Unhappy boards are unhappy in their own way
08 September 2026
Andrew Corbett-Nolan unpicks Patrick Lencioni’s Five Dysfunctions, public accountability, and why team health matters more when the organisation is tired.
Points raised in this article:
- Lencioni’s Five Dysfunctions explain common board effectiveness challenges
- Psychological safety strengthens trust, challenge and leadership team performance
- Public-purpose governance requires accountability, candour and collective responsibility
- Effective board development starts with outcomes, not generic interventions
Public-purpose organisations in Britain are tired. This is not a passing phase. Boards and top teams across the NHS and integrated care systems, local government, higher education, housing, charities, regulators and the cultural sector are being asked to hold strategy, money, workforce, quality and public confidence at the same time, often with less slack than the work requires. The papers get longer. The meetings get tighter. The room gets quieter. Non-executives get anxious for the future and the board gets less useful just at the very moment it needs to model confidence.
It is tempting, in that climate, for the board to reach for another O/D framework or another away day. GGi’s experience of board and top team development points to solutions that are more human.
Talented people still fail together. They fail, very often, not because the strategy is flawed, but because the conditions for whole-board team working have broken down. That is why we are supporters of Patrick Lencioni’s The Five Dysfunctions of a Team. Used properly, it is not corporate folklore; it is a practical way of helping leadership groups navigate difficult times without pretending that every distressed organisation is distressed in the same way.
Tolstoy saw the pattern first. His astonishing novel Anna Karenina starts with the words “Happy families are all alike; every unhappy family is unhappy in its own way.” It is a phrase I often find helpful because high-performing boards and top teams have a family resemblance. People can admit doubt. Disagreement happens openly in the room, about the real issues rather than individuals. Decisions are clear and colleagues hold one another, including themselves, to account. Collective results (the reason the organisation exists) outrank portfolio, status and personal survival.
Unhappy leadership groups tend not to share a single story. Sometimes the issue might be a chair and chief executive who have remained polite, but the relationship is thin. Another is a membership or elected element of the board never reconciled with the need for a skills-based board. Another is exhaustion: decent people with no residual courage for candour. Another is an inherited shock such as a regulatory judgement, a failed change programme or a public investigation, after which colleagues are fragile about raising difficult points. Yet another is a team that is technically strong but interpersonally unsafe. The presenting issue is rarely the whole issue. The professionalism is in finding out.
That is how GGi tries to work with organisations in trouble. We know not to jump to quick conclusions. We look hard at what is in front of us and why it is in front of us now. Lencioni is useful as a lens rather than a verdict.
What Lencioni gives us
Lencioni’s model is a pyramid. Each dysfunction makes the next almost inevitable.
At the base is absence of trust. He does not mean the thin trust of “I expect you to behave in a predictable way.” He means vulnerability-based trust: the ability to say I do not know, I got that wrong, I need help, without fear of being punished for it. Without that, people protect their standing. In a calm organisation that is merely inefficient. In a stressed public-purpose organisation, it is how a board loses its early warning system.
Next is fear of conflict. If trust is weak, disagreement feels like attack. Teams choose artificial harmony. Challenge is postponed, softened, or displaced into WhatsApp chats or private conversations. Chairs close items down to keep to time. Executives treat non-executive questions as hostility rather than just the job. The organisation is then deprived of the very debate that would have improved the decision.
Then comes lack of commitment. Lencioni is blunt: consensus is not the goal. Clarity and buy-in are. If people have not been properly heard, they leave the room uncommitted. They nod, then run their own version afterwards. Minutes record discussion rather than decision. Strategies become documents everyone can live with and no one will fight for. In systems, collaboratives and local partnerships, this is not a psychological curiosity. It is how joint working fails in plain sight.
Fourth is avoidance of accountability. Without commitment, peers have no licence to call one another out. Accountability collapses onto the chair, the chief executive, or eventually the regulator. In tired organisations, challenging a colleague can feel cruel. It is usually the opposite. Peer-to-peer accountability is how a team stays off the investigation pathway.
