, transparency and the willingness to ask uncomfortable questions about culture and behaviour as well as systems.

Best-practice points for NHS audit committees

  • Maintain strict independence: board chair excluded from membership; private sessions with auditors at least annually.
  • Ensure collective competence, including recent financial experience and sector knowledge; use skills matrices and targeted development.
  • Own the internal and external audit relationships: approve plans, monitor quality and independence, act on findings.
  • Focus on the system of governance, risk and control as a whole — not merely the board assurance framework report.
  • Demand triangulated, evidence-based assurance rather than single-source or compliance-only reporting.
  • Address emerging risks explicitly: cyber security, information governance, speaking-up culture, business continuity and supplier resilience.
  • Conduct rigorous annual effectiveness reviews and use structured maturity tools.
  • Report clearly and candidly to the board, highlighting residual risks and the quality of assurance received.
  • Align terms of reference, work plans and agendas with the legislative framework and the HFMA Handbook while remaining agile to local context.
  • Use GGi’s Audit Committee Maturity Matrix (and the accompanying board assurance prompt) as a developmental pathway from basic through improving to mature and future-fit practice. The matrices cover independence, assurance mapping, agendas, reporting, skills and culture, providing a shared language for continuous improvement.

King V as the foundational authority

The King Committee reports, culminating in King V (2025), remain the most influential global statement of outcomes-based, ethical, stakeholder-orientated governance. King V defines corporate governance as the exercise of ethical and effective leadership by the governing body towards ethical culture, performance and value creation, conformance and prudent control, and legitimacy. Principle 6 addresses committees of the governing body. An audit committee should comprise independent non-executive members; the governing body chair should not be a member; the committee should oversee assurance functions (including combined assurance), internal financial controls, the finance function and the integrity of external reports; and it should meet the auditors without management at least annually.

These principles travel well to the NHS. They reinforce independence, the primacy of substance over form, the need for combined assurance, and the committee’s role in supporting the board’s accountability for both conformance and performance. King V’s emphasis on outcomes rather than mechanistic compliance aligns directly with GGi’s long-standing argument that audit committees must move from “assurance theatre” to genuine insight.

Key learning points

  • NHS audit committees are the board’s primary independent assurance mechanism on governance, risk and control systems.
  • Legislative requirements differ across England, Scotland and Wales, but independence of membership and exclusion of the board chair are consistent principles.
  • Composition must prioritise independence, financial literacy and collective competence; attendance rights of the board chair vary by nation.
  • The relationship with internal and external audit is foundational: oversight of plans, quality, independence and findings, including private meetings.
  • Comparison with CIPFA local-government practice and Charity Commission expectations reveals shared principles of public stewardship and asset protection.
  • King V provides the enduring philosophical foundation: ethical leadership, independent committees, combined assurance and outcomes-focused governance.
  • GGi’s maturity matrices and board assurance prompts offer practical, evidence-based tools for moving from compliance to mature, future-proofed practice.
  • Effective audit committees ask probing questions about the quality and triangulation of assurance, not merely whether processes exist.
  • Annual effectiveness reviews and structured development are non-negotiable for sustained high performance.
  • In an era of system working and fiscal constraint, the audit committee’s role in protecting public value and organisational legitimacy has never been more important.

NHS audit committees that embrace these principles, grounded in legislation, sharpened by comparative insight, guided by King V’s outcomes orientation and supported by GGi’s developmental tools, will not only satisfy regulatory expectations but will actively strengthen the resilience, transparency and legitimacy of the organisations they serve. They are perhaps the key buttress to strong local governance for NHS and other public sector organisations. As such, they are essential to develop along best practice lines within any high-performing NHS organisation.

Meet the author: Andrew Corbett-Nolan

Chief executive and senior partner

Email: andrew.corbett-nolan@good-governance.org.uk Find out more

Prepared by GGI Development and Research LLP for the Good Governance Institute.

Enquire about this article

Enquire
Contact us