Arts Council England: what cultural boards need to know
09 September 2026
Andrew Corbett-Nolan looks at a unique institution and finds five practical implications for cultural boards
Points raised in this article:
- Arts Council England reforms refocus funding on artistic excellence
- Cultural boards face stronger governance, assurance and accountability expectations
- The Hodge Review drives simpler strategy and National Portfolio reform
- Boards should prepare now for 2028–33 National Portfolio funding
Arts Council England (ACE) occupies a unique position in English public life. It is both an arm’s-length body distributing hundreds of millions of pounds of Grant-in-Aid and National Lottery funding and a development agency charged with championing creativity and culture.
For the boards of cultural organisations (whether National Portfolio Organisations, project-funded groups or those seeking partnership with local authorities) understanding ACE’s history, current strategic direction, internal governance and expectations of funded bodies is essential practical knowledge.
Origins and evolution
Public funding for the arts in England traces to the wartime Committee for the Encouragement of Music and the Arts, chaired from 1941 by John Maynard Keynes. In 1946 it became the Arts Council of Great Britain by Royal Charter. The arm’s-length principle (that elected politicians set high-level policy but do not take individual funding decisions) has been foundational ever since.
In 1994 the Arts Council of Great Britain was succeeded by separate national bodies; the Arts Council of England was created. In 2002–03 it merged with the regional arts boards and became Arts Council England. In 2011 it assumed responsibility for museums and libraries after the abolition of the Museums, Libraries and Archives Council.
Today ACE is an executive non-departmental public body sponsored by the Department for Culture, Media and Sport (DCMS) and a registered charity. It operates under a framework document with DCMS and is accountable to parliament through its annual report and accounts. It remains the principal distributor of public and National Lottery funding for the arts, museums and libraries in England.
Strategy: from Let’s Create to the Hodge Review and beyond
Let’s Create (2020–2030) set out a ten-year vision of a country in which everyone’s creativity is valued and high-quality cultural experiences are widely accessible. It was organised around three outcomes:
- Creative people
- Cultural communities
- A creative and cultural country
and four investment principles:
- Ambition and quality
- Dynamism
- Environmental responsibility
- Inclusivity and relevance
ACE delivery plans then translated this strategy into operational priorities.
One of the most contested elements of the strategy was its approach to quality. Under the Investment Principle of Ambition and Quality, ACE defined ambition as the formulation and articulation of what an organisation or individual wanted to achieve and quality as the delivery of activity evaluated against those self-set ambitions.
Organisations were expected to determine what quality looked like for them, gather feedback from peers and the public, demonstrate continuous improvement and show awareness of the best work in their field. ACE explicitly acknowledged that excellence is difficult to define and will mean different things in different contexts. The principle applied equally to professional presentation, community programmes, education and talent development. Quality markers encouraged across the sector often included connection, relevance, captivation, challenge, authenticity and belonging alongside more traditional notions of craft.
This approach had a clear rationale. It sought to avoid a single, top-down definition of excellence that might privilege established artforms or metropolitan institutions. It recognised genuine differences in context. What constitutes high quality in a large-scale opera production is not identical to what constitutes high quality in a participatory community project or a museum learning programme. It aimed to foster a culture of continuous improvement rather than static judgements of merit, and to encourage organisations to listen beyond their immediate circles.
However, the approach attracted substantial criticism. Many in the sector felt that by making quality largely self-defined against an organisation’s own stated ambitions, and by ranking ambition and quality as one principle among four of equal weight, the strategy relativised traditional standards of artistic excellence, technical mastery and imaginative ambition. Critics argued that excellence risked being subordinated to process, to social and place-based outcomes and to the ability to demonstrate the full suite of investment principles.
The Hodge Review later recorded that people felt ACE had ‘lowered the priority given to the pursuit of artistic excellence. Art and excellence were sidelined’. The strategy was widely experienced as a ‘straitjacket’: organisations believed they had to tick ACE boxes rather than being judged primarily on the quality and ambition of the work itself. Implementation became heavily bureaucratic. The demands of application and reporting were said to crowd out artistic focus.
I was called ‘waspish’ for saying that the framework effectively treated quality as a matter of the artist’s or organisation’s intention, thereby placing a set of painted swirls on a warehouse wall in Bolton on the same footing as a Titian.
My words were meant as a caricature but nevertheless a caricature that captured a real anxiety that the combination of self-defined quality, equal weighting of non-artistic principles, and heavy process requirements, had made it harder to assert and defend distinctions of excellence and craft.
The independent review led by Baroness Margaret Hodge, published in December 2025, concluded that ACE remains a vital national body but required significant reform. It recommended:
- replacing Let’s Create with a simpler, less prescriptive strategy
- a completely new model for the National Portfolio
- radical reduction in application and reporting burdens
- stronger protection of the arm’s-length principle
- longer funding cycles and clearer support for individual artists and under-served places.
The government accepted or committed to explore the recommendations. On the quality question, the review’s diagnosis aligned closely with the sector’s concerns: the strategy’s implementation had been experienced as stifling creativity and innovation and as downgrading the pursuit of artistic excellence.