At the apex is inattention to results. If the first four have failed, people optimise for what will protect them: the directorate, the profession, the personal brand or even just the need to get through the week. Process starts to feel like progress. For a commercial team, inattention to results is missed shareholder targets, but for a public-purpose team, it is delayed care, weaker education, poorer housing, lost trust, harm that will be explained later in a report nobody needed. This is the moral centre of the model for GGi. Governance exists to help an organisation do what it exists to do. A leadership team that cannot keep collective results in view is not having a culture problem off to the side of governance. It is failing at governance.
We stand behind this as an approach because it is sequential and behavioural. It stops people treating a results problem as a dashboard problem when it is still a trust problem. It gives a board language that can be used in the room, and it travels into the work we already do: diagnostics, meeting observation, facilitated whole-board and top-team sessions, 360s, coaching and the unglamorous business of making governance impactful.
Begin with the end
The most important discipline in team development is easy to skip when people are stressed and simply want relief. Start with what the organisation needs when the programme is over and not what would make a pleasant off-site. Then we work backwards. If the organisation needs committed decisions that survive contact with partners and the wider system, you will have to work on conflict and trust, not only on templates. If results for patients, students, tenants or citizens must move, you will have to name what currently crowds them out. So, we do not begin with the dysfunctions; we begin with the end. The Five Dysfunctions tell us what human work stands between here and there. Team health that does not serve that end is self-indulgent, and especially in difficult times, organisations can ill-afford self-indulgence. Cut-and-paste development is itself a form of inattention to results.
Psychological safety and the Nolan Principles have to live together
This is the point at which a borrowed American model has to be adapted into the complex world of British public life.
Lencioni’s trust is close to what later writing called psychological safety: a climate in which people can take interpersonal risks. Boards and top teams need that. Without it there is no useful assurance, only performance. But public-purpose leaders do not work in the often closed, private way that a for-profit enterprise can. They work under the Nolan Principles (selflessness, integrity, objectivity, accountability, openness, honesty and leadership) and under transparency duties that do not dissolve because the conversation was brave.
Psychological safety without public accountability becomes a private club. People feel able to speak but nothing hard is owned. Minutes are drafted to be deliberately vague. Dissent is therapeutic rather than consequential. The organisation is kind in the room and unclear outside it.
Public accountability without psychological safety becomes theatre. People speak for the record. Challenge is either absent or weaponised. Honesty is rationed because the cost of an unpolished sentence feels too high. Openness is confused with the volume of papers. Leadership becomes the management of impression.
Vulnerability-based trust in a public board is truly the work of grown-ups. It means a chair who models “I have been convinced differently, and I have changed my mind” and a chief executive who can bring bad news without being made to bleed for it. It also means that once a decision is taken, members can explain it, stand by it and be held to it. Candour in private is not a substitute for accountability in public. It is what makes accountability accurate.
Conflict has to stay ideological and not become personal: purpose, evidence, risk, options, consequences for people. Interpersonal score-settling is not “healthy debate.” Neither is the false peace in which everybody knows the problem and nobody feels the agency to raise it. Openness and honesty, in Nolan’s sense, are not the same as niceness. In a stressed organisation, artificial harmony is not kindness. It is deferred failure.
Accountability, likewise, has to be lateral as well as upward. We are rich in accountability to regulators, inspectors, auditors, ministers and the public. We are poorer at accountability around the table. If only the chair holds people to account, you do not have a board; you have an audience. If only the regulator holds the organisation to account, you have already waited too long. Peer accountability, such as a colleague saying, in time and in the room, that the behaviour or the performance will not do, is compatible with respect. It is one of the ways a leadership group honours the public.
Results complete the circle. Selflessness and objectivity are tested here. A director who cannot release a departmental interest, a non-executive who cannot release a constituency interest a professional who cannot release a tribal interest is not balancing stakeholders. They are declining to be on the team. For GGi, the scoreboard is not a quarterly number. It is whether the organisation did what the world would miss if it disappeared.
