Board meetings in public: getting it right
23 September 2026
Some public bodies must hold board meetings in public by law, while others have little or no such duty. GGi principal consultant Peter Allanson sets out the legal position across the UK, explains how private sessions and committee reporting should work and offers practical questions directors can use to test their own arrangements.
Points raised:
- Know which openness duties apply – they vary sharply by sector.
- Streaming alone may not satisfy the legal duty of openness.
- Private sessions need clear criteria and a public record.
- Does your committee reporting show the public the real work?
Boards of public bodies operate under a set of openness duties that are both clearer and more variable than many directors realise.
Some organisations, notably local authorities and most NHS bodies, face strong statutory requirements to hold key decision-making meetings in public. Others, including universities and many arm’s-length bodies, have far weaker or no equivalent legal duty, even though they remain subject to Freedom of Information and publication-scheme obligations. The result is a landscape in which practice differs sharply and in which boards can easily become either overly casual or unnecessarily uncertain.
To help directors understand their obligations, this article sets out the legal foundations across the United Kingdom, explains the important distinctions that matter in day-to-day board work, examines the particular rules that apply to NHS organisations (including a notable rule about the composition of ICB committees), and offers practical guidance on the management of private or ‘in camera’ sessions.
It also explores how the work of board committees should be reported into public board meetings, draws on cautionary examples and provides concrete questions directors can use to assure themselves that their organisation is meeting both the letter and the spirit of the legislation.
Legal foundations and territorial coverage
In England, Wales and Scotland the principal statute is the Public Bodies (Admission to Meetings) Act 1960. It requires that meetings of bodies to which the Act applies, when those bodies are exercising public functions, shall be open to the public. A body may, by resolution, exclude the public from the whole or part of a meeting whenever publicity would be prejudicial to the public interest by reason of the confidential nature of the business or for other special reasons stated in the resolution. The Schedule to the Act lists the bodies covered. This has been updated over time and includes various local authority bodies and, through later legislation and orders, many NHS organisations.
Local authorities are subject to additional, more detailed rules. In England the Local Government Act 1972 Part VA (inserted by the Local Government (Access to Information) Act 1985) and the Local Authorities (Executive Arrangements) (Meetings and Access to Information) (England) Regulations 2012 create a strong presumption that meetings of principal councils, their committees and executive decision-making bodies will be open to the public. Exclusion is permitted only on tightly defined grounds of confidential or exempt information, and there are detailed requirements about notice, agendas, reports and the publication of minutes (including a summary of any private proceedings that does not disclose exempt information).
Wales operates under a closely related framework within the same 1972 Act, with some specific electronic notice provisions. Scotland has parallel provisions in the Local Government (Scotland) Act 1973. Northern Ireland has its own regime under the Local Government Act (Northern Ireland) 1972; the 1960 Act does not extend there.
The 1960 Act therefore provides a baseline for many bodies exercising public functions, while local government legislation supplies a denser and more prescriptive set of rules for councils and their executives. Boards need to know which regime applies to them.
Sector variation
Local authorities face the strongest and most detailed statutory openness duties. Fire and rescue authorities and many policing bodies (Police and Crime Commissioners, related panels and joint boards) are generally caught by the 1960 Act or by local-government-style provisions and commonly hold meetings in public.
NHS bodies (NHS trusts, NHS foundation trusts and integrated care boards) are routinely expected to hold board meetings in public. The legal basis is primarily the 1960 Act as applied to these organisations, reinforced by constitutions, standing orders and NHS England guidance. Practice is well established: a public session (often called Part I) followed by a private session (Part II) for confidential items.
Universities and higher education institutions present a sharp contrast. They are public authorities for Freedom of Information purposes and must maintain publication schemes that typically cover agendas and minutes under the ‘how we make decisions’ class. There is, however, no general statutory duty to hold governing-body meetings in public. Most do not. Non-departmental public bodies and other arm’s-length organisations are equally variable. Only those listed in the Schedule to the 1960 Act or caught by specific establishing legislation have a clear statutory duty. Many cultural, regulatory or advisory bodies operate largely in private, publishing selected minutes under their publication schemes.
The practical consequence is that boards cannot simply assume the rules that apply to an NHS trust or a local authority apply to them. They must identify the precise legal basis for their own organisation.
