Whole-system governance and lessons from Wales
01 October 2026
Close political scrutiny, crowded partnership structures and tight money: Wales offers NHS boards in England an early look at what may be coming. Jan Williams OBE, chair of Swansea Bay University Health Board, shared her experience with GGi's peer-to-peer group for NHS non-executive directors.
Key points
- Wales is over-governed rather than effectively governed
- Adding layers rarely fixes a governance gap
- Delayed discharges are blocking the shift to community care
- Honest conversations with the public about NHS limits are overdue
GGi's chief executive Professor Andrew Corbett-Nolan chaired GGi’s September webinar for NHS NEDs on Friday, 25 September. Our guest, Jan Williams OBE, chairs Swansea Bay University Health Board and previously chaired Public Health Wales. She was a chief executive for 24 years, and her non-executive roles have included the Human Tissue Authority, the Home Office Domestic Homicide Review, National Museums Wales and the Independent Police Complaints Commission.
Jan began by explaining that, unlike NHS England, NHS Wales is not a legal entity. Seven health boards are vertically integrated, planning, commissioning and delivering almost all care for 3.2 million people. Alongside them sit three NHS trusts, two national bodies and two all-Wales joint committees. Regional partnership boards, public services boards and regional joint committees add further tiers.
Several of these arrangements are, in Jan's words, "flawed governance models". The joint committees are largely made up of the organisations they serve, so most people round the table have a conflict of interest. Regional working is encouraged, but accountability still sits with individual organisations. The new Plaid Cymru government is adding an accountability and escalation framework and a new oversight body, which Jan said currently feels more like "a government enforcer". Every health board is now in deficit.
Politics up close
In a small country, politicians are never far away. After May's election, Reform UK became the official opposition in the Senedd, the Welsh parliament. Members raise individual cases in the chamber every week, and the health minister follows up directly with the chair. When Swansea Bay had to pause its fertility service because the licence holder was unwell, ministers wanted a briefing within two days.
Andrew suggested England may be heading the same way, as devolution grows and new Reform UK councillors take their seats. Wales, he said, is getting an early glimpse of that future.
Change and consultation
Wales understands what needs to change but struggles to follow through. Cardiac services are about to be reviewed for a fourth time. Moving 30 beds nine miles has needed eight weeks of formal engagement. Jan said Llais, the statutory citizen voice body, takes a very orthodox view of what counts as service change. Even closing an unneeded ward or ending automatic outpatient follow-ups triggers consultation. Change, when it comes, is usually forced by money or staffing.
Asked whether Wales resists ideas from England, Jan acknowledged "a theme of that kind" but said it was changing, with national improvement programmes and well-led reviews now coming in.
The shift to the community
The Well-being of Future Generations Act requires public bodies to consider the long-term impact of their decisions. Andrew called it his favourite piece of legislation, though he wished it had more teeth. From April 2027 health boards must move 0.5% of their allocation into prevention. Yet the objectives are rarely costed, and NHS Wales may end the year more than £300m in deficit.
Swansea Bay has the structures for change: vertical integration, eight GP clusters and the right policy direction. But on the day of the session it had 179 patients in hospital with no clinical need to be there. Across Wales, between 13% and 15% of beds are taken up this way. That, Jan said, is the fundamental block on the shift.
One participant asked whether England's move to neighbourhood health risks the same layering. Andrew argued that neighbourhoods should be hosted by trusts or large community interest companies, not general practice, which he saw as the weak point of the 2012–13 commissioning reforms.
Lessons for boards
"Wales is probably over-governed rather than being effectively governed," Jan said. Her advice was not to add another layer when a gap appears, but to fix the underlying problem. She would merge national functions into one common services body and simplify escalation.
Above all, she called for an honest public conversation about what a publicly funded NHS can provide. Andrew framed this as a social contract, suggesting patients might even be told what their care had cost. Jan's closing reflection was that leaders should "rise above" the architecture and fix more problems together themselves.
The session also included a demonstration of Ask GGi, GGi's free AI tool for searching its governance knowledge.
Further information
Jan has shared the following background on two of the topics discussed.
The Well-being of Future Generations (Wales) Act 2015 requires public bodies to work towards seven national well-being goals and apply a sustainable development principle to improve the social, economic, environmental and cultural well-being of Wales. It sets duties for public bodies, creates public services boards and establishes the Future Generations Commissioner for Wales. The Act provides a legal framework to make sure today's decisions do not compromise the ability of future generations to meet their needs. It applies to Welsh ministers, local authorities, health boards, national parks, fire authorities and other specified public bodies. Find out more in the essentials guide on GOV.WALES.
Llais, the citizen voice body for Wales, is an independent statutory body set up by the Welsh Government to give people a voice in planning and delivering their health and social care services, locally, regionally and nationally. NHS Wales must consult on service changes when proposals are "substantial", as required by section 183 of the National Health Service (Wales) Act 2006, and must follow the Welsh Government's 2023 guidance on engagement and consultation. Useful links:
- Llais website
- Statutory guidance on representations made by the citizen voice body, under the Health and Social Care (Quality and Engagement) (Wales) Act 2020
- How to make changes to health services: guidance for NHS organisations