Breaking the cycle: what productivity tells us about governance

05 October 2026

The NHS Productivity Commission's final report argues that productivity is about turning resources into better outcomes, which makes it a governance question. Simon Hall explores what this means for boards across health and care, and why the Thirlwall Inquiry warns against simply cutting controls.

 

Points raised:

- Productivity means better outcomes, not more activity or effort.

- Accountability fails when responsibility is separated from real authority.

- Compliance is not assurance; simplification needs careful judgement.

- Freedom without capability doesn't empower people – it relocates risk.

 

The NHS Productivity Commission's final report, Breaking the cycle, contains an important message for anyone governing a health or care organisation. Productivity is not principally about making people work harder or producing more activity. It is about whether organisations and systems are set up to turn their available resources into better outcomes and experience.

That makes productivity a governance question.

The report's diagnosis will be familiar to leaders across health and care. Organisations are expected to deliver long-term transformation through annual budgets, short-term funding and changing priorities. They respond to a growing number of targets, returns and assurance requirements, but do not always possess the authority to change the pathways for which they are held accountable. Management, analytical, digital and improvement capability is stretched. New initiatives are launched more readily than older activity is stopped.

None of these problems is confined to NHS trusts. Hospices, charities, social enterprises, independent providers, local authorities and community organisations also operate through fragmented contracts, restricted funds and overlapping accountability. Many participate in partnerships that can discuss and coordinate but cannot always decide.

The Commission proposes four shifts: from constant churn to stable direction, from priority overload to focused accountability, from excessive compliance to freedom to deliver, and from episodic change to capability to improve. Taken together, these describe the foundations of more effective governance.

Start with outcomes rather than activity

The report defines productivity as better outcomes and patient experience from the resources available. Activity and cost still matter, but neither tells a board whether an organisation is creating value.

This is a useful challenge to board reporting. Packs can be full of information about contacts, attendances, staffing, finance and project milestones while remaining unclear about what has changed for patients, service users or communities. A productive board conversation starts with the outcome being sought and then traces the contribution made by services, people and resources.

The answer is not simply to discard process measures. Outcomes often emerge slowly and can be difficult to attribute. Boards need a clear chain connecting inputs, activity, experience, outcomes and equity. What matters is that activity is not mistaken for achievement.

Make accountability intelligible

One of the report's strongest observations is that the NHS is highly controlled but insufficiently accountable. Local leaders may face extensive oversight while lacking meaningful freedom over money, workforce, assets or pathways.

Accountability works when it connects a clear result with someone who has the authority, resources and information to influence it. Where those elements are separated, adding another committee or performance return will not solve the problem.

Every health and care partnership should therefore be able to answer some basic questions. What can be decided here? What remains reserved to the participating organisations? Who controls the relevant resources? Who owns each risk? What happens when partners disagree? How does each board obtain assurance about activity delivered through others?

Without clear answers, shared accountability can become diluted accountability.

Distinguish assurance from compliance

The report calls for a substantial reduction in duplicative or disproportionate regulation, reporting and approval processes. That recommendation needs care. Important safeguards often exist because people have previously been harmed. Simplification cannot mean weakening the organisation's ability to detect and act on risk.

But the accumulation of policies, reports and controls does not automatically produce safety. Compliance establishes whether a required process has been followed. Assurance should help a board understand whether objectives are being achieved, risks controlled and lessons acted upon. The former may support the latter, but they are not the same.

The Thirlwall Inquiry makes this distinction uncomfortably concrete. Countess of Chester Hospital had policies, committees, risk processes, mortality reviews and external inspection. Yet the arrangements did not bring together the emerging signals, ensure that clinical concerns were treated as potential safeguarding intelligence or escalate the neonatal deaths to the board. The inquiry described the board's lack of information about the deaths as a serious governance failure.

