Beyond the diagnosis: governance lessons from the Fonagy review

19 October 2026

At nearly 600 pages, the Fonagy review is about far more than mental health, autism and ADHD services. Simon Hall argues that its sharpest lessons are for boards in every sector.

 

Points raised:

- Diagnosis has become the passport to help across services.

- Boards’ own policies and thresholds can drive rising demand.

- Prevention needs named responsibilities, not just shared aspiration.

- Boards should measure people’s progress, not just activity.

 

The Fonagy review is not short. At nearly 600 pages, it is unlikely to be mistaken for a quick read before the next board meeting. It is, however, fascinating – and its implications go well beyond mental health, autism and ADHD services.

The review was asked to examine why demand for diagnosis and support has risen so significantly and what should be done about it. Its conclusions are careful. Mental distress has increased, particularly among children and young people. Recorded diagnoses of autism and ADHD have risen sharply, although this does not necessarily mean that the underlying prevalence of these conditions has increased at the same rate. Diagnosis can be enormously valuable, while not always providing a reliable guide to the nature or level of support somebody needs.

It would be easy to become absorbed in the argument about whether there is too much diagnosis or too little. The report is much more interesting than that.

What it describes is a system that has gradually made diagnosis the passport to help. Health services, schools, universities, employers and the benefits system may all require a recognised label before making adjustments or offering support. 

Meanwhile, the organisations responsible for different parts of the pathway operate their own eligibility criteria, waiting lists, contracts and performance measures.

Each part of the system may be following its own rules perfectly conscientiously. The problem is that nobody appears to be governing the experience of the person moving between them.

When diagnosis has two jobs

A good assessment can help people understand their experiences, secure appropriate treatment and gain access to support. For many people, a diagnosis is life-changing. Over time, however, diagnosis has acquired a second job. It has also become a way of rationing services and determining eligibility.

That creates some fairly obvious incentives. People and families pursue a diagnosis because it may be the only available route to help. Schools and other organisations refer people onwards because their own ability to offer support is constrained. Specialist services receive increasing numbers of referrals, including some people who undoubtedly need help but may not require a highly specialised clinical assessment.

Those with the most substantial needs then wait in the same growing queue as everyone else. Eventually, the queue starts to become the service.

This is an important governance lesson. Boards tend to scrutinise demand, activity and waiting times as though they were forces of nature. Fonagy invites them to look more closely at how their own policies, thresholds, contracts and funding decisions may be contributing to that demand.

If an organisation requires a diagnosis before making a relatively straightforward adjustment, it should not be surprised when requests for diagnosis increase. If support disappears when somebody falls below one service threshold, people will understandably look for another route into the system.

So, the useful question for a board is not simply: “How are we managing the waiting list?” It is also: “What have we made people wait for – and why?”

People have needs; organisations have pathways

People do not generally experience their lives as a collection of neatly separated conditions. Mental distress, difficulties at school, insecure housing, unemployment, family pressures, autism, ADHD and physical ill health frequently overlap.

Services remain largely organised into categories.

The review describes people being passed between mental health and neurodevelopmental services, between children’s and adult services, and between health, education and social care. Individuals whose circumstances do not fit neatly within one pathway can find that every service regards another part of the system as the more appropriate place for them.

We often describe this as fragmentation, as though it were an unfortunate weather condition. In fact, fragmentation is the cumulative result of governance decisions. It reflects how budgets are allocated, contracts are written, professional responsibilities are defined, information is held and performance is assessed.

The usual response is to create another partnership arrangement. Sadly, there is rarely a problem in public services for which somebody cannot propose a new board, forum or steering group!

These arrangements may be useful, of course, although bringing people together around a table does not in itself integrate anything. Services only become more joined up when people have the authority, information and resources to make decisions across the boundaries that created the problem.

The review’s proposed ‘no wrong front door’ approach is therefore more demanding than it sounds. It requires organisations to accept some responsibility for helping a person reach the right support, even when they do not provide that support themselves.

That raises some important questions. Who is responsible when somebody is passed from one service to another? Can staff secure help without sending the person back to the beginning of the referral process? Can resources follow need across organisational boundaries? Does anybody monitor how often people are redirected, rejected or simply lost between pathways?

A pathway diagram is not evidence that a pathway is working.

Seeing the whole provider landscape

One of the most striking developments examined by the review is the growth of independent provision in autism and ADHD assessment. Independent providers now undertake a substantial proportion of NHS-funded assessments, while commissioning, regulatory and information arrangements have not always developed at the same pace.

This is not an argument against independent provision. Independent, voluntary and social-enterprise providers can bring additional capacity, expertise and innovation. The governance question is whether commissioners and boards have retained sight of the whole pathway.

An assessment is not an isolated transaction. Its quality affects treatment, prescribing, educational support and the person’s understanding of their own needs. Somebody must remain responsible for continuing care, for responding when a diagnosis is uncertain and for ensuring that the individual is not discharged back into another queue.

