Governance of NHS health boards in Scotland

25 August 2026

Andrew Corbett-Nolan explores how Scotland’s distinctive NHS governance model shapes accountability and board effectiveness

 

Points raised in this article

- Scottish health boards operate within a distinct governance framework.

- The Blueprint for Good Governance sets expectations for effective board governance.

- System complexity is blurring accountability and decision-making.

- Strong challenge, assurance and collaboration are increasingly essential.

 

Scotland’s National Health Service operates under a distinct constitutional, legislative and accountability framework shaped by devolution and successive waves of public service reform. Unlike England’s mix of foundation trusts, trusts and integrated care boards, NHS Scotland is organised around territorial and national health boards that remain directly accountable to Scottish ministers. 

Understanding their governance is essential for anyone seeking to strengthen board effectiveness, assurance or system-wide reform. This article provides a wide-ranging, evidence-based account of the legal foundations, board composition, key standards, regulatory landscape and contemporary challenges facing health boards in Scotland. 

It draws on primary legislation, the Scottish Government’s Blueprint for Good Governance, Audit Scotland reports and the roles of scrutiny bodies such as Healthcare Improvement Scotland (HIS).

Constitutional and legislative foundations

NHS Scotland is not itself a legal entity. It is an umbrella description for a network of discrete statutory bodies. The foundational statute remains the National Health Service (Scotland) Act 1978, which places duties on Scottish ministers and the health boards they establish to promote the improvement of the physical and mental health of the people of Scotland and to provide a comprehensive health service. 

Boards are body corporates with their own legal personality, rights and liabilities, distinct from those of Scottish Ministers, yet they exercise functions on ministers’ behalf and are subject to ministerial direction under section 2(5) of the 1978 Act.

Subsequent legislation has layered additional requirements. The Public Bodies (Joint Working) (Scotland) Act 2014 fundamentally altered the landscape by requiring territorial health boards and local authorities to integrate adult health and social care functions, usually through integration joint boards (IJBs). The Public Services Reform (Scotland) Act 2010 reconstituted Healthcare Improvement Scotland and strengthened scrutiny powers. Other relevant instruments include the Health Boards (Membership and Procedure) regulations (as amended), the Gender Representation on Public Boards (Scotland) Act 2018, and the Public Finance and Accountability (Scotland) Act 2000, which underpins the accountable officer regime.

Scottish ministers determine policy, set the financial envelope through the annual budget process, appoint board members and hold ultimate political accountability to the Scottish Parliament. The Cabinet Secretary for Health and Social Care is the key political figure. Operationally, the Director General for Health and Social Care also serves as chief executive of NHS Scotland (a dual role that has attracted scrutiny) and is supported by a chief operating officer responsible for day-to-day performance management of the boards.

Structure of NHS Scotland

There are 14 territorial health boards responsible for the health of defined populations and the delivery of most frontline services:

  • NHS Ayrshire and Arran
  • NHS Borders
  • NHS Dumfries and Galloway
  • NHS Fife
  • NHS Forth Valley
  • NHS Grampian
  • NHS Greater Glasgow and Clyde
  • NHS Highland
  • NHS Lanarkshire
  • NHS Lothian
  • NHS Orkney
  • NHS Shetland
  • NHS Tayside
  • NHS Western Isles

In addition, there are national or special health boards and related bodies that provide specialist, support or all-Scotland services. These typically include Healthcare Improvement Scotland, NHS 24, NHS Golden Jubilee, Public Health Scotland, NHS National Services Scotland, the Scottish Ambulance Service and the State Hospital (with some lists also referencing NHS Education for Scotland or successor arrangements). Each board has its own governing body accountable through its chair to Scottish ministers.

Boards collectively employ more than 170,000 staff and manage expenditure measured in tens of billions of pounds annually, a substantial portion of which is delegated to the 31 IJBs.

Board composition, appointments and roles

A health board comprises a chair, non-executive members and executive members. The precise numbers are set by regulation for each board, but the pattern is consistent.

Non-executive members fall into two broad categories. 

Lay members are appointed through the regulated public appointments process overseen by the Ethical Standards Commissioner and conducted in accordance with the Commissioner’s Code of Practice (principles of merit, integrity, and diversity and equality). 

Stakeholder members, notably local authority councillors, are nominated by the relevant authorities and appointed by Ministers. The Gender Representation on Public Boards (Scotland) Act 2018 applies, creating a duty to achieve (or make progress toward) 50 per cent female non-executive membership where candidates are equally qualified.

Executive members are typically the chief executive, director of finance, medical director, nurse director and director of public health (or equivalent). They are employees of the board. An employee director (staff-side representative) is commonly included. All members share collective responsibility for the board’s decisions.

