State of Care: when the boundary becomes the problem

26 October 2026

The Care Quality Commission's State of Care report reveals a system in ‘flux and fracture’. Simon Hall explores its governance lessons and the questions boards should ask.

 

Points raised

- Moving services across boundaries can leave workforces without a champion.

- Markets left unshaped follow money, not people’s needs.

- Commissioning is a governance function, not just a management process.

- Who is accountable when people cross organisational boundaries?

 

The Care Quality Commission’s latest State of Care report uses the memorable phrase ‘flux and fracture’. It is an apt description of a health and care system in which some things are improving, but access, quality and outcomes still depend far too much on where people live and who they are.

The report contains plenty of sobering statistics. More than 80,000 children and young people have been waiting for over a year for community health services. The number waiting for a first contact with mental health services has risen by 31% in two years. Local authorities overspent their adult social care budgets by £715 million in 2025/26, the second successive year in which the overspend has approached three-quarters of a billion pounds.

The report is much more interesting than a catalogue of pressures, however. Its deeper message is about governance: how responsibilities are divided, how markets are shaped and what happens when organisations perform their allotted roles without anyone retaining a clear view of the person’s experience of the whole system.

Some boundaries have consequences

One striking example is the position of health visiting and school nursing. Demand for school nursing increased by 25% between 2021/22 and 2025/26, while staffing across school nursing fell by 30% between 2015/16 and 2025/26. Health-visiting referrals increased by 16% between 2021/22 and 2025/26, set against a 12% reduction in qualified health visitors. CQC warns that these pressures are weakening early identification and safeguarding at precisely the point when children’s needs are becoming more complex.

There is an important history here. The reforms that followed the Health and Social Care Act 2012 moved responsibility for commissioning school nursing from the NHS to local government in 2013, followed by health visiting in 2015, as part of the transfer of public health responsibilities. The workforce may still be employed by NHS organisations, while commissioning, funding and accountability sit elsewhere.

It would be too simple to suggest that the transfer alone caused the present workforce shortages. Local government funding, national workforce policy, provider capacity and changing levels of need all play their part. The pattern should nevertheless give boards a reason to pause and think. When responsibility for a service is moved across an organisational boundary, the workforce required to deliver it does not automatically acquire a new national champion.

This is a familiar governance risk. One organisation holds the budget, another employs the workforce, several depend on the service, and the consequences of failure emerge somewhere else. Health visiting and school nursing may then become everybody’s concern but nobody’s first call on resources.

For boards, the question should not simply be whether their own organisation is delivering what it has been contracted to provide. It is whether the commissioning and workforce arrangements taken together are capable of meeting need. Organisational assurance is not much consolation to children and families waiting more than a year for support.

The social care market is being shaped: just not necessarily on purpose

CQC’s analysis of adult social care is equally sobering. The care-home market is consolidating around fewer and larger homes, with increasing institutional investment. At the same time, homecare and other community provision are fragmenting among a growing number of smaller providers.

CQC describes this as a market changing shape ‘by accident rather than design’. That phrase deserves the attention of anyone interested in social care.

Markets providing essential public services are always shaped by something. If they are not being shaped deliberately through commissioning, long-term planning and engagement with communities, they will be shaped by financial pressure, workforce availability, property values and the commercial preferences of providers.

CQC reports that some providers are increasingly seeking people who can fund their own care because local-authority fees do not meet rising costs. In the south east of England, 47% of care-home residents are self-funders, compared with 24% in the north east. That is not simply a question of individual purchasing power. It affects where providers choose to operate, the services they offer and the choices available to people who depend on publicly funded care.

The NHS sees the real consequences of this every day. Gaps in social care contribute to delayed discharge, pressure on beds and longer waits for admission. Yet NHS boards can sometimes discuss social care as an external constraint: important, certainly, but belonging to somebody else. The report makes that position increasingly difficult to sustain. The NHS may not govern social care, but it cannot govern its own services effectively without understanding the condition of the social care market on which they depend.

A sensible board discussion about patient flow should therefore include more than the number of people waiting to leave hospital. It should consider local market capacity, provider fragility, workforce conditions, the availability of homecare and reablement, and the extent to which people are being placed away from their communities because suitable local provision does not exist.

Commissioning is a governance function

One of the most valuable features of the report is its insistence that commissioning still matters.