Read alongside Breaking the cycle, the lesson is not that every control should be retained. It is that simplification requires judgement. Thirlwall recommends board-level monitoring of deaths, safeguarding training for board members and immediate action when good-faith concerns about deliberate harm are raised. These are targeted safeguards with a clear purpose. Boards should remove reporting that duplicates or obscures, while strengthening the routes by which weak signals, difficult concerns and unwelcome evidence reach those able to act.

Boards should periodically ask which information changes decisions, where reports duplicate one another and which controls reveal conditions at the frontline. They should also ask what remains invisible. A shorter board pack is not necessarily a better one; a more purposeful and connected pack often is.

Treat capability as part of care

The Commission is unusually clear about the importance of management, operational, analytical, digital and commercial capability. These roles are often classified collectively as overhead, even though improvement depends upon them.

This matters wherever organisations are being asked to do more through collaboration and delegation. Freedom without capability does not empower; it relocates risk. A board should know whether people have the skills, information, time and authority to act on the responsibilities given to them.

Not every organisation needs to employ every specialist. Capability can be shared across a group, partnership or system. But shared capability still requires clear access, priorities and accountability. A partnership analytics team that is technically impressive but disconnected from operational and board decisions will add less value than expected.

Govern learning, not just delivery

The report also challenges the health service's fondness for pilots. Too many are launched locally, evaluated inconsistently and then allowed either to disappear quietly or continue without clear evidence of benefit.

Its alternative is a test-and-learn discipline much on the lines of good QI: agree the hypothesis and outcomes, establish safe parameters, use common measures and make explicit decisions to stop, adapt or scale. Failure within agreed boundaries can generate valuable learning. Repeating activity without learning cannot.

This is particularly relevant to technology and AI. The accompanying technology paper argues that the main constraint is often not the availability of technology but the ability to implement it, redesign pathways, support adoption and realise benefits. Board scrutiny should therefore extend beyond procurement and go-live dates. It should include clinical safety, workforce impact, inclusion, patient experience, decommissioning and evidence that benefits have actually been achieved.

Look beyond the organisation

Perhaps the hardest governance lesson concerns stewardship across systems. Productivity is lost when each organisation optimises its own position while costs, delays or risks move elsewhere in the pathway.

Boards cannot abandon their duties to the organisations they govern. They can, however, make the wider consequences of decisions visible. They can ask whether a saving depends on an unfunded burden being absorbed by primary care, social care, a charity, families or another provider. They can insist that collaborative decisions address resources and risk, rather than relying on goodwill.

For public-purpose organisations, this is also a question of legitimacy. Patients, service users, staff and communities should help shape the outcomes sought and the trade-offs involved before decisions are made, not simply be consulted on a preferred solution afterwards.

A more demanding form of governance

The message of Breaking the cycle is not that governance should step back. It is that governance should become more purposeful.

Boards need to be clearer about outcomes, more disciplined about priorities, more deliberate about delegation and more curious about whether assurance processes reveal reality. They need to protect the capability and headroom required for improvement, tolerate responsible experimentation and be willing to stop work that no longer creates sufficient value.

Thirlwall is the necessary caution against treating this as a simple call for fewer controls. Some safeguards need to be strengthened; others can be simplified or removed. The work of governance is to know the difference, and to test whether the arrangements reveal reality when the evidence is incomplete and uncomfortable.

That applies across the NHS and the wider health and care sector. The decisive question is not how much governance an organisation has. It is whether its governance enables people to make sound decisions, learn and convert scarce resources into better care.

 

References

  • NHS Productivity Commission's final report, Breaking the cycle: how to build a more productive NHS, published in September 2026. 
  • Two accompanying policy options papers are also relevant: Transformation and NHS productivity and Technology, innovation and NHS productivity. The article also draws on the summary report and recommendations of the Thirlwall Inquiry, published in September 2026.

Meet the author: Simon Hall

Principal consultant

Find out more

Prepared by GGI Development and Research LLP for the Good Governance Institute.

Enquire about this article

Enquire
Contact us