Is your board governing, or just complying?
23 September 2026
Too many public-purpose boards let regulators set the terms of their governance, GGi's September webinar heard today. The alternative is to judge governance by what it achieves for the people organisations exist to serve.
Points raised:
- Has your board's governance been captured by the regulator?
- Regulators cannot give boards assurance, whatever they claim.
- Who is your board really accountable to?
- School governor training may hold lessons for other sectors.
Ask many public-purpose boards to describe their governance framework and they will describe the rules their regulator sets. That, said GGi's chief executive Professor Andrew Corbett-Nolan, is the problem. Opening GGi's September webinar on Wednesday, 23 September, he argued that too much governance has been ‘captured’ by regulators. Satisfying the regulator matters, but it is not the whole job, he said.
The session, chaired by GGi partner and principal consultant Aidan Rave, coincided with the launch of Ask GGi, GGi's free artificial intelligence platform, which draws only on a curated library of 10 million words of governance knowledge. Building the tool, Andrew said, had forced him to rethink what governance is for. His answer: governance should be purpose-driven and practical, aimed at "a fairer world, rather than a tidier paper trail".
From comply to apply
Andrew drew on the King reports, the South African work led by Judge Mervyn King since 1994 that has shaped governance codes worldwide and underpins GGi’s approach. Regulators' codes typically say comply or explain. King says understand your context and mission, apply the principles, then explain why they work.
King also tests governance by its outcomes: an ethical culture, performance and sustainable value creation, conformance and prudent control, and legitimacy in the eyes of stakeholders. And it asks boards to think about double materiality. Most governance looks outside-in, at how the world affects the organisation's risks and finances. Impact materiality looks inside-out, at how the organisation affects people, society and the environment, even before that shows up on the balance sheet.
That led to three uncomfortable questions. Has our governance been captured by the regulator, and how do we free it? Is everyone involved in our governance trying to achieve meaningful outcomes? And are we achieving double materiality, or doing governance for governance's sake?
Assurance, not reassurance
Participants took the challenge to heart. One said these were questions people should have been asking years ago. Another described regulated organisations where following the rules ate up time without producing any benefit.
The difference between assurance and reassurance ran through the discussion. One participant who had chaired a board out of special measures said it had failed precisely because it never understood that difference. Others argued that regulators cannot provide assurance, whatever they claim, and that doing so creates a misleading sense that all is well. The board, it was suggested, should see itself as the regulator of first resort, backed by frontline staff who fix problems where they arise.
There were lessons from other sectors. School governors described Ofsted's expectation of recorded governor training as a model others could learn from. Larger charities increasingly ask for evidence of impact, though smaller, volunteer-run charities often struggle with the basics. Andrew commended the Charity Commission's practical guidance to boards in any sector.
Who is the board really for?
Several contributors asked to whom boards are really accountable: the funder, the government, the patient or the local population? In social care, one asked, is the customer the person using the service or the council paying for it? Aidan recalled four years on an integrated care board where the word ‘patient’ only came up about six times. One participant argued that if boards get things right for the people they serve, everything else follows.
Curiosity came up too. Boards were urged to read other organisations' inquiry reports and ask what would stop the same thing happening here, rather than how to limit the reputational damage. One suggested looking at the hospital site map and asking when the board last heard about each department listed. Another worried that dashboards and summary statistics can smother curiosity altogether.
Andrew was sympathetic to regulators, calling them thoughtful people trapped in a short-term political system that "never gets away from the urgent to focus on the essential". The organisations in most trouble need the best boards, he added, yet are the hardest to recruit to, so the risk of joining must be made worth it.
Late questions opened new ground. Is double materiality really the same as the gap between reassurance and assurance? How should partnerships govern when one partner has a democratic mandate and the other works to tested evidence? One chat contribution offered a neat summary: compliance is static, while governance focused on outcomes is dynamic.
Andrew closed by noting that roughly half the UK economy is spent through public-purpose organisations. What their boards do, as their controlling minds and conscience, really matters.
Sign up for Ask GGi - it's free!
To download the slides Andrew used during today’s session, click below.