None of this is easy when FOI, media and political weather sit outside the door. That is not a reason to abandon safety or to abandon Nolan. It is a reason to design the work carefully: what belongs in confidential development, what belongs in the formal meeting, what must be said to staff and the public, and how the three remain consistent. Psychological safety that cannot survive contact with accountability is not safety. It is postponement.
What this looks like when the organisation is under strain
Under pressure, the five dysfunctions do not appear as a neat seminar diagram. They often incarnate as ordinary habits.
Trust thins out first. People stop thinking aloud. Skills gaps go unnamed. After a difficult regulatory encounter, the board may become technically more compliant and humanly less truthful. Development then has to rebuild enough safety for the truth to be usable, without demanding a confession culture that some members, given history or power in the room, cannot safely enter. Vulnerability is not equally cheap for everyone. A serious programme takes that seriously.
Conflict is rationed next. Tired teams treat disagreement as a cost they cannot afford. Then the cost arrives later and is higher when it materialises. A good chair mines for the argument the agenda is trying to skip. A good chief executive does not get impatient with the person who makes the meeting longer by making it honest. GGi’s work on meetings is, at bottom, work on conflict and commitment: fewer items, more actual decisions, challenge that is specific and an ending that can name what has been agreed.
Commitment fails in the gap between the development session and the week that follows. In integrated systems and local partnerships this is now increasingly visible as governing problem, not a team-building footnote. People leave with different stories and call it alignment. The remedy is almost embarrassingly practical. What exactly have we decided? Who owns it? What will we all say tomorrow? How will we know? Lencioni calls the last of these a scoreboard. We would add: keep it small, keep it about outcomes for people and put it on the table before the meeting ends.
Accountability fails when everyone has become happy with merely coping. The underprepared colleague is managed around. The dominant voice is tolerated because there is no energy for another difficult conversation. The executive who cannot work across boundaries is described as "passionate". Then a review discovers that everyone knew. In development work we look for whether peers can have difficult conversations with peers. If they cannot, the programme has not reached the organisation’s need, however warm the feedback forms.
Results fail last and most expensively. A busy board is not the same as an effective one. Activity is a sedative. Purpose has to be made operational again: a handful of outcomes, owned collectively, against which cleverness and loyalty are both judged. That is what “govern what really matters” means when the institution is strained.
Finding out, then acting
Because, to paraphrase Tolstoy, unhappy boards are unhappy in their own way, the opening move is curiosity with a spine.
What is the presenting issue, as they name it and as the evidence names it? Why this, and why now? What would good look like for this organisation at the end of the work? What must we not assume?
Sometimes Lencioni’s pyramid fits almost exactly and accelerates honesty and can be useful. Sometimes it does not, when for example the presenting issue is constitution, capability, resource or a single unaddressed relationship. Sometimes the team is healthier than the system it is trapped in.
Where Lencioni does fit, GGi’s board and top team programmes tend to follow a simple arc. Find out. Define the end. Use the shared language of the five dysfunctions where it helps. Do the human work in the right order – trust and conflict norms before you demand commitment and accountability – while keeping results visible so the work does not become self-referential. Embed it in the real calendar of boards and executive meetings, not only in an off-site. Judge the programme by organisational effect: clearer decisions, better grip, less wasted leadership time, a group that can stand the next difficult season.
That is the sense in which we find the approach useful for navigating difficult times. It will not remove the stress. Nothing honest promises that. It can decide whether a leadership team spends that stress on itself or on the people the organisation exists to serve.
Happy boards are alike in ways Lencioni described with unusual clarity. Every board and top team in trouble is in trouble in its own way. Look first. Do not assume. Do not cut and paste interventions. Start with the end. Hold psychological safety and the Nolan Principles in the same hand. Then do the work in, order, as if the public outcome depended on whether this group can tell the truth and still decide.
It usually does.