Engaging with the Charity Commission: lessons from Captain Tom
09 September 2026
Andrew Corbett-Nolan identifies some important lessons for charity leaders in a high-profile case
Points raised in this article:
- Charity Commission inquiries demand early, constructive trustee engagement
- Captain Tom Foundation highlights conflict-of-interest and reputation risks
- Trustees should act promptly on regulatory opportunities to rectify concerns
- Strong charity governance protects public trust during regulatory scrutiny
When the Charity Commission opens an inquiry, it is performing a statutory function. It has a duty to investigate concerns about the administration of charities, to protect public trust and to apply clear legal standards around trustee duties, conflicts of interest, private benefit and the proper use of a charity’s name and resources.
For the individuals and boards involved, the experience is almost always stressful and high stakes. Yet the way trustees and related parties choose to engage with the regulator can significantly influence both the regulatory outcome and the wider public narrative.
The Charity Commission’s statutory inquiry into The Captain Tom Foundation, concluded in November 2024, provides a clear illustration of this dynamic. The case involved serious and repeated findings of misconduct and/or mismanagement. It also shows how earlier, more constructive engagement with the opportunities the commission itself offered might have altered the trajectory of the process and reduced some of the later reputational damage.
Context in brief
The Captain Tom Foundation was established in May 2020 as a charitable company in the name of Captain Sir Tom Moore. The original £38.9 million he raised for NHS Charities Together during the first Covid lockdown did not form part of the inquiry; that money went to NHS charities. The foundation itself was intended to continue his legacy of supporting good causes.
In June 2022 the commission opened a statutory inquiry under section 46 of the Charities Act 2011. The focus was on governance, conflicts of interest (particularly those arising from links to the family’s private companies), intellectual property arrangements, public communications and whether trustees had acted solely in the best interests of the charity.
The inquiry report, published on 21 November 2024, found serious and repeated instances of misconduct and/or mismanagement by Hannah Ingram-Moore (former trustee and interim CEO) and Colin Ingram-Moore (former trustee). These amounted to a pattern of behaviour in which private and charitable interests were repeatedly blurred, resulting in significant personal benefit. There was also mismanagement by the unconflicted trustees who held office at the relevant times. Both Hannah and Colin Ingram-Moore were disqualified from charity trusteeship and senior management roles (for ten and eight years respectively) with effect from June 2024. The commission did not find criminal behaviour and did not refer the matter to the police.
It is important to also say that the Ingram-Moores have publicly stated that they were treated unfairly and unjustly, that the inquiry was excessive and had a predetermined agenda, and that they never misappropriated funds from the charity’s bank account or took money from the original NHS appeal. They have disputed key findings of the report.
The commission’s role and the opportunities it created
The Charity Commission is not an optional interlocutor. Once serious concerns are raised and a statutory inquiry is opened, it has a duty to gather evidence, test it against the legal standards set out in charity law and reach conclusions. Those standards include the duties to act in the best interests of the charity, to manage conflicts of interest properly, to avoid unauthorised private benefit and to ensure public communications about the charity are not misleading.
In this case the commission did more than investigate. In October and November 2022 (relatively early in the inquiry process) it formally wrote to Hannah and Colin Ingram-Moore on two separate occasions. The letters set out the information the inquiry had gathered concerning the book publishing arrangements and explicitly offered them the opportunity “to rectify matters by making a donation to the charity in line with their original intentions as understood by those involved.” On both occasions the opportunity was declined.
This is a matter of public record in the commission’s report. The remaining trustees of the foundation later joined the commission in calling for a substantial donation so that funds could be applied to charitable purposes. At the time the report was published, no such donation had been made from the book proceeds.
Why early constructive engagement matters
Regulatory processes are rarely comfortable. Trustees and related parties often feel that the regulator does not fully understand the context, the pressures of the time or their intentions. Those feelings are understandable. Yet the legal framework requires the commission to apply objective standards. When those standards appear not to have been met, the regulator’s job is to say so.
Engaging early and constructively does not mean abandoning a defence of one’s position. It can mean:
- providing full and timely information
- acknowledging where public expectations may have been created, even if unintentionally
- taking voluntary steps to address concerns while the process is still live
- recognising that the regulator has a public-interest duty that sits above any individual perspective.
In the Captain Tom Foundation case, the formal invitations in 2022 to make a donation represented a concrete opportunity to demonstrate that the charity’s interests and the reasonable expectations of the public were being taken seriously. Declining those invitations left the commission’s later findings about public expectations and the absence of any donation from the book proceeds unsoftened. It also contributed to a public narrative in which the family’s position appeared fixed against the regulator’s.
By contrast, boards that recognise the commission’s role and engage with a degree of openness (even while robustly defending their record) often find that the final regulatory language is more measured and that residual goodwill is better preserved. The Mermaids inquiry, for example, noted the charity’s cooperation and the independent reviews it had already commissioned. This helped frame the outcome as mismanagement rather than misconduct and avoided personal disqualification.
Lessons for charity boards and trustees
The Captain Tom Foundation inquiry offers several practical lessons about engagement with the regulator:
- The commission has a job to do. Once an inquiry is opened, the process will run according to the commission’s statutory duties and evidential standards. Treating the regulator as an adversary rather than as a body performing a necessary public function rarely improves the outcome
- Opportunities to rectify are significant. When the commission explicitly invites voluntary steps to address concerns, those invitations should be weighed carefully. Declining them is a legitimate choice, but it carries consequences for both the regulatory findings and the public record
- Public expectations matter. Where communications or arrangements have created a reasonable public belief that a charity will benefit, addressing that expectation early can prevent findings that the public ‘would understandably feel misled’.
- Constructive engagement is not an admission of liability. Providing information, correcting the record where necessary, and offering practical solutions can demonstrate good faith without conceding every point of dispute.
- Independent trustees have a particular responsibility. Unconflicted trustees should insist on full information flows and should not allow related parties to manage the relationship with the regulator in isolation.
- Reputation is cumulative. A defensive posture sustained over years, however sincerely held, tends to harden public and regulatory perceptions. Early signals of willingness to prioritise the charity’s interests can alter that trajectory.
The Charity Commission’s findings in the Captain Tom Foundation case were serious. They centred on repeated failures to manage conflicts of interest and to maintain a clear boundary between private and charitable interests. Those findings stand on the evidence the commission assembled and the standards it is required to apply.
At the same time, the process itself illustrates a wider truth for every charity trustee. The regulator has a job to do. Engaging with that reality early — providing information, considering opportunities to put matters right, and recognising the public-interest dimension of the commission’s role — can reduce the intensity and duration of the difficulties that follow. In this case, the formal opportunities offered in 2022 to make a donation were not taken.
Whether or not one accepts the commission’s overall conclusions, that decision formed part of the public record and shaped the final chapter of a highly visible inquiry.
For boards facing regulatory scrutiny the practical message is clear. The commission will apply its standards. The more trustees can help it do so while demonstrating that the charity’s interests remain paramount, the greater the chance of containing both regulatory and reputational harm. That is not weakness. It is good governance.