NHS committees composed of board members – an important distinction
The legal position on when a committee of a public body must meet in public is more nuanced than is sometimes assumed, and it differs slightly between integrated care boards and other NHS bodies.
The Public Bodies (Admission to Meetings) Act 1960 Section 2(1) of the Act applies the openness duty to any committee of a body to which the Act applies ‘whose members consist of or include all members of the body’. In other words, the statutory trigger is a committee whose membership is the full board (or includes every board member). A committee made up of only some board members, even if every one of those members is a board member, does not automatically fall within section 2(1).
The Act also closes the old loophole of a body resolving itself into a ‘committee of the whole’ or ‘board in committee’ to exclude the public. Section 1(6) provides that when a body resolves itself into committee, the proceedings in committee are still treated as part of the body’s meeting and remain subject to the openness rules. The only lawful route to a private session is a proper resolution under section 1(2) citing the confidential nature of the business or other special reasons.
Integrated care board constitutions, following the NHS England model, use a wider formulation. The standard wording is that all meetings of the board, and all meetings of committees that are comprised of entirely board members or which include all board members, at which public functions are exercised, will be open to the public (unless a proper exclusion resolution is passed).
This is broader than the pure 1960 Act wording. On a literal reading it would catch any committee whose membership consists solely of board members, even if that committee does not include the full board.
In practice, however, NHS England guidance and the great majority of ICB constitutions make clear that there is no expectation that audit or remuneration committees are held in public. Many constitutions expressly state that these two committees shall not be held in public. Boards should therefore treat the wider ICB constitutional wording as applying principally to any other committee that is made up entirely of board members, while recognising the accepted exception for audit and remuneration committees.
Other NHS bodies
NHS trusts are generally subject to the 1960 Act and therefore to the narrower statutory test (committees that include all board members). NHS foundation trusts are not formally listed in the same way under the 1960 Act. Their constitutions are required to provide that board meetings are held in public, but the treatment of committees is a matter for their own standing orders and constitutions. In both cases, audit and remuneration committees are almost universally held in private, and this is accepted practice.
Practical implications
- A committee that includes all board members (or, in the case of an ICB, is composed entirely of board members) will normally need to meet in public unless a proper exclusion resolution is passed.
- Audit and remuneration committees, even though composed entirely of board members (usually NEDs only), are not expected to meet in public.
- The ‘board in committee’ or ‘committee of the whole’ device does not provide a lawful route to privacy for bodies covered by the 1960 Act.
- Regardless of whether a committee itself meets in public, its work should still be reported into the public board meeting in a way that gives a fair and sufficient account of the issues considered, the assurance obtained and any matters escalated.
Directors should check their organisation’s own constitution or standing orders carefully. For ICBs the wider ‘entirely of board members’ formulation will usually be present; for other NHS bodies the narrower 1960 Act test is more likely to apply. In all cases the accepted position of audit and remuneration committees should be reflected clearly in terms of reference and public reporting arrangements.
Meeting held in public versus public meeting
Language matters. A meeting held in public (or ‘meeting in public’) is a formal meeting of the board or committee that members of the public may attend to observe. Observers have no right to speak, ask questions or otherwise participate. The meeting remains the board’s meeting. A public meeting, by contrast, is one designed to allow public participation, for example for NHS foundation trusts an annual members’ meeting or certain sessions with the council of governors.
Many chairs of board meetings held in public nevertheless include a short, discretionary slot for questions from the public, often limited to agenda items and sometimes requiring advance submission. This is good practice and enhances transparency, but it is not a legal right that flows automatically from the meeting being held in public. It remains at the chair’s discretion and can be managed to protect the orderly conduct of business. Standing orders and public communications should make the distinction clear.
Physical attendance and streaming
The original language of the 1960 Act and the Local Government Act 1972 contemplates physical presence. Temporary COVID-era regulations expanded the definition of ‘open to the public’ to include remote access by video conference, live webcast or interactive streaming, and provided that a meeting accessible by remote means was open whether physical attendance was possible or not. Those temporary provisions have largely expired for England.
