Beyond compliance: what makes an NHS audit committee effective?

05 November 2026

Peter Allanson explains how deliberate membership, strong chairing and continuous development help committees look behind the assurance they receive. He also sets out ten questions every board should ask.

 

Key points

  • Boards are often reassured rather than truly assured.
  • Design committee membership around strategic risks, not just filling seats.
  • A strong chair turns individual expertise into collective challenge.
  • Measure maturity by impact, not activity or self-assessment.
     

GGi’s recent blog, NHS audit committees, sets out the statutory basis and ground rules for these committees. This article considers how they can move beyond compliance to make a greater contribution to governance, risk and organisational learning.

NHS audit committees face widening responsibilities amid financial pressure, cyber risk, service transformation and increasingly complex system working — at a time when NHS structures are themselves being reshaped, with integrated care boards cutting running costs and merging, and NHS England’s functions moving into the Department of Health and Social Care. 

Change on this scale tends to strain controls and blur accountability just when reliable assurance matters most. Yet a full work programme and a steady flow of reports do not guarantee strong assurance. Inquiries into serious NHS failings have repeatedly found boards that were reassured rather than assured. The real test is whether a committee has the membership, capability and maturity to look behind the assurances presented to the board and assess whether they can be trusted.

HM Treasury describes the audit and risk assurance committee as the organisation’s ‘conscience’: a source of insight and constructive challenge on governance, risk and control. For the NHS, that means connecting finance with quality, strategy with risk, culture with control, and formal assurance with the experience of patients and staff. The answer is not more paper, but a committee designed deliberately and developed continuously.

Start with purpose: look behind assurance

An audit committee is not another performance committee. It should neither duplicate the detailed work of finance, quality, workforce or performance committees nor drift into executive management. Its distinctive role is to scrutinise the systems through which the board receives assurance and assess whether they are coherent, proportionate and reliable.

Members should look beyond whether a report has been received or an action completed. They should ask:

  • Where did the evidence come from and how far does it support the conclusion being drawn?
  • What remains uncertain and which perspectives or contrary indicators may be missing?
  • What has actually been tested, what remains untested and how independent was the testing?

A collection of positive reports does not necessarily amount to a convincing overall picture. The committee must be able to identify the limits of assurance as well as its strengths.

Good committees connect the board assurance framework and corporate risk register with internal and external audit, clinical audit, complaints, incidents and workforce intelligence. These should be considered together, not as separate reporting streams. This works best when other board committees understand their own assurance responsibilities, allowing audit to test the overall picture without repeating their work.

The committee oversees the integrity of the assurance architecture, but it should not become the owner of every weakness it identifies. Its role is to ensure that responsibility for addressing deficiencies is clear, that management action is proportionate and timely, and that the board understands any residual uncertainty. Effective scrutiny strengthens accountability; it does not displace it.

External audit forms a critical independent strand of that assurance. The committee’s responsibilities run in both directions: it must satisfy itself that the external auditor has the access, information and organisational support needed to form a robust opinion, and it must use the auditor’s findings, including the value for money conclusion, together with internal audit and other sources to test management’s assertions rather than treat them as conclusive.

The same scrutiny applies to the assurance providers themselves. The committee should satisfy itself that internal audit has the independence, resources and risk focus to deliver a meaningful head of internal audit opinion, and that the audit plan is driven by principal risks rather than habit.

Design the membership; do not simply fill the seats

Membership should be a strategic, designed decision. Independence and financial literacy are essential, but not sufficient as the sole criteria for membership. Start with the organisation’s strategic risks and assurance needs, then identify the perspectives required around the table. Members need enough collective range to connect accounts with quality, performance, digital risk, workforce culture, service change and partnerships. Not everyone needs to be a specialist in every area, but the committee must be able to recognise the right questions, detect weak signals and know when to seek expert advice.

Diversity of professional background, sector experience, community understanding and thinking style broadens what the committee notices and challenges.

Boards should plan for renewal as well as continuity. Unplanned vacancies, dependence on one financial expert and repeated extensions of tenure can weaken effectiveness. Mapping future needs, developing succession options and keeping potential candidates engaged makes recruitment part of a continuing capability strategy.

Independence must also be behavioural. Members need time, confidence and access — including private dialogue with internal and external auditors — to pursue difficult issues. They should challenge prevailing assumptions while remaining connected to the organisation’s purpose and avoiding an adversarial relationship with executives.

