Minutes matter: why meeting records have never counted for more

20 October 2026

Peter Allanson explains how secretaries and chairs can make sure the record stands up to scrutiny in an age of inquiries and artificial intelligence.

 

Points raised:

- The Thirlwall inquiry shows how closely minutes may be scrutinised.

- Authenticated minutes carry real legal weight as evidence.

- Record decisions and the reasons behind them, not every word.

- Minutes drafted by artificial intelligence still need a secretary’s edit.

 

And so, while the great ones repair to their dinner
The secretary stays growing thinner and thinner
With racking their brains to record and report
What they think they will think that they ought to have thought!

- Anon WW2

 

In an age of crisis, anxiety, formal and informal review – not to mention the benefits of hindsight – the quintessence of the secretary’s art, writing good minutes, has never been more important. 

Being cited a number of times in the recent Thirlwall public inquiry into the events at the Countess of Chester Hospital 2015-2018 has shone a light into the significance and importance of minutes. 

Issues that turn into problems do not necessarily begin life as the big issues they become, so those recording the story must make sure that their approaches to minute writing are consistent, accurate and highly professional. 

This blog replaces the guidance we issued in 2020 and updated in 2022, though it contains much of the same advice. In the age of artificial intelligence, it is more relevant now than it was then.

Legal status

Firstly, a reminder of the legal status of minutes. For an ordinary UK company – and it should be assumed to apply to all corporate bodies – the principal legislation is the Companies Act 2006, section 248 of which says:

"Every company must cause minutes of all proceedings at meetings of its directors to be recorded."

They must be retained for at least ten years. Failure to comply is an offence by an officer in default. 

But the important provision is s.249. Where minutes have been recorded in accordance with s.248 and purport to have been authenticated by the chair of the meeting or the chair of the next directors' meeting, they are evidence of the proceedings at the meeting. More significantly, s.249(2) provides that, until the contrary is proved:

  • the meeting is deemed duly held and convened
  • the proceedings are deemed to have duly taken place
  • appointments made at the meeting are deemed valid. 

That is quite a strong statutory evidential presumption. So, minutes are not simply an aide-mémoire. There is an important distinction between "the secretary wrote down what happened" and "these are the company's minutes, authenticated by the chair". The latter have a specific statutory status, but they are not necessarily conclusive evidence of everything recorded in them. The wording ‘until the contrary is proved’ means they can be challenged with contrary evidence.

In other words, board minutes are the formal corporate record of the proceedings and decisions of the board. They are prepared by the company secretary and authenticated by the chair in accordance with the Companies Act 2006. Properly authenticated minutes have a statutory evidential status under section 249 of the Companies Act 2006.

The company secretary may have contemporaneous notes which they then use to assist in preparing accurate minutes. These should record the substance of the board's proceedings, including material matters considered, decisions reached, significant challenges or reservations, where relevant, and actions arising. 

They are not intended to constitute and should not try to mimic a verbatim transcript of the meeting. The point about the secretary’s notes is important – particularly their status. While they are not evidence in themselves, they may subsequently help to establish what took place. Once approved or authenticated, the minutes can be used evidentially under s.249 of the Act. 

While the secretary is responsible for producing an accurate record of what was decided (as opposed to what was said) and the chair is responsible for authenticating the corporate record, neither has the right to determine retrospectively what took place. The test is whether the minute fairly and accurately records the proceedings and decisions of the board.

How does the secretary fulfil this brief?

Minutes are a record of a meeting – and a meeting should always have a purpose. The board has a clear purpose and function; good minutes should support it in achieving them. Key elements of minutes which should always be included are:

  • actions agreed (what will be done)
  • action leads (who will do it)
  • deadline (when it will be done by)

Other useful information that it may be helpful to include in the minutes:

  • context for actions (why it was agreed the action will be done e.g., in response to a particular concern, or to achieve a particular outcome)
  • points of concern or discussion (e.g., ‘members asked why the issue had not been flagged sooner’, ‘members discussed whether further action was needed’ etc.)

What not to include:

  • unnecessary detail
  • repetition of information found in meeting reports, unless this provides context to the discussion.

How do I produce minutes as a minute-taker?

There are four key elements to producing a good-quality minute:

  • Preparation: Try to liaise with the meeting chair beforehand to understand their expectations. Read papers and previous minutes where available to help your understanding of what is likely to be discussed. Review previous actions. If the meeting is in person, sit next to the chair during the meeting so that you can discreetly clarify any key points if necessary. If you are minuting a hybrid or virtual meeting having an open communication channel with the chair can be useful – WhatsApp, for instance, or the meeting chat facility – but make sure you only addressing the chair and not the whole meeting.
  • Listen: Don’t aim to write down everything said. Listen to the discussion and then summarise the key points raised. Ensure you know who is saying what.
  • Record: Ensure you make a note of attendees and any apologies. Don’t expect to record everything, focus on key words and information, particularly around actions. If something is unclear and you cannot ask for clarification at the time, make a note to check the information later. Record items discussed in the order of the agenda, not the order of discussion if that is different (for example, if an item is brought forward for scheduling reasons).
  • Write up: Focus on clarity: would someone who did not attend the meeting understand what you’ve written? Prioritise actions. Check your work for errors, and/or get someone else to review it for you.

What can the chair do to help?

  • Make sure actions are clear. Summarise the proposed action verbally following board discussion to ensure members agree and outcomes are clear. Ensure that an action lead is identified and, where possible, agree a deadline.
  • Give your board secretary/minute-taker a clear steer on your expectations of the style of minute that should be provided. As they describe events that have taken place, minutes should always be written in the past tense. They should generally be unattributed; it should be clear who is introducing the subject and it is more helpful to describe them by title than name as this describes the authority they bring to the topic and will help anybody looking at minutes in the future to see that the chief finance officer introduced the subject rather than John Smith.
  • Minutes should describe what was decided – what the arguments were that led to the decision, including points of dissention where they are material to the decision, and then what actions should follow. 
  • The current trend of recording meetings and then asking AI to produce the minutes does only part of the job. The secretary’s role is to edit the AI derived minutes so that they achieve the same ends as being written from the outset by the secretary. Prolixity and unnecessary detail is not the friend of good, clear, professional governance.

Minutes, therefore, are important. They tell the story of the organisation in conjunction with the accompanying board paper. The presentation and slides are ephemeral – all that remains are what sit on the record. As is clear in this blog, these can be used in evidence and assume a status that may not have been envisaged when they were written. 

Most organisations, fortunately, do not have to face the consequences of their decisions in terms of life and death. But they may have to. So, the minutes could be the difference for directors and the organisations of being found to act criminally negligently and liable or being seen to act to the best of their ability and in good faith.

Meet the author: Peter Allanson

Principal consultant

Email: peter.allanson@good-governance.org.uk Find out more

Prepared by GGI Development and Research LLP for the Good Governance Institute.

Enquire about this article

Enquire
Contact us