The chair is accountable to the cabinet secretary for the performance of the board and for ensuring effective governance. Non-executives are expected to provide constructive challenge, hold the executive to account, contribute to strategy, oversee risk and influence culture. Executives bring operational expertise while remaining subject to board oversight. The chief executive is designated the accountable officer and carries personal responsibility, under the Public Finance and Accountability (Scotland) Act, for the proper stewardship of public funds, regularity, propriety and value for money.

Appointments are values-based, involve application, psychometric assessment and interview, and are subject to Fit and Proper Person considerations. Board members are bound by the Principles of Public Life in Scotland and the board’s Members’ Code of Conduct. Remuneration and expected time commitments have been standardised in recent years to address recruitment difficulties, particularly for chairs and in rural boards.

The Blueprint for Good Governance and core principles

The definitive statement of expected practice is the Scottish Government’s Blueprint for Good Governance in NHS Scotland (second edition, November/December 2022). It defines governance as:

“…the means by which NHS Boards direct and control the healthcare system to deliver Scottish Government policies and strategies and ensure the long-term success of the organisation. It is the ability to ask questions and make decisions to improve population health and address health inequalities, while delivering safe, effective and high-quality healthcare services. It is to be distinguished from executive-led operational management.”

The Blueprint sets out ten principles of good governance that function as an executive summary of requirements. These include the need for the board to set strategic direction, hold executives to account for delivery, manage risk, engage stakeholders and influence organisational culture; the requirement for a diverse board with the necessary skills, experience, values, behaviours and relationships; and the importance of active, collaborative and continuously improving governance arrangements.

The model encompasses strategic planning and commissioning, an assurance framework, risk management, stakeholder engagement, performance management and the governance of change. Boards are expected to conduct annual self-assessments against the Blueprint and to develop action plans. Supporting concepts of ‘active governance’ (intelligent use of data and intelligence for assurance) and ‘collaborative governance’ (working across organisational boundaries) have been emphasised in response to system complexity.

Boards must also operate within the three established governance strands of clinical governance, financial governance and staff governance (the latter underpinned by the Staff Governance Standard). Counter-fraud arrangements, whistleblowing standards (with a designated non-executive whistleblowing champion) and information governance form further mandatory elements.

Accountability, performance management and escalation

Accountability runs from the board, through its chair, to the cabinet secretary and ultimately the Scottish Parliament. The dual role of the director general/chief executive of NHS Scotland creates a structural tension between strategic direction-setting and performance oversight that Audit Scotland has highlighted as requiring stronger independent assurance mechanisms.

Scottish Government operates a Performance Management Framework that includes a Ladder of Escalation. Boards facing significant difficulties in finance, performance, leadership or governance can be placed on higher stages of support and intervention. External audit is undertaken by auditors appointed by the Auditor General for Scotland under the Code of Audit Practice. Internal audit and the board’s audit and risk committee provide the first line of independent challenge. Boards must produce annual accounts, governance statements and performance reports that are subject to parliamentary and public scrutiny.

Integration joint boards and system complexity

The 2014 Act requires health boards and local authorities to integrate functions. Most areas adopted the body-corporate model, creating integration joint boards as separate legal entities. IJBs typically have equal numbers of voting members nominated by the health board (usually non-executives) and the local authority (councillors), plus non-voting professional and stakeholder members (chief social work officer, GP, nurse, secondary-care clinician, staff-side, third-sector, carer and service-user representatives). 

The IJB is responsible for strategic planning of delegated functions and issues directions to the health board and local authority for operational delivery. This multi-layered arrangement increases the complexity of accountability and decision-making — an issue repeatedly noted by Audit Scotland.

Regulation and scrutiny of NHS services

Regulation and external scrutiny of NHS services in Scotland are multi-layered.

Healthcare Improvement Scotland (HIS) is the principal national body for quality assurance and improvement. Established under the 1978 Act (as amended), HIS has a general duty to further improvement in the quality of healthcare. It conducts risk-based inspections of NHS hospitals and services (including the ‘safe delivery of care’ methodology for acute hospitals, adult mental health inpatient units and maternity services), develops national standards and indicators, and supports improvement programmes such as the Scottish Patient Safety Programme. 

HIS also regulates independent healthcare (independent hospitals, clinics, medical agencies and, more recently, certain pharmacy services). It possesses powers of entry, the ability to require information, and, in cases of serious risk to life, health or wellbeing, the power to direct a health board to close a ward to new admissions.

HIS works jointly with the Care Inspectorate on inspections of integrated adult health and social care services under the 2014 Act. The Mental Welfare Commission provides independent scrutiny of mental health and incapacity services. The Scottish Public Services Ombudsman handles complaints. Audit Scotland provides independent public audit and value-for-money reporting, including its 2025 NHS in Scotland: Spotlight on Governance report, which identified weaknesses in Scottish Government-level assurance processes, risks arising from the dual role of the director general/chief executive, and the growing complexity of multi-partner decision-making that can hinder reform.