The chair is pivotal

Expertise alone does not make a capable committee; the chair turns individual strengths into collective effectiveness. A strong chair shapes the agenda around strategic risk and assurance, sets clear expectations for preparation and follow-through, invites different perspectives and prevents one voice or discipline from dominating.

Challenge that is merely ceremonial adds little; challenge that becomes confrontational can close down candour. The chair must create conditions in which difficult questions are asked early, answered honestly and pursued until the committee is satisfied.

The chair also connects the committee to the wider governance system. Regular dialogue with the board chair, chief executive, chief finance officer, board secretary, auditors and other committee chairs can expose overlaps and gaps. Reporting to the board should explain not only what was discussed, but where assurance is strong, where it is qualified and where action or board attention is needed.

Build collective capability around risk

Beyond recent, relevant financial experience, the committee’s collective capability should include:

  • financial literacy, including NHS accounts, financial reporting and value for money
  • practical understanding of governance, risk, internal control and assurance
  • knowledge of the NHS and the organisation’s context, linking assurance to strategy, quality, performance and patient safety
  • independent thought, sound judgement and confidence in testing evidence and pursuing concerns
  • the ability to connect information, identify gaps and recognise the limits of the committee’s knowledge.

Depending on its risk profile, the committee should also be able to access specialist expertise in digital and cyber security, data and artificial intelligence; workforce, culture and speaking up; major programmes and service transformation; partnerships; procurement and counter-fraud; and climate, sustainability and other emerging risks.

The National Audit Office effectiveness tool treats skills and experience as a core test of effectiveness, and the Northern Ireland Audit Office highlights cyber, AI, programmes and procurement. The point is not to expand the agenda indefinitely, but to ensure capability follows risk. Map strengths and gaps, decide what can be addressed through development, and identify when additional attendance, co-option or external advice is needed. No committee of three or four non-executives can hold all this expertise itself. Relying on the work of other board committees, co-opting specialists for defined periods and commissioning targeted reviews are legitimate ways to fill gaps, provided the committee is clear about what it has relied on and why.

The test of capability is not what members know, but how effectively they use that knowledge together. Do they question assumptions, listen to dissenting views, acknowledge uncertainty and pursue unresolved concerns? Or do deference, time pressure and comfortable consensus allow weak assurance to pass unchallenged? The chair’s responsibility is to create the conditions for this behaviour, but every member shares responsibility for it.

Make development continuous and practical

Development should be built into the committee’s work, starting with an induction that covers meetings with assurance providers, observation of other board committees, site visits and exposure to patient and staff experience. New members need to understand the board assurance framework, risk appetite, internal audit strategy, annual governance statement and the respective roles of internal and external audit.

It should then continue throughout each appointment. Scenario exercises, though rarely used, can reveal gaps more effectively than generic presentations: how would the committee respond to a major cyber incident, persistent quality failure, a collapsed financial plan, programme slippage or evidence that staff do not feel safe to speak up? Such exercises test knowledge, relationships, escalation routes and decision rights before a real crisis.

Annual skills reviews should shape agendas, recruitment and the use of experts. The goal is not mastery of every subject, but enough fluency to challenge confidently and recognise when assurance is narrow, over-optimistic or based on untested assumptions.

Turn information into intelligence

Hundreds of pages do not create assurance; they can obscure it. Every paper should explain why the issue is before the committee, what judgement or decision is required, what the evidence shows, where uncertainty remains and what management recommends.

Committees should watch for four common substitutions, in which the first is offered in place of the second: 

  • activity for impact 
  • explanation for evidence 
  • confidence for control
  • volume for completeness. 

Executive reporting should be triangulated with audit findings, workforce and patient insight, complaints, incidents, benchmarking and external intelligence.

Risks rarely sit in neat categories. A productivity programme, for example, may affect staffing, access, safety, data and reputation. Mature committees follow the assurance trail across these connections rather than considering each in isolation.

Treat maturity as a pathway, not a badge

Maturity models are valuable when they prompt honest discussion and practical improvement — not when they become self-awarded labels. GGi’s maturity matrices distinguish basic, improving and mature practice. The five-stage pathway below builds on them, separating out the integration of assurance and the point at which the committee’s challenge demonstrably changes the organisation:

  1. Compliant: sound constitution, clear terms of reference, reliable core reporting and access to internal and external audit.
  2. Developing: planned membership and skills, improving agendas, consistent follow-up and systematic development.
  3. Integrated: assurance aligned with strategy and principal risks, with clear links between committees, audit plans and the board assurance framework.
  4. Mature: the committee looks forward, challenges assumptions, triangulates evidence across the organisation, attends to weak signals and adapts its focus as risks change.
  5. Leading: the committee’s challenge demonstrably changes the organisation, which learns from it, anticipates emerging risks and improves its controls, decisions and resilience.

