Alert, Advise, Assure

10 September 2026

Peter Allanson offers an overview of GGi’s 3As framework, which complements our Making Meetings Matter offer

 

Points raised in this article:

- GGi’s 3As framework improves board and committee communication. 

- Alert highlights emerging governance risks, problems and issues.

- Advise captures key recommendations requiring board-level consideration. 

- Assure provides evidence that risks are effectively controlled.
 

Please note that the information in this article and the linked guidance note relates to the board and its committees – we will publish separate articles about management groups soon.

 

One of the facets of meetings that organisations sometimes struggle with is how much to tell the next level in the hierarchy about what a meeting dealt with. The choice sometimes seems to be between a blow-by-blow account of the meeting so that you could have been there or a deadly silence – neither of which informs, warns or assures. 

Perhaps it is worth reminding ourselves what committees are designed to achieve – here I’m mainly thinking about committees set up by a board of trustees or directors. In any organisation, time is at a premium and with the best will in the world boards cannot spend as much time on everything they are responsible for as may be needed. 

That is not to encourage committees to spend all their time delving into the operational minutiae of the organisation, although looking at a particular problem can make good use of a committee’s time. Rather they should be making sure that the key issues facing an organisation, its future and the risks to achieving that future are thoroughly and properly considered. 

Any committee only exists because another part of the governance hierarchy has set it up. While there may be specific responsibilities up to and including decision taking delegated to it, its main role is to advise and recommend to the more senior group. 

Looking forward

A well-run board will be spending most of its time looking forward, working on the strategy and the risks that could prevent it achieving its longer-term goals. Remember, supervising management is a retrospective activity and while there may be lessons to be learned and warnings to be taken notice of the board is much better placed to advise on the future than to join in a lament for the past. 

One of the most effective ways a committee can support the board is by taking responsibility for appropriate risks to the strategy related to the committee’s subject specialism. This might also run to supervising parts of the strategy – for example a people committee should be all over the people strategy making sure that skills and staffing are fit for the future and the finance committee should be concerned with how to invest for the future both literally and figuratively.

So, if the committee agendas are well constructed and the work relevant and valuable to support the board’s purpose then a key requirement is that the board understands what is being done its behalf, what it needs to worry about now and in the future and what it can take assurance from that matters are under control. This element of communication between committee and board is vital and not often well done.

As with long board papers in which the author shares all their knowledge about a subject, so an unselective rerun of a meeting is unhelpful. To this end, GGi came up with a methodology called the 3As as part of our Making Meetings Matter offer. The three As – Alert, Advise, Assure – are elements of the escalation that may be needed through the governance hierarchy. 

What is expected in a 3As report is a short report (no more than two sides of A4) from the chair of the meeting. This should describe the agenda and confirm that the meeting was quorate and discuss risk and learning. The conclusion should set out up to: 

  • three alerts dealing with emerging risks problems or issues
  • three matters where there was sufficient evidence and material for members to triangulate their views which provide assurance
  • three items of advice arising from the meeting

Magic number

There is no magic about the number three – except that it’s advisable not to set out more than three of each or you run the risk of turning the report into a re-run of the meeting. This methodology allows matters to be escalated in a timely manner, although it is not intended to replace major incident reporting should something approaching catastrophe arise. 

It helps to plan future agendas especially where a watch needs to be kept on emerging issues and of course assurance (as opposed to reassurance) is a vital part of enabling the organisation to run smoothly. It also provides a disciplined and relatively brief note for the committee chair to use as their report. It is also more helpful than sharing the minutes of the meeting as these will not necessarily identify the issues the next layer in the hierarchy should be interested in.

As with anything brief it takes more thought and effort than something much longer – but the 3As are an important and helpful way of communicating between parts of the governance system and making sure the right issues are addressed at the right time. Although they are often used in management groups, their impact on end-to-end assurance should not be underestimated.

We have developed a short guide to help you use the 3As framework effectively. Click the button below to download it.

If you need any further help in improving inter-committee communications, please do get in touch.

Meet the author: Peter Allanson

Principal consultant

Email: peter.allanson@good-governance.org.uk Find out more

Prepared by GGI Development and Research LLP for the Good Governance Institute.

Enquire about this article

Enquire
Contact us