Commissioning seems to have acquired a rather unfashionable air. Structures change, organisations are renamed and enthusiasm moves on to collaboration, integration or neighbourhood working. The underlying task remains: understanding need, deciding what outcomes matter, allocating resources and shaping provision so that people can receive the right support.

CQC describes commissioning as one of the most powerful levers available to improve quality, equity and sustainability in adult social care. Its assessments found substantial variation. Better-performing councils aligned commissioning with prevention and workforce planning, engaged providers meaningfully and considered the interaction between publicly funded and self-funded markets. Weaker arrangements showed poor market shaping and provider engagement, with insufficient connection between commissioning, safeguarding and equity.

This is not simply a management process. It amounts to a governance agenda. Boards and governing bodies should be interested in the assumptions behind commissioning decisions, the outcomes being sought, whose voice has shaped them and how the consequences are evaluated. Contract monitoring tells us whether a provider has delivered what was purchased. Good commissioning asks whether the right thing was purchased in the first place.

Wigan shows that this is not inevitable

CQC’s example from Wigan is particularly useful because it makes the wider findings about commissioning and integration come alive.

CQC rated the council outstanding. It found deliberate work with residents, providers and health partners to understand need and shape local provision. An integrated front-door team brings together different professional perspectives and emphasises early intervention. Local provision has reduced reliance on placements outside the borough, while CQC reports that a jointly delivered reablement service means fewer people need ongoing support a year after leaving it.

There are structures in this story, naturally. The more important ingredients are consistent purpose, relationships, professional autonomy and the alignment of commissioning with prevention. The approach appears to connect strategy, resource allocation and frontline practice, which is much harder than producing an attractive partnership diagram.

Wigan also demonstrates that integration does not require responsibilities to become indistinguishable. Local government, health services, providers and communities retain different roles. What matters is whether those roles add up to a coherent experience for the person receiving support.

That is a useful test for any collaborative arrangement. The existence of a partnership board, provider collaborative or neighbourhood team tells us very little on its own. The interesting questions are whether decisions are made differently, resources move, provision changes and people experience better outcomes.

Assurance must follow the person

The report repeatedly shows how apparently separate pressures connect. Weak community provision increases crisis demand. Poor access to social care delays discharge. Declining health visiting and school nursing capacity weakens prevention and safeguarding. Inequalities become visible at different points in a pathway, even when no single organisation appears responsible for the whole result.

Traditional assurance tends to follow organisational accountability. Each board receives information about the services, workforce, finances and risks for which it is formally responsible. That remains necessary, but it is no longer sufficient.

Assurance must also follow the person through the system. That means understanding where people wait, where responsibility changes hands, where information is lost and where no organisation has both the authority and incentive to resolve the problem.

It also requires boards to pay attention to variation. An average can show overall improvement while concealing that particular communities are waiting longer or experiencing poorer outcomes. CQC’s findings on children, deprivation, severe mental illness and maternal safety underline why equity must form part of mainstream performance and quality assurance rather than sit in a separate report considered occasionally.

Questions for boards

So what might board members and trustees across health, local government, social care and the voluntary sector ask as they consider the report? Here are a few questions.

  • Which services and outcomes depend most heavily on organisations outside our direct control?
  • Where are commissioning, workforce and provider responsibilities divided, and who sees the combined risk?
  • Do our partnership arrangements change decisions and resources, or mainly provide additional meetings?
  • Do we understand the health of the provider markets on which our services depend?
  • Can our assurance show how access, experience and outcomes differ between communities?
  • When people cross organisational boundaries, who remains accountable for their overall experience?
  • Are we monitoring activity and contracts, or can we demonstrate that commissioning is producing better outcomes?

Good governance is often described in terms of clarity: clear roles, clear responsibilities and clear lines of accountability. State of Care reminds us that clarity within organisations can coexist with fragmentation across a system.

The central question is not whether every organisation can show that it has discharged its responsibilities. It is whether those responsibilities, taken together, produce care that makes sense to the people who rely on it. That may sound obvious; in governance terms, it is quite a challenge.

 

Reference and further reading:

Meet the author: Simon Hall

Principal consultant

Find out more

Prepared by GGI Development and Research LLP for the Good Governance Institute.

Enquire about this article

Enquire
Contact us