In 2026 ACE published an interim strategic framework organised around three priorities:
- support excellence
- deliver for everybody
- reach everywhere
The document states that funding decisions will be made on the basis of the quality of the creative or cultural work proposed, and that ACE will only invest in work it believes is, or has the potential to be, excellent. This explicit re-centring of quality and excellence is a direct response to the criticisms of the previous approach. Work on a new long-term strategy continues and a redesigned National Portfolio process is in development, with the next cycle expected to begin in April 2028 for the period 2028–33.
ACE’s own governance
ACE is governed by a national council, which functions as both the non-executive board and the body of charitable trustees. The chair is appointed by the secretary of state; other members are also appointed by the secretary of state (with the London area chair appointed by the mayor of London subject to approval). Five area councils provide regional advice and advocacy. Day-to-day leadership rests with the executive board, headed by the chief executive as accounting officer.
The arm’s-length principle remains central to ACE’s legitimacy. The Hodge Review recorded strong criticism of perceived political interference during the previous government’s levelling-up interventions, particularly around the 2023–26 National Portfolio, and concern that ACE had not sufficiently defended the principle. The review was clear: ministers should set overarching policy objectives, but individual funding decisions must remain free from political interference. Subsequent government and ACE responses have reaffirmed this distinction.
Criticisms crystallised around the 2023–26 National Portfolio
The announcements for the 2023–26 National Portfolio became a focal point for wider concerns about transparency, communication and decision-making. Organisations reported short notice of cuts and inadequate explanations. The simultaneous reductions affecting English National Opera (initially removed from the portfolio and required to relocate, later partially adjusted), Glyndebourne’s touring subsidy and Welsh National Opera’s touring support were widely described as difficult to understand vandalism, particularly in the absence of visible artform strategies. Critics argued that place-based and levelling-up priorities had been applied in ways that produced inconsistent outcomes and that the process lacked sufficient artform expertise and clear communication.
The Hodge Review documented almost universal criticism of the application and reporting regime as burdensome and a loss of trust and respect among parts of the sector. These criticisms did not lead the review to recommend abolition; they did drive the reform agenda now under way.
What ACE expects of the governance of cultural organisations
ACE regards the board (or independent oversight group) of a funded organisation as a critical part of the accountability chain for public and Lottery money. Core expectations include:
- an independent board or oversight group, clearly independent of the executive
- proper terms of reference, a conflicts of interest policy and regular meetings (at least quarterly review of progress against the funding agreement)
- board responsibility for oversight of the funding agreement, receipt and scrutiny of progress reports, and timely submission of required information
- quarterly submission of board papers (typically agenda, minutes, management accounts with variances and projections) and other material relevant to the agreement
- active engagement with the organisation’s commitments under the funding agreement and the capacity for the board (or designated members) to communicate directly with ACE independent of the executive if necessary
- policies and procedures that meet legal and regulatory requirements and reflect good practice.
Relationship managers engage through annual progress reviews and are often expected to attend at least one board meeting a year. Boards are expected to hold the executive to account for delivery, financial stewardship, risk and the integrity of the relationship with the funder.
Practical implications for boards
Several points follow for boards of cultural organisations in England.
- First, ACE is itself in transition. The move away from the detailed architecture of Let’s Create, the redesign of the National Portfolio and the renewed emphasis on excellence and the quality of the work itself create both opportunity and uncertainty. Boards should ensure their organisations can articulate distinctive artistic and public value clearly and are prepared to adapt as reporting requirements evolve. The debate over quality under Let’s Create is a useful reminder that boards themselves must be capable of making and defending judgements about artistic ambition and excellence, rather than outsourcing those judgements entirely to external frameworks.
- Second, strong internal governance remains non-negotiable. ACE continues to rely on boards as the first line of assurance. Weak, captured or poorly informed boards create risk for the organisation and for the funder. Regular, high-quality board papers, independent challenge and clear lines of accountability are practical necessities.
- Third, the arm’s-length principle that protects ACE from day-to-day political interference has a parallel inside organisations: boards must protect artistic and operational integrity while fulfilling public accountability obligations. Direct communication channels between board and funder, used appropriately, are part of that protection.
- Fourth, preparation for the 2028–33 National Portfolio should already be on board agendas. Organisations that can demonstrate excellence, clear contribution to place and audiences, robust governance and financial resilience will be better placed under a less prescriptive regime.
- Finally, the wider case for cultural investment (articulated most fully in Dr. Darren Henley’s Arts Dividend framework) remains relevant. Boards that understand how their organisation contributes to place-shaping, economic activity, opportunity and wellbeing, while remaining firmly anchored in artistic purpose and a clear-eyed judgement of quality, will be better equipped to make their case to ACE, to local partners and to other funders.
Arts Council England is neither a simple grant-giver nor an unchanging bureaucracy. It is a complex institution navigating political direction, sector expectation, fiscal constraint and its own reform. The quality debate that ran through Let’s Create and its aftermath illustrates both the difficulty of defining excellence in a diverse cultural ecology and the risks of allowing process and secondary objectives to crowd out the primacy of the work itself.
Boards that understand ACE’s history, its current strategic direction, the lessons of recent controversy and the practical expectations it places on funded organisations will be better able to govern effectively and to secure the resources their artistic work requires. The quality of that governance is itself part of the case for continued public investment.