Collectively these arrangements aim to provide independent assurance to the public and parliament while supporting continuous improvement. They sit alongside internal clinical, staff and financial governance systems within each board.

Contemporary challenges and implications for governance

Audit Scotland’s recent work underscores that governance arrangements must be strengthened if the scale of reform required for financial and operational sustainability is to be achieved. Planning and decision-making now involve a dense network of local, regional and national partners, blurring lines of accountability. Recruitment and retention of high-calibre chairs and non-executives remain challenging given time commitments, remuneration and the intensity of the operating environment. Boards must simultaneously deliver current services, manage financial pressure, implement national strategies and drive transformation—while maintaining robust assurance and public confidence.

Effective governance in this context demands rigorous adherence to the blueprint principles, strong independent non-executive challenge, clear escalation of risks, high-quality data and intelligence, genuine stakeholder engagement (including patients, carers and the third sector), and a culture that distinguishes strategic direction and assurance from operational management. Boards that treat the blueprint as a living framework for continuous self-assessment and improvement, rather than a compliance document, will be better placed to navigate complexity.

Conclusion

The governance of NHS Health Boards in Scotland rests on a clear statutory foundation in the 1978 Act, refined by the integration legislation of 2014 and operationalised through the Blueprint for Good Governance. Boards are discrete legal entities with collective responsibility, composed of ministerially appointed non-executives and executives, led by a chair accountable to ministers and a chief executive who is the accountable officer. External scrutiny by Healthcare Improvement Scotland, Audit Scotland and other bodies provides independent assurance, while the dual role at the apex of NHS Scotland creates both opportunities for alignment and risks that require careful management.

For practitioners, board members and those supporting governance development, the key messages are the primacy of independence and constructive challenge, the necessity of active and collaborative approaches, the centrality of the blueprint as the organising framework, and the need for clarity of accountability in an increasingly complex system. 

As elsewhere, in Scotland governance is understood as a key enabler of better public services. Strong corporate and clinical governance developed in Scotland away from a belief in an ‘internal market’ that for a time characterised the main driver of improvement for the NHS in England. 

Strengthening good governance and board accountability within the NHS in Scotland became the hallmark not just as a matter of good practice; it is a prerequisite for the sustainable, high-quality, equitable healthcare that Scottish legislation and policy demand. 

Key learning points 

  • NHS Scotland is not a single legal entity but an umbrella term for 14 territorial health boards plus national/special boards, all accountable to Scottish ministers.
  • The foundational legislation is the National Health Service (Scotland) Act 1978, supplemented by the Public Bodies (Joint Working) (Scotland) Act 2014 that created integration joint boards.
  • Every health board is a discrete body corporate with its own legal personality, rights and liabilities, yet remains subject to ministerial direction.
  • Board composition combines a ministerially appointed chair, lay and stakeholder non-executives, and executive directors (typically chief executive, finance, medical, nursing and public health directors), with collective responsibility.
  • Non-executive appointments follow the regulated public appointments process overseen by the Ethical Standards Commissioner, guided by principles of merit, integrity, diversity and equality.
  • The chief executive of each board is the accountable officer with personal responsibility for the proper use of public funds under the Public Finance and Accountability (Scotland) Act 2000.
  • The Scottish Government’s Blueprint for Good Governance in NHS Scotland (second edition, 2022) is the definitive framework, defining good governance and setting out core principles including strategic direction, accountability, risk management, stakeholder engagement and culture.
  • Boards must operate three interlocking governance strands — clinical governance, financial governance and staff governance — alongside counter-fraud, whistleblowing and information governance requirements.
  • Healthcare Improvement Scotland provides independent quality assurance, risk-based inspections of NHS services, standards development and regulation of independent healthcare, with powers including ward closure in cases of serious risk.
  • Audit Scotland’s external audit and value-for-money work, including the 2025 Spotlight on Governance report, highlight system complexity, dual-role risks at Scottish Government level and the need for stronger independent assurance.
  • Integration joint boards add a further layer of multi-partner accountability, increasing the complexity of decision-making and lines of responsibility across health and social care.
  • Effective governance in Scotland prioritises independence of non-executive challenge, active use of data, collaborative working across boundaries, and continuous self-assessment against the blueprint rather than pure compliance.

Meet the author: Andrew Corbett-Nolan

Chief executive and senior partner

Email: andrew.corbett-nolan@good-governance.org.uk Find out more

Prepared by GGI Development and Research LLP for the Good Governance Institute.

Enquire about this article

Enquire
Contact us