Pour encourager les autres

17 September 2026

Andrew Corbett-Nolan on Admiral Byng, the revolving door Wes Streeting wanted shut — and the other one nobody named

 

Points raised in this article

- In 1757 Britain shot an admiral “…to encourage the others”

- Streeting named the NHS's guilty secret: sacked, paid off, rehired

- The other revolving door nobody names removes the merely adequate

- Nine health secretaries in nine years – lecturing the NHS on tenure

 

On 14 March 1757, during a gale and a few minutes before noon, Admiral John Byng was shot on the quarterdeck of HMS Monarch in Portsmouth Harbour. 

The ship’s log gave it one line: “At 12 Mr Byng was shot dead by 6 Marines, and put into his coffin.” He had not been found cowardly. He had been found guilty of failing to “do his utmost” to relieve Minorca. The court recommended mercy. George II did not grant it. Voltaire’s verdict in Candide has outlived the battle: “In this country it is thought good to kill an admiral from time to time to encourage the others”.

Byng was not a great admiral; he was not a traitor either. The navy that sent him was late, under-manned and poorly fitted. The ministry that condemned him had left the island exposed. Shooting him did not put more ships in commission. It put a name on a failure so that the system did not have to wear it.

That is the Byng reaction. It remains the most tempting move in public service after a visible failure. An emergency meeting of the remuneration committee, a press release, the interim arrives and the feeling that grip has been shown. The wiring is untouched.

The door that should be shut

Wes Streeting, as Secretary of State for Health and Social Care, named one real problem and named it well. The “guilty secret of the NHS”, he told the Today programme in November 2024, was senior managers “managed out, given a payoff in one trust and then reincarnate in another.” He promised “no more rewards for failure.” 

In July 2025 he said regulation of managers would “slam the door in the face of unsuitable managers” and stop “the revolving door that allows managers sacked for misconduct or incompetence to be quietly moved to another well-paid role in another part of the NHS.” Silence a whistleblower, and you would never work in the NHS again.

That door should be shut. There are people who should not run be running an NHS organisation. There are boards that have moved a problem on rather than name it. There are payoffs that bought quiet instead of learning. If manager regulation can distinguish misconduct and serial incompetence from the ordinary difficulty of the job, it is a legitimate response to Mid Staffs, to governance failures in the shadow of Letby and to the quiet recycling of people already found wanting.

Streeting was right about that door, but he was not in post long enough to see whether the lock would work. He resigned in May 2026. The next health secretary will be the ninth in nine years. Ironic really, in the same article as the revolving door of NHS managers. The centre preaches tenure to the service and does not practise it.

The other door

There is a second revolving door. It is how the service usually uses Byng.

It is the performative moving on of people who were not incompetent, who had not silenced anyone and who had not been given the one resource complex change actually requires: time.

The recovery evidence from large, previously failing NHS organisations is consistent. First credible exit from special measures is typically two to four years. Time to embed sustainable change and a culture that does not bounce backwards is closer to a decade. There are also journeys that slipped after a first Good rating often had a change at the top before the job was finished. And in relation to the NHS 10 year plan there is still almost no published example of a large provider moving a material share of recurrent hospital money into community care inside a single planning cycle. If the political demand is a visible scalp every time a rating stalls or a winter is ugly, no one competent will stay long enough to do the unglamorous work of turning round complex public sector organisations.

So, the service now faces two opposite errors, dressed up as the same virtue of accountability.

One is recycling the unfit: Streeting’s door. People found wanting for misconduct or serial incompetence reappear elsewhere with a payoff and a new lanyard.

The other is sacrificing the adequate: the Byng door. People mid-recovery, or mid-redesign, are moved on because a minister, a regulator or a board needs to show grip. Nothing really changes and the clock is reset.

Why the two get confused

They get confused because both produce a vacancy and a sense that something has been done.

They get confused because the NHS rarely writes down why someone left. “Mutual agreement,” “new opportunity,” “to spend more time with the family,” and “the board has decided to seek fresh leadership” cover at least four different realities: the person was unsafe, the person was exhausted, the person was fine and the sponsor was bored, the person was the price of a new chair’s first hundred days – the list is endless. 

Without that distinction, regulation of managers will either be toothless or it will become a second Byng - a professionalised way of attaching a name to a complex system problem.

Whistleblowing makes the confusion worse. Some whistleblowers are the last line of patient safety. Some can be “weaponised.” A board that cannot tell the difference will either crush legitimate concern or let a small number of voices set the risk appetite of an entire regulator. That is not an argument for ignoring whistleblowers. It is an argument for adult investigation rather than reflex.

League tables and “zero tolerance” make it worse still. Consequences are healthy when they attach to the right issue. If the issue concerned is actually a two-year dip in a ten-year recovery, the wrong person will have been exited and this further reinforces every other chief executive to manage for the short term.

Five questions before a departure

Before a board, a region or a secretary of state reaches for an admiral to shoot, five questions are enough:

  • Is this really misconduct or incompetence that can be properly been evidence, or impatience with a timeline we privately know is longer than the political cycle?
  • Has this person been in post long enough for the change we say we want? If the honest answer is no, a departure is not grip. It is a reset of the clock
  • What, exactly, will be different on Monday that is not just a new name on the letterhead? If the answer is “energy” or “a fresh pair of eyes,” that is Byng
  • Are we about to recycle someone who has already failed elsewhere? If yes, Streeting’s door should stay shut.
  • Who benefits from this being a story about a person rather than the substantive issue in hand? If the ministry, the regulator or the local paper needs a name, suspect the system is using one.

The same test applies at the centre. Nine secretaries of state in nine years is also a revolving door. It is not called incompetence; it is called politics. The service notices the difference.

What accountability would actually look like

Streeting wanted to shut the door on managers who fail and reappear. He was right. However, the door that still swings is the one that removes people who have simply not been given time needed to see through complex change.

A scalp is not a diagnosis. First exit from special measures takes two to four years. A genuine recovery and a culture that does not bounce takes nearer ten. A secretary of state who lasts twenty months is in no position to call that slowness. Byng did not put more ships to sea. A new chief executive does not, by themselves, put more nurses on a night shift.

Regulation of managers is a good idea if it can tell misconduct from a mid-journey stumble. If it cannot, it will become a professional firing squad with a code of conduct.

The NHS will not get better at removing the wrong people until it also gets better at keeping the right ones long enough. Accountability that cannot tell a scapegoat from a failure is not accountability. It is theatre. Pour encourager les autres is a joke that stopped being funny in 1757.

 

Selected sources: contemporary Portsmouth letters and the Monarch log on Byng’s execution, 14 March 1757; Voltaire, Candide; Wes Streeting, BBC Radio 4 Today, November 2024, and DHSC statements on manager regulation, July 2025; CQC Driving Improvement (2017) and subsequent provider ratings; Yu et al., British Journal of General Practice, 2020, on Wolverhampton vertical integration

Prepared by GGI Development and Research LLP for the Good Governance Institute.

Enquire about this article

Enquire
Contact us