Progress will not be linear, and different aspects of a committee may sit at different stages. The value lies in identifying the next improvement. Maturity must be evident in behaviour and outcomes, not merely asserted in a self-assessment. Placing the committee on the pathway should rest on evidence — observation of meetings, feedback from executives and auditors, and examples of impact — rather than on members’ own view.

Work across systems without blurring accountability

Trusts, foundation trusts, integrated care boards, provider collaboratives, local authorities and voluntary-sector partners may share objectives and risks, but they do not necessarily share the same accountabilities, controls or assurance standards. Audit committees should be clear who owns each decision, risk and control; what has been delegated or reserved; and how information moves between partners. Common assurance requirements can reduce duplication and expose gaps.

Collaboration must not become collective ambiguity. Each organisation must remain confident that its statutory duties are being discharged, as each non-executive remains accountable through their own board. Joint assurance, shared internal audit or committees in common may improve coherence, but only where decision rights, reporting lines and conflicts are explicit. The test is whether the arrangement strengthens visibility of risk and accountability, not simply whether it reduces meetings.

Measure impact, not activity

Meetings held, attendance, papers received and actions closed are useful disciplines, but they do not demonstrate value. More important indicators include closed assurance gaps, fewer repeat findings, stronger controls, earlier escalation, clearer reporting and better-informed board decisions.

Ask what changed because the committee did its work well. Evidence may include a hidden dependency brought to the board’s attention, a programme reset after assumptions were challenged, a recurring audit issue resolved or a clearer account of risk in the annual governance statement. Attribution is rarely clean, as improvements usually have several causes, but the committee should be able to point to specific instances where its challenge made a difference.

Annual reflection should be candid and proportionate, supported by periodic deeper or independent review. HM Treasury’s handbook provides a formal self-assessment tool and points towards drawing on views from members, executives, auditors, the board and other assurance providers — not relying solely on the committee’s own perspective.

Ten questions for every NHS board

  1. Is membership deliberately designed around our strategic risks?
  2. Do we understand our collective strengths, gaps and development priorities?
  3. Does the chair enable constructive, persistent challenge?
  4. Can members distinguish reliable assurance from confident assertion?
  5. Does the agenda look forward as well as backward?
  6. Do we connect finance, quality, culture, performance, digital and system risks?
  7. Can we obtain specialist advice when our knowledge reaches its limits?
  8. Are accountabilities clear across partnerships and system arrangements?
  9. Do we assess maturity through evidence of impact rather than self-description?
  10. Can the board identify decisions, controls or outcomes improved by the committee?

Boards and audit committee chairs could use these questions as the starting point for an annual maturity conversation. Rather than attempting to improve everything at once, they should identify the two or three changes most likely to strengthen assurance, assign responsibility and revisit progress after 12 months. The maturity framework should be a stimulus for improvement, not another compliance exercise.

In summary: beyond compliance

An effective NHS audit committee does more than fulfil its formal responsibilities. It helps the board understand whether governance, risk management and internal controls are working in practice, and whether the assurance on which decisions depend is reliable.

Maturity is not measured by the volume of reporting, the completion of the annual work programme or a self-awarded rating. It is demonstrated by what changes as a result of the committee’s work: stronger controls, better-informed decisions, earlier recognition of risk and a greater capacity to learn.

The ambition is not simply a compliant audit committee, but one that helps the NHS make safer, wiser and more sustainable decisions.

 

Source note

This article draws on GGi’s 2021 and 2025 audit committee board assurance prompts and maturity matrices; HM Treasury’s 2025 Audit and Risk Assurance Committee Handbook; the National Audit Office Audit and Risk Assurance Committee effectiveness tool; and the Northern Ireland Audit Office guide to Effective Audit and Risk Assurance Committees.

Meet the author: Peter Allanson

Principal consultant

Email: peter.allanson@good-governance.org.uk Find out more

Prepared by GGI Development and Research LLP for the Good Governance Institute.

Enquire about this article

Enquire
Contact us