The government has already accepted the need to strengthen regulation, including bringing all autism and ADHD diagnostic assessments within the scope of CQC regulation. That is welcome. Regulation, however, cannot substitute for active commissioning and effective board assurance.

Boards need to understand who is providing services on their behalf, how quality is assessed, what happens after diagnosis and whether the apparent expansion of capacity has actually improved outcomes.

This is not only an NHS issue. Local authorities, schools, universities, charities, social enterprises and other public-purpose organisations increasingly rely on networks of partner and external providers. The organisation delivering the activity may change. Accountability for the consequences does not disappear quite so conveniently.

Are we measuring activity or progress?

The report repeatedly returns to functioning, wellbeing and participation. Can people remain in education? Can they work, sustain relationships and participate in community life? Do they receive useful support while waiting? Has intervention made a meaningful difference?

These are rather harder questions than counting referrals, assessments and diagnoses. They also expose the limitations of many board reports.

Activity measures are attractive because they are available, comparable and apparently objective. They can tell a board whether more assessments have been completed or whether a waiting list has grown. On their own, they cannot show whether the right people received the right help or whether anybody’s life improved.

A system can become more productive on its own terms while becoming less useful to the people it exists to serve.

Fonagy therefore presents a challenge to conventional assurance. Boards need information which follows people across organisational and professional boundaries. They need to know not just how many people entered each service, but what happened to them afterwards. They should be able to see whether particular communities are less likely to gain access, more likely to be redirected or more likely to wait without support.

The answer is probably not another dozen indicators squeezed onto an already crowded dashboard. It is to be clearer about the outcomes the organisation exists to achieve and then select information which helps the board judge whether those outcomes are being realised.

Prevention: everybody’s priority and nobody’s budget

The report’s account of rising mental distress extends far beyond clinical services. It points to financial insecurity, poor housing, disrupted education, social media, loneliness, sleep and reduced feelings of connection and belonging.

None of these can be resolved by mental health services alone.

Prevention is regularly embraced in strategies. It is rather less securely represented in budgets and accountability arrangements. The costs of preventive action may fall to one organisation, while the benefits appear years later or emerge in somebody else’s accounts. Faced with an immediate operational pressure and a distant potential benefit, most systems behave fairly predictably.

The review’s emphasis on neighbourhood multidisciplinary support is therefore important. Neighbourhood working will only make a difference, however, if the organisations involved can share information, deploy resources flexibly and make collective decisions. A multidisciplinary meeting is not necessarily a multidisciplinary service.

This is relevant to NHS bodies, councils, schools, universities, housing organisations, charities, social enterprises and employers. Each holds part of the picture and can influence the conditions in which people either flourish or struggle.

The governance task is to convert a general commitment to prevention into identifiable responsibilities. What contribution is each organisation expected to make? What resources will it commit? Which outcomes are shared? How will the partners know whether collective action is working? What happens when organisational priorities conflict?

Without answers to those questions, prevention risks remaining everybody’s aspiration and nobody’s job.

Questions for boards

So, what might board members and trustees ask as they consider the implications of the review? Here are a few questions to consider.

  • Are we organising support around people’s needs, or around the services we already happen to provide?
  • Have any of our policies made diagnosis an unnecessary gateway to help?
  • Can we see the whole experience of people moving through the pathway, including services delivered by other organisations?
  • Who is accountable when people are passed between services or do not meet anybody’s threshold?
  • Do our contracts and payment arrangements reward assessment activity or meaningful outcomes?
  • What useful support is available while people wait?
  • Are our waiting-list controls sensitive to risk, impairment and changing need, rather than simply time waited?
  • Can we demonstrate the quality and consequences of work undertaken by independent providers?
  • Do our measures tell us whether people are participating more fully in education, employment and community life?
  • Have our partnership arrangements been given real authority, or have we simply created more meetings?

These are not questions solely for organisations providing clinical care. Any organisation whose decisions affect access, participation or wellbeing has a place in the wider system: whether or not it has yet noticed.

A final thought

The Fonagy review will inevitably be drawn into debate about whether there is too much diagnosis or too little. Its conclusions deserve better than that.

It describes a system in which genuine and growing need coexists with long waits, uncertain thresholds, fragmented accountability and strong incentives to pursue a diagnostic label. Specialist services are overwhelmed, while many forms of useful earlier support remain difficult to obtain without specialist involvement.

The answer is not to diminish the value of diagnosis or weaken access to specialist care. It is to stop asking diagnosis to perform every function in the system.

Good governance begins with purpose and with the experience of the people an organisation exists to serve. It looks across boundaries, follows the consequences of decisions and pays particular attention to the spaces between formally accountable bodies.

Perhaps the simplest test is this: if somebody needs a map, a diagnosis and exceptional persistence to obtain fairly basic help, is their complexity really the problem?

Organisations may be separately managed, funded and regulated. People experience one system. Governance needs to start behaving as though that is true.

Meet the author: Simon Hall

Principal consultant

Find out more

Prepared by GGI Development and Research LLP for the Good Governance Institute.

Enquire about this article

Enquire
Contact us