The High Court confirmed the continuing force of the physical-access requirement in Hertfordshire County Council & Ors v Secretary of State for Housing, Communities and Local Government [2021] EWHC 1145 (Admin). The Court held that the statutory requirement for a meeting under the 1972 Act to be ‘open to the public’ or ‘held in public’ means members of the public must be admitted in person to the place where the meeting is being held. Live streaming alone does not satisfy the requirement, although authorities remain free (and are often well-advised) to stream meetings for wider access. Wales has more permissive permanent multi-location arrangements under the Local Government and Elections (Wales) Act 2021.
For NHS bodies and others under the 1960 Act the position is less sharply litigated, but pure streaming without any physical option carries residual legal risk in England. Hybrid arrangements (a physical venue (even if capacity is limited and registration is required) plus a live stream) remain the most robust approach. Notice should clearly state how the public can access the meeting.
Managing private sessions
Private or ‘in camera’ sessions are legitimate. Commercial negotiations – perhaps including highly sensitive ‘blue sky’ strategy discussions, identifiable personal data – including senior HR matters, live legal advice and certain sensitive operational matters often require confidentiality. The existence of a private session does not, however, remove the organisation from the reach of openness duties or publication-scheme expectations.
Good practice requires:
- written criteria, known to the board, that define when an item may properly be taken in private; vague or expansive criteria tend to expand over time
- a clear public record that a private session occurred, the broad nature of the business (without disclosing exempt detail), the decision reached where it is not itself exempt, and the exemption or reason relied upon
- a full private minute for the organisation’s own record and for any later FOI request or regulatory review;
- periodic review of the volume and nature of private business; a rising proportion of private items, or the regular appearance of routine strategy or performance matters in private session, is a warning sign – why can’t this matter be discussed in public?
Local authorities have a statutory duty to produce a summary of private proceedings that does not disclose exempt information. Many NHS bodies now publish a standing public agenda item (a chair’s or company secretary’s report on matters considered in private sessions) listing topics and high-level rationales. This is a practical way of demonstrating that private business is being kept under control and that the public record of decision-making remains coherent.
Board seminars and development sessions raise a related issue. These are often treated as informal and left without any proper record. When significant board-level deliberation occurs outside the formal, minuted meetings, the public (and internal) record of ‘how we make decisions’ becomes incomplete. A short factual note of attendance, topics and any emerging conclusions or actions is good practice, even if the session itself is developmental.
Reporting board committee discussions into the public board meeting
A frequent weak point in practice is the way the work of board committees is brought back into the public board meeting. Committees exist to provide detailed scrutiny, assurance and, in some cases, delegated decision-making. If their deliberations and conclusions remain largely invisible in the public record, the board’s own public meeting loses much of its value as an account of how the organisation is governed.
Good practice is for each committee that reports to the board to produce a clear, structured highlight or assurance report for the public board agenda. That report should normally cover:
- the key items considered since the last report
- any decisions taken under delegated authority (or recommendations made to the board)
- significant risks, issues or exceptions escalated to the board
- areas where the committee is seeking further assurance or where progress is off-track
- any matters that were considered in private committee session, summarised at an appropriate level of generality.
The report should be written so that an informed member of the public can understand the substance of the committee’s work without needing access to the full private papers. It is not enough for the board simply to ‘note’ a set of committee minutes that remain unpublished or heavily redacted. The public board meeting is the place where the cumulative work of the committees becomes visible and where the unitary board demonstrates collective ownership of the issues.
Where a committee itself meets in public (or is required to do so because of its membership), the link is more straightforward: the public minutes of the committee can be received, and the chair can highlight the most important points. Where the committee meets largely or wholly in private, the quality of the public summary report becomes critical.
Boards should resist the temptation to treat committee reporting as a purely internal assurance process. The public board agenda is the principal vehicle through which the organisation shows that detailed scrutiny is occurring and that the board is sighted on the resulting issues.
Directors should periodically ask whether the committee reports appearing in the public papers give a fair and sufficient account of the real work being done. If the public board meeting consists largely of noting private committee activity with little substantive discussion, the openness arrangements are more formal than real.
Cautionary examples
The consequences of getting this wrong can be severe, particularly under pressure.
In June 2017, two weeks after the Grenfell Tower fire, the Cabinet of the Royal Borough of Kensington and Chelsea attempted to hold its first meeting on the disaster entirely in private, citing security and public safety concerns. Media organisations obtained an emergency High Court order requiring the admission of journalists. The meeting then began but was adjourned after only a short time on the basis that an open discussion would prejudice the forthcoming public inquiry. The episode was widely described as a fiasco. Downing Street publicly rebuked the council. Opposition councillors and the Mayor of London were scathing. The attempt to exclude the press and public, followed by the abrupt abandonment of the meeting once access was forced, compounded an already acute crisis of trust. It remains a stark illustration of how poorly prepared openness arrangements can themselves become the story.
The Hertfordshire High Court ruling confirms that, for meetings required to be open under the 1972 Act, physical admission remains the legal baseline in England. Streaming is valuable but not a substitute.
The Mid Staffordshire inquiries provide the most powerful longer-term cautionary tale. The board was found to have operated with a closed culture; meetings were frequently held in private; quality, complaints and clinical governance were not given the visibility they required. The decision, on achieving foundation trust status, to hold more meetings in private was explicitly criticised as contrary to the intention of the legislation. Secrecy and inward-looking governance were linked to the board’s failure to see or act on catastrophic standards of care.
These examples show that problems arise both from dramatic mishandling under crisis conditions and from gradual, unexamined drift toward excessive private business or opaque committee reporting.
Practical prompts for board members
Directors can usefully test their organisation’s arrangements with the following questions:
- Which of our meetings (board and committees) are subject to the Public Bodies (Admission to Meetings) Act 1960 or the equivalent local-government access-to-information rules in our nation? Have we mapped this clearly, including any composition-based rules such as those applying to certain ICB committees?
- When we resolve to exclude the public, do we record a clear resolution that states both the confidential nature of the business (or other special reason) and, where required, a meaningful description of the item? Is that resolution visible in the public record?
- Do our public minutes or a standing public report provide a short, factual summary of private-session business (topics considered and the reason for privacy) without disclosing exempt detail? Is this done consistently?
- For meetings required to be held in public, do we provide a genuine facility for physical attendance (even if capacity is limited and registration is required), or are we relying solely on streaming? Given the Hertfordshire ruling, is our current approach legally robust?
- How do we distinguish, in standing orders and public communications, between a ‘meeting held in public’ (observe only) and a ‘public meeting’ (participation invited)? When we offer a questions slot, is it clear that this is discretionary?
- Are agendas, papers and minutes for meetings held in public published in good time, and are private papers handled with clear, consistent redaction criteria that the board understands?
- Has the volume and nature of private business been reviewed recently? Is routine strategy or performance material drifting into private session without strong justification? Have we asked ourselves why any particular matter should not be discussed in public?
- Do the reports from our board committees that appear on the public board agenda give a fair and sufficient account of the work done, the issues escalated and the assurance obtained? Or is significant committee activity effectively invisible to the public record?
- Do board seminars and development sessions generate any formal record of attendance, topics and outcomes? If not, is that a conscious policy choice or an oversight?
- Has an internal audit or any other independent review ever examined the operation of the public/private boundary, the quality of public summaries, and the visibility of committee work in the public board papers?
- Does our assurance framework or audit committee programme include periodic assurance on openness arrangements?
Conclusion
Openness about how public functions are exercised is not a technical side-issue. For many public bodies it is a statutory duty; for all of them it is a practical test of transparency culture, record-keeping discipline and board grip. The legal frameworks differ across the four nations and across sectors, but the underlying expectation is consistent: organisations should be able to show that the meetings at which significant decisions are taken are properly open where the law requires it, that private sessions are tightly justified and properly recorded, that the work of committees is visible in the public board record, and that the overall account of decision-making remains coherent and defensible.
Boards that treat these arrangements as a living commitment – regularly reviewed, clearly documented and actively assured – strengthen both external accountability and internal effectiveness. Those that allow private business to expand by default, or that allow committee work to remain largely opaque in the public papers, or that improvise under pressure, risk the kind of public damage illustrated by Kensington and Chelsea and the deeper cultural failures identified at Mid Staffordshire.
Getting the balance right between legitimate confidentiality and necessary openness is a core board responsibility. The questions set out above provide a practical starting point for directors who want to be confident that their organisation is meeting both the letter and the spirit of the law.